GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

merit pay

As evaluations impasse grinds on, a new way to reward teachers

BigAppleNew178

The Department of Education’s new awards program will recognize ten top teachers this spring.

New York City might not have a new teacher evaluation system yet, but new efforts are underway nonetheless to reward the city’s best teachers.

The Department of Education announced today the creation of the “Big Apple Awards” program to identify and honor teachers who make an “exceptional impact” on student performance. Ten teachers will win cash prizes and classroom grants when the winners are announced in June.

In a statement today, Chancellor Dennis Walcott encouraged parents, administrators, students, educators, and community members to nominate teachers. Teachers can also nominate themselves. Top nominees will be invited to submit formal applications, and department officials will visit the finalists’ classrooms before selecting the winners.

The new model of rewarding a small number of teachers based on community nominations is a far cry from the merit pay system the Bloomberg administration had hoped to be implementing by now. Last year, Mayor Bloomberg proposed giving raises to teachers who posted two straight years of top ratings on a new evaluation system based on student progress and principal observations. But the city and teachers union have not yet agreed to adopt such a system, and the teachers union has also said that even when an evaluation system does go into effect, it would not agree to raises based on ratings.

According to Connie Pankratz, a department spokeswoman, funding for the new prizes will come from private donors, and the size of the grants has not yet been determined.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tommy-Calderon/100000263260717 Tommy Calderon

    Yes, by all means, I would like to be judged by the most incompetent and corrupt educational administration in the history of New York City.
    The best reward and biggest motivator that Bloomberg and Walcott could give New York City’s teachers would be to disappear tomorrow.

  • MrKotter

    This has nothing to do with rewarding teachers. Rather, it is a cheap publicity stunt. There is a section of Eric Schlosser’s book Fast Food Nation that focuses on inexpensive strategies that fast food franchises use to motivate employees to perform. One is to hold contests not terribly different from this one. The idea is to cheaply motivate a whole bunch of employees for a prize that is attractive but few can win. Or the contests used to motivate young children to sell candy to win prizes like, say an IPOD for selling a zillion boxes. This is how highly DOE and the Mayor think of teachers.

  • philip nobile

    ATRs screwed again! Surely we’ll be ineligible for prizes no matter how good we are at passing out sub work to strange students every day. Where’s our incentive? But I’m all for a Whistleblower Prize for teachers including ATRs and ACRs who report common core corruptions. they also see every day in high schools–like take-home tests that count as in-class tests, failed tests handed back for open-book corrections, final exams spread over two days without the slightest security allowing students to look up answers overnight, etc. Anything to squeeze out a 65 to meet the your principal’s pass rate quota, or else you’re ineffective, a taker, and you’re cooked with no help from the Unity gang. …

  • disqus_2xWNJN5E5m

    10 out 0f 80,000 Wow !

  • http://www.facebook.com/omarlopezedm Omar Lopez

    It seems that Bloomberg’s merit pay system would have gone over better, according to the comments here. The biggest criticism is that this program does not go far enough.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

1 comment so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031