GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

nail in the coffin

Calling it a night, city and union say their eval talks are over

Michael Mulgrew has left UFT headquarters at 52 Broadway and a union official confirmed that any chance that a deal could be salvaged in the final hours tonight are “dead.”

And the other side also appears to have thrown in the towel. A spokeswoman for the Department of Education said they “called the UFT a couple of hours ago and tried one last time with a proposal and they rejected it.” She did not say what the specifics of that proposal were.

Micah Lasher, a former aide to Mayor Bloomberg who lobbied hard for the evaluations, was optimistic that a deal could happen earlier in the day, even after the city and the union exchanged blows. But his mood had soured in a statement released late tonight.

“Today is a sad day for New York City’s 1.1 million schoolchildren, who will lose out because the adults couldn’t stop fighting and get their acts together,” Lasher said.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo has insisted that he will not amend a law that he wrote into last year’s budget, which gives education funding only to districts that submit and implement evaluation plans this year. The deadline for both is midnight.

“Please hear me – there will be no extensions or exceptions,” Cuomo said of the few districts that had not submitted plans to the state ahead of midnight.

For New York City, that means that it will not receive $250 million in aid, money that city officials said would result in midyear cuts and could affect school funding for school staff, technology and after school and arts programs.

The absence of an evaluation means that the city will also not be able to claim up to another $200 million in state and federal grant money.

“We don’t have an exact timeframe but it has to happen soon,” Chief Academic Officer Shael Polakow-Suransky said of the cuts.

 

  • Diego3

    What this proves is that Mulgrew is an inadequate leader. He has now put the entire UFT at risk. Mulgrew has let down multitudes of educators who feared no evaluation system and would continue to rise up to face all that Bloomberg brings. Where’s the kind of leadership that came with the likes of a Randi Weingarten when you need her?

  • Kev

    you can’t be serious in saying Randi is a good leader. please.

  • Clay

    What this proves is that Mulgrew stood firm, held his ground, and showed his effective leadership. He put the needs of students and educators first and opened himself up to personal endless attacks from our spiteful bully mayor and his wealthy friends.

    Diego3, what have you been smoking?

    Mulgrew’s actions today show his commitment and integrity. All those that said that the fix was in, all those AstroTurf reform groups, all those lying Tweed lackies should be called on it and questioned the next time they disparage Michael Mulgrew.

  • Insiderknowledge

    Are you serious?  There is no negotiating with bloomturd. Every plan that’s not what he wants is stupid.  It’s been reported that 90% of the districts had a sunset clause in it. What’s Bloomturd’s response to the UFT’s 2 year proposal? That it would be ridiculous…You can’t negotiate with someone like that..Walk away and deal with the next guy. 250 million is about 1% of the budget.  It’s worth every penny if it means he doesn’t get his way.

  • Josh

    This is also black eye for the Governor, and a blow to Merryl Tisch – who publicly and confidently predicted a deal, and to John King who was clearly part of the talks and whose Stare Ed Dept. may lose a big part of their Race to the Top dollars.

  • Tall Paul

    Great job by Mulgrew. Tonight he stands tall with the great Albert Shanker.

  • Guest

    First of all, I am thrilled that what ever the deal was, it ain’t happening.  Mulgrew would’ve made a deal but Bloomberg was his usually big baby self.  The only thing I’m thrilled to hear there was a sunset clause-so things could have been adjusted, changed, etc….

    Second of all, Randi sold us out again and again.

    I have been a delegate under them both and i trust neither, but Randi is a true snake in the grass.

  • Schoolgal

    These talks should never have come to the table.  But Mulgrew’s lack of leadership was evident when he endorsed a horrible VAM deal with the governor last year.  Those who read the fine print know what I mean.  Buffalo teachers who will be evaluated on truant students know what I mean.   NYSUT did not stand by their teachers when they allowed VAM to be the judge and jury if 2 years in a row the VAM scores are low.  That makes VAM worth 100% of the eval after the 2nd year!!!  Mulgrew by agreeing to even 20% of junk science did not stand by his teachers.  

    Those who know Julie, or have seen her debates on TV know she will be a formidable leader.  She fought charter co-locations when Mulgrew and Randi welcomed them.  She doesn’t believe Pearson should be certifying teachers, but Mulgrew welcomed that too.  She doesn’t believe a student’s worth is judged by high-stakes testing, yet those from the UFT have written some nasty articles about Carol Burris, the principal who circulated the petition to Cuomo against high-stakes testing.  Now why would any union leader not support that petition.  Petitions like that are circulating all over the country.  Even the state of Texas (where this whole thing started) have school boards that are up in arms over the amount of tests.   Parents are fighting this.  Shouldn’t the teachers be standing with them??

