GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

he said he said

Bloomberg blames UFT for killing deal with 2015 sunset demand

Mayor Bloomberg blamed new and unacceptable demands by the UFT for ending the possibility of an agreement on teacher evaluations.

During a hastily convened press conference about the collapse of teacher evaluation talks, Mayor Mike Bloomberg rejected the teachers union’s account that he had “torpedoed” a deal.

It was the union’s insertion of new demands at the last moment, including that the evaluation system would expire in 2015, that made an agreement impossible, Bloomberg said.

“If the agreement sunset in two years the whole thing would be a joke,” he said. “Nobody would ever be able to be removed. The law would be gone before the process could finish. It would essentially sabotage the entire agreement.”

The vast majority of evaluation plans — about 90 percent —  that districts across the state have adopted are in effect only for this school year.

“Those deals are shams,” Bloomberg said when asked about them.

Flanked by Chancellor Dennis Walcott and two deputy chancellors who had headed negotiations, Bloomberg said the union also demanded additional arbitration for teachers who want to appeal their ratings and a change to the way evaluations are scored “in a way that would have ensured that fewer teachers were rated ineffective.”

Bloomberg said the latest demands undermined an agreement that was close to complete. “There was an agreement to be had here. We were actually very close,” he said. “But unfortunately, every time we approached a deal in recent days, the UFT moved the finish line back.”

Department of Education officials said the call for a 2015 sunset came around 12:30 a.m. today, and talks finished at about 3:30 a.m. without a deal in place. UFT President Michael Mulgrew had said department and union negotiators had agreed on a deal overnight but Bloomberg rejected it this morning.

Without an evaluation system in place, the city is set to lose $250 million in state aid, per Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s mandate. Bloomberg said today that “it’s much too early to tell” whether the loss would require teacher layoffs, but he said the Department of Education would bear the brunt of budget cuts.

“I’m always the eternal optimistic but right now things look bleak,” Walcott said.

  • Former Turnaround Teacher

    I am sure the mainstream media will take Bloomberg’s side on this, but I really don’t see how a deal sunsetting in 2015 is unreasonable.  If we are rated on the evaulation this year, and the next two, they certainly could fire teachers under this.  And agreeing to anything longer would be foolish, since most of the ideas have not actually been implemented yet and there will certainly be tons of issues.

    Either way, I really could care less who the media blames, I will sleep easier knowing that for at least one more year, I won’t be rated based on “junk science.”

  • Bob Schwartz

    I have to be fair, I have killed Mulgrew for bowing down and kissing the mayor’s ring finger, but he showed me that he is for his members today.  Mulgrew is right.  Parents have seen this week that the mayor’s arrogance has caused a school bus strike.  This mayor cannot leave office quick enough, but for today, kudos Mike Mulgrew!  Hopefully, the ghost of Randi Weingarten’s bs is gone from the UFT.

  • Koozy14

    ““Those deals are shams,” Bloomberg said when asked about them.”  I wonder how Cuomo and the rest of the state feel about that….

  • Jane G.

    I gotta say: THANK YOU MR. MULGREW! I honestly did not think you had it in you to pull this off. Wait it out till the next mayor comes along. However, the rank and file would like to know what the agreement in principal looked like that caused Bloomberg to walk away from.

  • http://www.accountabletalk.com/ Mr. A. Talk

    So we gave Mayor4Life TWICE as long a deal as other districts, and that still wasn’t enough for him. He’s a stubborn ass, but in this case I am glad because this awful deal is dead.

  • wise owl

    THROW YOUR HANDS IN THE AIR AND MAKE LIKE YOU JUST DON”T CARE!  Everybody sing and start dancing to the beat!  Have a glass of wine. That’s what I just did! Glad to see that Mulgrew finally have some balls. I was beginning to wonder. There was no such money. That was all bullshit. Bloomberg is a “dollar and cents” man and thinks that anyone can be bought. People are still waiting for Sandy relief money that was promised also. He wanted the veteran teachers to be pushed out? That’s exactly what is going to happen to him. He won’t be able to last to next year. He will need to save face from the public. I just watched the news and he looked like he was going to boil over. Now we need to figure out what his next move on the “checkerboard” is going to be.

