GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Competitive advantage

Cuomo floats competitive grants to urge more learning time

The state will underwrite costs for schools that keep students in class an extra 300 hours per year, according to a top proposal floated today in Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s third “State of the State” address.

Extended learning time was one of several proposals Cuomo mentioned during the education section of his speech, which lasted more than an hour and covered a variety of non-education issues, including a strict ban on assault weapons, decriminalization of small amounts of marijuana, raising the minimum wage and a new plan to build casinos in upstate New York (the revenue of which will mostly go toward state school aid).

The proposals were part of a “more and better” approach to education reform that Cuomo is crafting for 2013, a year after he targeted education “lobbyists” and school bureaucratic inefficiencies. Cuomo said he also wants to invest in expanding early education programs and creating schools that provide health and social services for poor communities.

Cuomo is making the funds available in the form of competitive grants, which he has used in the past in an attempt to fast-track education reforms. The grants would only be eligible to districts and schools that craft plans that adhere to best practices prescribed by Cuomo.

The previous grants have encountered resistance, both from union officials, the Board of Regents and State Education Commissioner John King. They all agreed that a $250 million mini-Race to the Top grant would be be better used if it were redistributed into the state’s general school aid formula.

Update: Officials from the state education department did not respond to requests for comment. New York State United Teachers President Dick Ianuzzu and United Federation of Teachers President Michael Mulgrew praised the proposals.

“We … applaud Gov. Cuomo for proposing a way for school districts to increase learning time for students through a creative grant program, one that districts could use to restore their enrichment programs in music and the arts,” Mulgrew said in an emailed statement.

For the second straight year, Cuomo also touted the importance of boosting and rewarding teacher quality. He proposed a plan to give accomplished “master teachers” $60,000 bonuses over four years to train other teachers. Cuomo said he’d seek to replicate the model used by the New York City-based Math for America,  a fellowship organization that boast 380 math teacher fellows.

All of the education proposals were previewed last week, when an education reform commission that Cuomo convened last year released a preliminary round of recommendations. Cuomo touched on all of the recommendations in today’s speech.

It was the extended learning time proposal that Cuomo headlined with his education speech. The proposal was based on a Massachusetts initiative that added 300 instructional hours to 19 schools since 2006. Students from those schools who participated in the initiative saw their math scores spike 20 percent and their English scores  increase by 8 percent.

In New York City, which extended its 6.5-hour day by an additional 37.5 minutes on most days for many students, schools have for years been able to extend and rearrange their day if teachers agreed to do so.  Brooklyn’s Generation School added an extra 20 days to its school year by staggering work schedules and vacation periods so that no teachers work more than the legally-required minimum of 180 days. Another school, Washington Heights Expeditionary Learning School, voted to extend school periods to 65 minutes and eliminate the five minute hallway break between periods.

Cuomo’s proposal will reward schools that submit similarly-creative plans, which are designed to minimize costs. Cuomo did not mention how much it would cost, but the extended learning initiative in Massachusetts costs the state about $1,300 per student per year, 7.5 percent of the average per pupil cost, according to National Center on Time and Learning, which oversees the initiative.

Chris Gabrieli, chairman of NCTL, said most schools with extended learning models “found their own way to doing this” and applauded the top-down policy directive that Cuomo was putting forward.

Cuomo gave himself a pat on the back for creating a law that tied state funding to districts that hammered out deals on evaluation plans before a Jan. 17 deadline. New York City, which has 40 percent of the state’s 2.7 million public school student, is among the nine districts out of 700 that hasn’t submitted a plan. Without mentioning New York City’s absence, Cuomo declared the funding incentive “a success story,” as getting districts to come to a deal.

FINAL 2013 State of the State

the

  • Lorna D.

    Hey Mulgrew: We don’t want to work a single minute more that we already do. We got sold out for working the extra 37.5 minutes as a “raise” a while back. If you even think about agreeing with the the DOE in applying for this grant money, you better remember that the rank and file WILL have a chance to vote on this as it is a contract change, plain and simple. Don’t think for a second that you can sign off on this in a back door deal. 

  • Hhhyyhhh

    God forbid you work an 8 hour day like most people!! Can you imagine, some people actually work 12-16 hours a day to put food on the table. How dare they!!

  • Lorna D.

