GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

wheeling and dealing

In new arrangement, teachers’ pensions to fund infrastructure

President Bill Clinton was joined by AFT President Randi Weingarten (behind him) and other union and city officials today to announce a $1 billion investment of the city's teacher pension fund into Hurricane Sandy recovery projects.

One billion dollars of the city’s teacher pension fund will be used to finance construction and repair projects for city roads, bridges, and homes, President Bill Clinton and other officials announced Thursday.

Clinton joined UFT President Michael Mulgrew, AFT President Randi Weingarten, City Comptroller John Liu, and U.S. Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Shaun Donovan to announce the pledge, which Clinton called “a remarkable commitment” to “properly rebuild in the aftermath of Sandy.”

“This storm exposed weaknesses in our infrastructure that must not only be repaired, but we must rebuild in a different way,” said Donovan, who is now in charge of federal Sandy recovery efforts.

This will be the first time the city’s teacher pension funds are used for infrastructure projects, Liu said, even though the idea has been around for years.

“There’s always been apprehension about, is it going to work, is it potentially a vicious circle? So what I’ve seen is everybody is waiting for somebody else to do it, and therefore nobody does it. I’m very proud that, in this case, New York City is taking the lead,” Liu said after the announcement.

Until now, funds in the Teachers’ Retirement System have all been invested more traditionally, in stocks and bonds and other financial products. Under the new arrangement, the pension fund’s investment will support the construction of projects such as bridges or housing complexes that generate revenue, through tolls and rent or mortgage in those cases. Those revenue streams will return funds to the pension system over time.

Liu wouldn’t predict the rate of return, but he said he was confident that the investments would “earn good returns” and said that each project would be evaluated individually. The California State Teachers’ Retirement System has done something similar in the past two years, pledging to invest $750 million in infrastructure projects — though that’s less than one half of 1 percent of its total $152.5 billion. Weingarten said today that California is starting to see “real returns” from those investments.

Liu said no decisions have been made about which projects would be funded. But Clinton pointed to his foundation’s work to rebuild storm-safe and eco-friendly buildings in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina as an example of the possibilities.

The improvements likely will not include the construction of new schools, since the focus so far has been on projects that will generate revenue, Liu added. All but six of the dozens of school buildings that were damaged by the storm have since reopened.

The pledge, which the city Teachers Retirement System agreed to last week, is part of a larger project of the Clinton Global Initiative to encourage the use of pension funds for infrastructure investments, which began in 2011. The $1 billion amounts to just over 2 percent of the $46 billion Teacher Pension Fund.

Clinton clearly shared the enthusiasm of the other officials, who were effusive in their praise for each other’s work. After everyone else had spoken, he could not resist going up to the microphone one last time.

“I think it’s great that teachers are leading the way here,” Clinton said.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Bad idea.  The funds are supposed to earn 7.5%, which is extremely unlikely.  The city can borrow at far less.  So does the city pay more than it has to on the bonds?  Or does the pension fund accept a lower return, and then force city taxpayers to make up the difference?

    This is just a way to generate PR today, at the expense of a bigger disaster tomorrow.

  • Cindy C.

    Ummm… is it just me, or shouldn’t Mulgrew be focusing on the new teacher evaluation “negotiations” right now? Oh wait, I forgot, we got sold out last night at the DA meeting so he has plenty of time on his hands for other more important things.

  • Guest

    I love how my union asks me how to spend my money.

  • http://twitter.com/SoBronxSchool Bronx Teacher

    Why do I have images from the movie Casino in which the Teamsters funded the Tangiers? Mike Mulgrew=Andy Stone?

  • Guest

    I agree with you. In fact here’s my take on this: The UFT never discussed whether or not union members wanted their hard earned pensions to be used instead of the government doing this work. How dare they make decisions like this with our pensions? How do we know if we will get a return on this investment? The federal, state, and local governments are trying to outlaw unions around the country with their right to work laws and the UFT turns around and gives them money. Does the UFT believe this gives the union protection against being outlawed? How many infrastructure projects have been discovered as bogus, inept, and corrupt? We have our very own corrupt projects (anyone remember City Time?) right here in the city and yet the UFT gladly hands over our pensions to the same people without consulting its members. What guarantee is there that when members retire/or those who are retired, that there will be pension funds to pay out or will members find out that there is very little or no money because the “infrastructure” people had their hands in the cookie jar and no one was watching.

  • http://twitter.com/leoniehaimson leonie haimson

    It’s sad no money will be used for schools; probably the most under-invested, neediest part of the city’s infrastructure and one that intimately affects the quality of education.

  • Husband of a great teacher

    It is amazing that the union is doing something good to help the city and all are complaining, it my money and no one asked me.  This is 2% of your pension fund.  Can any of you tell me where the other 98% is invested?  Have any of you been asked if you approve of those investments?  Right now the city needs help, it should not be political, just help.

  • Larry Littlefield

    “What guarantee is there that when members retire/or those who are retired, that there will be pension funds to pay out or will members find out that there is very little or no money because the “infrastructure” people had their hands in the cookie jar and no one was watching.”

    Acutally, the retired get lots of guarantees here, regardless of the consequences to others.  But if things get bad enough…   And it may be 2.0% of the pension fund, but it is 4.0% of the pension fund that OUGHT TO be there.

    He Guest, want to do something for your pension and the future of the city?  Sue the city for underfunding the pension, which it has admitted it is doing.  This way we won’t have to wait and see whether you lose your retroactively enriched pension or completely destroy the city to keep it ten years from now.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

9 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031