  • Asdf

    Bloomberg…why are you so desperately looking for ways to fire teachers? Don’t you have anything else to do with your time?

  • wise owl

    Aw my heart is so broken over this!

  • Jdbalthazar

    I still believe there’s a deal and this is just a game…I’ll be over joyed a day or two from now when I am sure. But still, the highlight of Mulgrews tenure

  • http://twitter.com/SoBronxSchool Bronx Teacher

    With all due apologies to the sad and recent demise of Conrad Bain, “What are you talking about, Mr Drummond?” This is the first I ever heard of this…. “The vast majority of evaluation plans — about 90 percent —  that districts across the state have adopted are in effect only for this school year.” Great reporting (really no sarcasm!) Philisa! Nice to see how wedded Governor Andy is to his plan.

  • Guest

     

    Mayor’s Last Minute Move Undermines Principal Evaluation Agreement 

    CSA President Ernest Logan sent the following email message to members this afternoon.
     
    Dear Colleagues,

    After
    six weeks of negotiations with the DOE on a principal evaluation system
    — with the understanding that this would be a one-year plan — the CSA
    and the DOE were closing in on a final agreement on January 16, just
    before midnight. However, moments later, the Mayor intervened, demanding
    an agreement for an indefinite period of time. It is important to know
    that the overwhelming majority of school systems throughout the state
    have reached a one-year agreement in order to evaluate and modify it
    later to better serve our children. The state law provides for a
    one-year evaluation plan and the mayor supported the enactment of this
    legislation.

    We
    resumed talks with the DOE at 11:00 a.m. today in hopes that we could
    still reach an agreement.  The mayor remained intransigent about his new
    demand and it became impossible to reach a resolution.

    Above
    all, we regret that New York City public school students will suffer
    the loss of a quarter of a billion dollars of state aid.  We stand ready
    to resume these negotiations.

    Sincerely,

    Ernest Logan

  • http://twitter.com/SoBronxSchool Bronx Teacher

     Must be nice to hide behind the wall of anonymity.

  • Nina

    Bloomberg is licking his lips right now. What does this lead to? Teacher layoffs, major budget cuts, removal of special Ed programs, cuts in art, music, and theater programs, cuts in the number of AP classes… And the list goes on and on! You name it! Bloomberg hates public education in NYC and it’s sad because our educational system is really f*cked up, but this makes it worse. NYC schools are all a pile of crap, and if you don’t think they will target your school eventually, ha! Think again. No one’s safe.

  • Li educator

    More money for my district!

  • old unionist

    So who are we supposed to believe Mulgrew and CSA president Ernest Logan or mayor Bloomberg? The real sham your honor is your education policies, the illegal third term, your corrupt outsourced over priced consultants, or the city time,911 scandals all part of your administration. The media will harp on the 250 million, not a drop in the bucket when compared to the Blomberg education budget of more than 20 billion, not too much of a hit when teacher and student integrity are at stake. Kudos to the UFT for saying no to the mayor and his underhanded negotiating tactics. By the way, will anyone point out that the mayor has been at the center of the bus strike and evaluation negotiations and both have turned out bad for the city and the schools.  Are we to believe that both union leaderships are failing to compromise. The mayors legacy is in deep doo doo.

  • Former Turnaround Teacher

    It is important to note that Bloomberg also refused to sign off to the deal between CSA and the DOE.  It certainly makes his claim that the UFT walked away seem much less likely.  The CSA and UFT rarely seem eye to eye, and the fact that Bloomberg blew both of these deals shows how incompetent he really is.

  • wise owl

    Let’s hear it for our very “ineffective” mayor!!

  • Danielson Who???

    Ummmmm, guess you can throw that Danielson crap out the window Huhh???

