GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

exchange students

Inverting conventional wisdom, Korean leader lauds city school

Democracy Prep Charter High School students who recently took an exchange trip to South Korea, met with South Korean Prime Minister Kim Hwang-Sik during his visit to the school.

Last month, students from Democracy Prep Charter High School were honored guests at Seondeok High School and Dong Seong Middle School in South Korea. Today, they honored a guest of their own: Kim Hwang-Sik, South Korea’s prime minister.

Kim met with school leaders; spoke with the students; and hobnobbed with Congressman Charles Rangel, who supported the exchange trip, during Kim’s brief stop at the school this afternoon. He was in New York City to visit the United Nations as part of a tour of North America.

All students at Democracy Prep High School study Korean, and last month, three dozen of them traveled to South Korea to see the country up close. They visited the schools, toured Buddhist temples, and stayed in the homes of South Korean families.

One student told Kim that the trip had brought the Korean culture she had studied at school to life for her. “Now I want to travel more and … see things with my own true eyes,” she said.

Democracy Prep Superintendent Seth Andrew told Kim that American education leaders often point to South Korea and Finland as two countries whose students far outpace students in the United States. Korea, he said, is the more instructive example of educational excellence because of its economic history.

“I think we have more to learn from Korea because our students have to go from poverty to prosperity” as Korea did, Andrew said. “In Finland, they have always had prosperity.”

But Kim said Korea could also learn a lot from some of the traits that Democracy Prep aims to instill in its students.

“The values of discipline, responsibility, enthusiasm, accountability, and maturity,” he said, listing the qualities in English before switching back to Korean — “I believe these are the values that we need to import to Korea and take back to the education system in Korea.”

While attainment and academic skills are high in South Korea, even the country’s own leaders say that the education system promotes rote learning at the cost of creativity and critical thinking. Schools have long focused on preparing students for a single high-stakes test, the national university entrance exam, and the pursuit of high scores led South Koreans to spend 2 percent of the country’s GDP on private tutoring in 2010, according to a Time Magazine report. Now, reforms are underway to diversify the national curriculum and allow universities to consider more than just test scores when selecting students.

At Democracy Prep today, Andrew gave Kim a baseball cap in the school’s trademark yellow, and students presented him with a number of other gifts. The delegation from South Korea delivered gifts of its own: Samsung printers for each of the school’s two Korean teachers.

  • Abbas Manjee

    Hmm… Pretty sure Finland has NOT “always had prosperity.”  They were an almost 100% agrarian economy until the 1950s and 1960s. Their economic woes during this period and later in the 1990s forced them to make some really important decisions, which led to the more integrated economy they have today. A large part of this was fueled by revamping their education system, which increased social mobility.

  • http://twitter.com/leoniehaimson leonie haimson

    Surveys show that ” discontent with the nation’s
    educational system is at a historically high level. A national poll
    taken by EAI, a Korean think tank, indicates that an absolute majority of
    Koreans are concerned about the “failure” of the nation’s public education
    system.

     
    Byong Man Ahn, the former minister of education in South Korea,
    warned Americans against praising the “educational zeal” of South
    Korean parents, saying that Korean schools had become too test-centered and too
    focused on rote learning, and that they “force the students to memorize so
    much that they experience pain rather than pleasure [of] acquiring knowledge
    through the learning process.”

    An article in the Washington Post  described
    how fully three quarter of all students attend private
    “cram” classes and
    that the average Korean family spends nearly 20 percent of its income
    on private tutoring. Not a system anyone should want to emulate.

     

  • Michael Fiorillo

    Thank you, Abbas, you beat me to it.

    A forty-five second trip to Wikipedia would have shown Mr. Andrew that Finland was a poor, agrarian country until the 1950′s.

    Andrew’s statement was clearly intended to underscore and validate the kind of high-pressure, test-based, rote learning that dominates South Korea, and that most charter chains are imposing on their students.

    As always with charter operators, it’s about ideology, not facts.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

19 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031