  • GUEST

    Of course it’s better late than never but Mulgrew has allowed Bloomberg (and before him Randi) to destroy the school system, to destroy the union, to destroy the job protectins that people worked hard to protect.  And of course, as it always is, when some bureaucrat wants something done, invariably iut’”s for the children or so they say as the teachers are forcfed to take step after step down the plank till they fall in.

    Of course teachers have always een evaluation, and very well thank you as I can say as a retrired high school techer   I had an Assistant Principal who was an expert on education in my field who worked with me from the time I came into the system showing me the ins and outs of teaching my subject.  Not some generalist like so many of the so called Principals who after two or three years on the job were adjudged by this sick system to e ready to help improve instruction and properly evaluate teachers  These small schools have destroy the essence of what a secondary school was supposed to be with a myriad of activities for students to pursue, with arge departments of expderienced techers in various disciplies, with subject area specialists in each discipline and with Principas who took 10 years as a teacher frollowed by 5 years as an Assistant Principal before assuming the awesome responsiblities of being a true Principal.  Not the Johnny come latelys being pushed first by Klein, then by Black (remember her) andnow head lackey Walcvott along with his cadre of deputy chancellors who go around destroying schools.;

    And if yu listen to the Supreme Leader, the system is riddled with hundreds of incompetent teachers and that is the key problem in educatin in New York City today.  Please.  It’s about time, after allowing Bloomberg to destroy the school system that Mulgrew for once in his life time stood up to Bloomberg.  I, frankly, am shocked that he did but sometimes it takes a while to realize you are being led astray.  Tell Mr. Bloomberg to f*** off.  All he wanted, berfore we rid ourselves of him and the rest ofg the incompdetents down at Tweed, was to be able to say he fired thousands of bad teachers.  Too bad Michael.  When you leave, hopefully for a normal human being, thenm perhaps the kids of this city will have their educational opportunities restored to them.  Until then, the Kleins, Blacks and Walcotts of the world demonstrate just how far this school system has been destroyed.

  • Jdbalthazar

    I’m proud of Mulgrew! We can’t give anymore and his deal was more than generous, 2 years until a through review, when most others gave it one year. Bloomberg would rather kill the baby, than strike a compromise.

  • Betty

    I can’t believe that I am writing these words, but: MIKE MULGREW IS A HERO!

  • GUest

    $250 million is a drop in the bucket compared to the cuts this mayor has imposed on the classroom in recent years.  The fact is that if this money came it would just have been squirreled to some private consultant that would have created more nonsense paperwork off some cheap gimmick acronym and charge the city a boatload.

  • Larry Littlefield

    “$250 million is a drop in the bucket compared to the cuts this mayor has imposed on the classroom in recent years.”
    Despite large increases in education funding and cutbacks in administration, to pay for retirement increases including one that (for some reason) he signed off on.  I wouldn’t say the Mayor imposed the cutbacks.  I’d say that everyone who matters was in favor of the shift in where the money went — the Mayor, the state legislature, and most importantly (the winner!) the UFT.

    Meanwhile, Bill Thompson just said that if elected he will not raise taxes.  That BS.  The next Mayor will raise taxes, just as Bloomberg has over and over.  And the cuts the classroom will continue.

    The $250 million means that some of the cuts might happen now instead of being dumped on the next Mayor.  And I’d agree that any evaluation plan agreed to under these circumstances would have been an administrative mess.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Ah, Thompson also said he would add more cops.  The number of police officers in NYC has falling from 3 times the U.S. average relative to population in recent years to 2 1/2 times.  Like spending in the classroom, the number of police officers will need to go down.

  • celt

    School districts across the country are complaining about the costs of implementing a new evaluation system. A lot of the $ that were “lost” would have been spent (money is fungible) on counsultants, training, test design for non-Regents courses, and the like. Why worry about losing $ that would largely be spent on an evaluation system that is unfair and inaccurate?

  • Lynn3265

    Its amazing that the press will not highlight the fact that 90 percent of school districts that reached a teacher evaluation agreement agreed with a 1 YEAR SUNSET.  LET ME SAY THAT AGAIN, MOST DISTRICTS IN NEW YORK (90 PERCENT) SUBMITTED AGREEMENTS WITH A 1 YEAR SUNSET!!!!  THE UFT OFFERED BLOOMDOE A 2 YEAR SUNSET THAT HE TURNED DOWN….Bloombird, please just give up…Read the blogs mayor, most new yorkers hate you and disagree with just about everything you say and do.  