  • Gladys4

    You sound scared and pathetic. Crawl back in your studio apartment and look at old pics of your x-wife.

  • Guest

    Anyone else see the arrogance when he called all the other agreement reached shams? Shouldn’t all those districts be screaming loudly? His insulting demeanor is just too much to take…

  • Jane G.

    Hey Nina. You really don’t have a clue. The money “lost” was the equivalent of 1% of the DOE budget. There will be no layoffs, no removal of special ed programs, or cuts to art, music, etc. Maybe Bloombucks will cut one of his multi-million dollar contracts with one of his ed-deformer corporate buddies. 

  • me

    Bloomberg is a prime example of what happens when you let a billionaire make decisions for the people.  Does anyone else feel like a serf in the lords manor?

  • Nycdoenuts

    Lol, yeah. But for the fact that NO ONE reads those old newspapers anymore!!

  • Jkuwolsky

    What a stand by the STRONGEST UNION IN THE UNITED STATES!! Bloomberg looks REALLY BAD and should now be viewed as a LAME DUCK!!

  • Clay

    Well said!

    There should be no doubt about Bloomberg’s education legacy.

  • Nycteacher

    I don’t know why Bloomberg just doesn’t fire all us teachers. We’re such a pain and he definitely could educate 700k students better than any of us. If anything, he could probably hire a few 20 year old interns to do it too, I mean, it’s so easy — just teach them a few things and they do everything else.

  • Punchinthenose

    MICHAEL MULGREW FOR MAYOR!!!!!!!!!
    YAY!!!!!
    President, Oh my president…
    Take that Mayor Doodie Bomb!

  • wise owl

     You took the words out of my mouth. And according to the mayor, checking off boxes on a Danielson checklist constitutes an administrator doing an observation .

  • Allycat

    Say it with  me, ” NO DEAL IS A DAMN GOOD DEAL”.

  • Larry Littlefield

    The legacy is the 25/55 deal and its cost.  Will anything else remain?  I don’t think so.

    I’ll say it again, the next Mayor should refuse to accept a continuation of Mayoral control.  He or she would just end up taking the blame for a very bad deal for city residents, city children, and younger teachers.

  • Bronxeducator

    The way you post is borderline offensive. Please stop w/the random caps & kooky sarcasm. Plus, maybe I’m old fashioned, but I feel like when educators curse it makes us all look less intelligent.

  • Stop discrimination

    ExpandTweed has no clue of what they are doing, sending leadership principals to destroy schools like Ms. Dwarka of W.C. Bryant High School, rating veteran teachers u who are satisfactory while using the Danielson Model to rate the teachers when the UFT has not agreed to this model. They want a new evaluation system to make it easier to fire veteran teachers and replace them by younger teachers, get rid of experienced teachers since they are expensive. it is called discrimination.

  • wise owl

     I write how I want to write. I speak the truth and I tell it like it is. Please don’t tell me how to write.  Go grade your essays. I’m a science teacher.

  • Insiderknowledge

    Keep up the fight Mulgrew!! Don’t give another inch to this tiny despot.

  • TTorana1

    I would pay heavy $$$ to see Mulgrew and Suransky go at it. Mulgrew would be the favorite. Suransky would be handicapped at about 50-1.

  • Coacheagle22

    Why do you feel that the Danielson Model is crap?

  • Reformer

    The swearing and name calling, combined with no real sophisticated thought or analysis of the situation is really quite embarrassing. Honestly, the number of typos, grammatical errors, and general lack of ability to articulate a complex thought on these boards makes me really believe that we need a faster and more streamlined system for firing teachers. It is actually quite scary to think that people referring to the Mayor as “Bloomturd” actually have responsibility for the education of our children. I already know the facts, I only come to GothamSchools to read the comments of the inane “science teachers” such as yourself. They are quite entertaining and reinforce the stereotype that your union is there to protect teachers that do more harm than good.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

1 comment so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031