    God forbid that you have to be bitten, spit on, verbally abused daily, or have your personal belongings stolen by the people that you serve. The teachers of NYC work their collective asses of each and every day. We are required to earn a masters degree and most teachers have to perform countless hours of paperwork on their “own” time. Oh yeah, I wonder when the last time you were able to go 4 hours without a chance to take a whizz. 

  • Dample

    You really have no idea how much unpaid hours goes into planning and grading.

  • anonymous

    Hey Hhhyyhhh,

    As a matter of fact I Do work MORE than 12-16 hours a day but I don’t get paid for it I get to school  at 7:30 AM and stay till 6pm.The excessive paperwork doesn’t stop. There is no goddamn end to it!  Then I  finally go home and finish up what I couldn’t finish at school. Makes no difference whether I left at 3. So I would be doing the paperwork at home. When YOU work 12-16 hours a day you get PAID for it, right?  Do you take money out of your pocket for supplies? What job do you know where people  take money out of their pocket for supplies? Half the time the copy machine doesn’t work and I have to go someplace outside of school and of course on my own time and pay for it! Then you go home and your day is OVER. Time for your/family whatever. People have told me more than once don’t take the job home with you well I have to because there is NOT enough time during the day to do all that Bloomberg wants. My nights and weekends and breaks are consumed with paperwork, phone calls etc. I’m not eating right or taking care of myself for my goddamn job Why don’t you try this “life”sometime? Try not having a life and keep sacrificing for your job and then your reward is a U! And as far as the summer? That’s time that’s “stolen” from me all year without pay. Finally have time to go to a doctor etc. I am exhausted and stressed out and sick of hearing this bullshit about teachers getting out at 3 and having all this time off.

  • Andrew, you really get me

    “…a historic step forward in making New York a national leader on educator accountability.” 
    So inspirational, Andrew. Can’t wait to tell my daughter tomorrow. We test her daily. I think she is really developing a love of accountability. 

    The two year old isn’t getting it yet. We are recording poops in the potty, numbers of blocks needed to build a tower, what percentage of the paper he uses when drawing. Other suggestions are welcome. 

  • User4

    thanks to giving more time for learning knowledge skills

  • Pogue

    Ah, “competitive” like “Race to the Top”, meaning more criticism and threats if schools don’t accept the grants.  More attacks from newspaper editorial sections on not “putting the students first’.  More test prep, and sitting at desks longer, and bubbling in answers as suppertime nears – oh, the kids will just love it.

    How about…

    A. Get rid of your business “geniuses” pushing the most ridiculous education policies – more testing, more school time, merit pay, and overcrowding co-locations, and hire some education people to make the current school time more productive and creative for kids.
    It can be done.  You did it as a kid.  I did it as a kid.  And millions of others did it through the years.

    B. Get your faux-democrat privatization butt back to making sure the Hurricane Sandy victims are getting all the help and assistance they need during these winter months.    

  • Nyr683

    do not vote for christine quinn unless you want more of bloomdoe policy which has destroyed the school system…..does anyone know any educator who agrees with anything bloomdoe has done in the past 12 years??  If so, please respond to this posting because i do not know any educator who agrees with one thing bloomdo has done

  • BloombergMustGo

    Oh good, another ignorant heard from.  Where are you when all my friends with “real” jobs are going out to dinner, the bars and the movies and my sorry butt is stuck home grading papers, writing curriculum, and typing up assignments and lesson plans. 
    To all the geniuses who think they know how many hours a teacher puts in, I say: “SHUT UP!!”. 
    You wouldn’t last three days in most teachers shoes.  Your jobs would be a vacation for us.  We would get them done in half the time, do a better job at it, organize your offices better than they are, and have better attitudes.
    The next time you can get up and go to the bathroom when you want instead of waiting til you can, SHUT YOUR MOUTH.

  • http://www.facebook.com/charlie.noriega Charlie Noriega

    Bureaucrats love more bureaucracy and in this case, more education red tape. The kids are not learning? Hmmm. It cannot be because the teachers and the teachers’ union is at fault! It cannot be because of all the fraud, waste and abuse of taxpayers money! It cannot because the system lacks creativity, adaptability and accountability. Oh no. It MUST be because the kids are not getting enough “Education Time,” yes. That sounds good. Cuomo, Mulgrew and his buddies sure love this. More taxpayer money to waste and put in their pockets! While the kids get stuck in failing schools LONGER. Just brilliant, no?!

  • Nyr683

    this is not mexico my friend this is the us

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031