  • Geraldine_maione

    If the COMMON MAN’S PRESIDENT DID NOT STAND STRONG FOR OUR CHILDREN, WHO WOULD? If not NOW, WHEN?

  • The One

    I finally feel that the UFT is working for the teachers, it is unfortunate to lose the funding but it is worth taking a stand. Let us all remember that it is not about the children but about the supersize ego of Bloomberg. He is not ready to admit that he failed at controlling the DOE.

  • reality

    No business budgets on “maybe” money. There should be no need for further cuts especially since over half the money was for consultants and admin costs of implementation

  • reality

    All the other districts combined serve fewer students than NYC

  • East Sider

    Will the school system face midyear layoffs?  Will the elimination of “Last In. First Out” Seniority Law also re-emerge?

  • Mince

    hey terd, learn the facts

  • Nyr68

    what does that have to do with the price of bananas genius

  • Principal

    I’m demoralized as this will likely mean the loss of our Title I school’s extended day program, funded by federal grants that will now be lost because of failure to strike a deal.  That grant also funds critical professional development.  Anything would be better than the U/S system, which makes baseline competence (the standard for an S) the highest bar formally expected or recognized. 

  • Queens CL

    Leadership Academy graduate?….how many years did you work in the classroom before you became a principal?…if it is less than 10 years please don’t even reply to the post

  • Queens CL

    being quiet would serve you well here

  • Janitor

    principal my azzz  jack

  • Janitor

    east sider my azzzz get real east sider move back to the south where you came from and do not forget to go to the dentist

  • http://twitter.com/BNiche B

    Reading through the history to try and find that answer (10 years, I believe, as a principal)), this person also heavily praises Klein (despite potentially cutting funding for principals years back), E4E, and also changed the name (Nicole/Ruth) a few times. Very bizarre. 

  • T5yuir

    I cannot even get magic markers for my whiteboard  and you talk about professional development. What nonsense.

  • citymama

    What does that have to do with anything?

  • Janitor

    if your a principal i am i dream of Jeannie astronaut 

  • deuceman99

    if you are a teacher and have half a brain you will be glad there was no deal. its all about being able to get rid of teachers because as usual they are the scapegoat. god forbid the blame is put where it belongs: on the horrible uneducated parents. and i laugh when people say they should take a parenting class. if u need a class then u have no business being a parent. its not like taking a math class. everything isnt solved by taking a class. stop blaming teachers for the failure of the education system. you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make him drink it.

  • Evelyn

    your demoralized!!!! people reading these blogs PLEASE NOTE:…These are the kind of principals the schools now have….. I’ve met some principals in schools and i really thought when i originally met them that they were paras or some teaching asst….(really, im not trying to be wise here….i cannot believe what i am seeing.  Then, she said to me I am the principal……I said oh sh** really???….

  • Sci Teach

    Evelyn, you should have written “you are demoralized.” 

  • Senior Teacher

    The money goes to the DOE and it is then ‘filtered’ to the schools.  We would never see any of it!

  • Guest

    Just a quick glance at your rudimentary writing (“your demoralized”), and your vulgarity (“oh sh**”), reveals exactly what you are: unpolished and unacceptable. Do you seek to judge others? Do you think you can easily generalize principals? You met principals who you believed were paraprofessionals or teaching assistants? What does that imply–about principals? Or paras? Or teaching assistants? You must be something special. Your weak attempts to pose derogatory comments about principals speak volumes about the kind of leadership that you possess.

  • wise owl

    Good that there are principals on here and I hope mine is one of them. It’s unfortunate that I have to go under disguise in order to get things out into the open. I would be “unsatisfactory or “ineffective” if I said it to your face. I could not sit down and have this conversation, I would be retaliated against. I’m tired of the blatant favoritism that goes on. I’m tired of the witch hunts that you do on a daily basis.  I understand that you have a”quota” of negative observations/ratings to make, and the reasons that teachers get a U that have nothing to even do with teaching. I know that there are teachers in the school who are your pets and don’t even get observed. There is always money available “according to the person”. Let the layoffs begin and I hope that you have to take over my classes. There is a lot more that I could say.  Bloomberg wants to run a school like he does a business? In business when you tell an employee to do something he does it. It doesn’t work that way with children. Children don’t always listen in case you don’t know.  I write the truth and when you write the truth you aren’t thinking about the mechanics of writing. I  do not want to get replies/advice on how to write. This comes from my heart. You hurt me

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

3 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031