GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Vox populi

Comments of the week: Teacher’s-eye views of Regents scoring

It’s that time again — the time for us to highlight some of the week’s informed, thought-provoking comments from our readers.

This week, we especially appreciated the comments posted on our story about a new grading system for high school exams that the Department of Education quietly piloted this year. The system, called distributed scoring, requires for the first time that teachers not grade their own students’ Regents exams, which are required to graduate.

We reported that some teachers worried that distributed scoring would depress scores, sometimes unfairly. Several readers backed up that hypothesis. For example:

…My school’s passing percentage went from 70+% to 20% (!) when they were graded by another school. No doubt there is biased grading going on there.

Some commenters said they thought students from struggling schools were likely to feel the effect of the new grading system most:

While it clear that my whole grading team were really rooting for the kids whose papers’ we scored (even without knowing them), I worry about how my students would fare if they’re papers were graded by teachers who were used to only top tier students. I suspect that a Brooklyn Tech or Stuyvesant teacher (or a teacher on the north shore of Long Island if the pilot expands state-wide) would expect much more from a response for it to earn credit then would most city teachers.

I saw two teachers from a selective high school grade papers from a struggling school and give a whole school 0 and 0 on questions 26 and 27 of the ELA. Makes it almost impossible to pass. The rubric would have dictated at least one point for most of the responses. A colleague and I were grading the essays of the same envelope and gave 3′s, 4′s, and even one or two 5′s to the same students. Their incompetence will likely lead to a school’s closure.

But other readers said their experience suggested that higher-performing students would be penalized:

Our school was chosen.  The passing % didn’t change but mastery fell, a lot. Shockingly low. It wasn’t the students work, it was the graders. A lot of schools gave low scores to ‘better’ schools. It was known and talked about. I heard that it was planned out in some schools. Some schools want their tests regraded and some kids are demanding it.

I have a feeling that some of the “good’ schools are going to be screwed with this system.

I’m in a better school and I was rooting for the weaker kids from the other schools. I was sad when I got blank papers because I couldn’t even look for points to give. Pretty much all the teachers at my school (and, in all subjects) wanted the kids we graded to do well. Sometimes a weaker school student didn’t express themselves as well, but they knew what they were talking about. We gave as many points as we could.

The problem was that some of the other schools resented grading the papers of stronger students. They complained about reading longer essays, having to work through math problems, etc. Our students often paid for it.

A commenter succinctly offered one reason why distributed scoring might not solve the problem of scores not always accurately reflecting student performance:

I think there is an interesting point about incentives here. Originally there were concerns about teachers inflating their own student’s grades, but given the competition inherent in progress reports, there is an incentive to deflate the grades of students from other schools.

And several comments included suggestions for the city and state as distributed scoring is required for all schools next year:

It does not seem like it would be that difficult for the state to maintain a website with a list of all questions asked by teachers and the responses given. This would be tremendously helpful to teachers across the state and help ensure that grading is consistent.

As a math teacher who participated in the electronic grading pilot this June, I have one major complaint. Open-ended math questions were scored by only one rater. There was no check process in place at all. I strongly suggest adopting the model used for grading essays in Global History and English: two raters independently score each essay with a third rater used to settle discrepancies.

  • sosps

    I am a parent of a Brooklyn Tech student.  He took two Regents exams this year.  I expected him to do well, and he did.  So, no complaints here (well, I was hoping Geometry would be a bit higher).  This article was quite surprising to me.  I understand that teachers would “root for” students from less good schools and try to give as much credit as possible, but the idea that teachers would resent having to grade exams taken by students at stronger schools, and would give lower grades as a result, is disturbing to say the least.  Profoundly disturbing.

  • Anonymous

    ZBY-For nearly a century, Mont Blanc Pens has been well-known for its classic writing instruments around the world.The famous name of Mont blanc’s represents the art of writing,symboled by hexagonal white star which is precisely the shape of Europe’s highest mountain.Mont Blanc symbolizes the crown of Europe’s highest snowy mountains that has the altitude of 4810 meters,and the figures are usually used for a variety of topics.mont blanc ballpoint pen are     handmade with the 25 more process to create a pen point.That is why mont blanc fountain pen as writing instruments have the character of solidness and elegance.
    Mont Blanc,1906 in Hamburg, Germany,was founded by a stationer create the adoption of the company before the Montblanc trademark Simplo Filler Pen Company name was established in 1911.The company later by Dunhill all present for the Richemont Group, the formal part.
    In 1908,Simplo Filler Pen Company published the first high-quality security pen – Red and Black.1910 to become an official trademark registration of “Mont Blanc”.The 1924 classic mont blanc meisterstuck grand launch.1935 began producing small leather goods. In 1992, the great writer of limited edition series and patron of the arts series (also known as the Emperor series). In 1997, Mont blanc watch collection to enter the market.2000,mont blanc discount bohemia series to create a new chapter in the art of writing,design simplicity,compact and elegant,to become the new symbol of the modern pop culture.
    We slowed down and enjoy life “(deacceleration),the reliable quality of written and handmade quality,and long-standing emphasis on perfect sense, who insist on making Mont blanc,the emphasis on” high tech “society,the markedly precious.In people’s minds,fountain pen mont blanc has become a symbol of the aspirations of the “high feeling”,a quality of life choice.
    christian louboutin sale sole design very clever, “catch” the selling point of sight let woman enchanted,sexy very narcissistic is frowsty coquettish,imagine a man to follow his sole after the line of sight of red,women must have is willing to pay. The identification of the “red sole degree is high,it’s another benefit is let female stars free advertising.See red christian louboutin pumps is,does not need to find the logo.christian louboutin sales red bottom shoe is the logo,highlights of the women’s gentle and lovely,beauty,and not make public mature sexy.Heel becoming larger and more and more high,once in christian louboutin boots,breast will natural standing,coxal radian will be more tightening become warped,on the vision strengthened the woman idiosyncratic,show lordosis of curved curve,natural after have woman flavour.Christian louboutin wedges with its own language,heels itself is a kind of culture. Louboutin wedges as a woman’s external wearing choice embodies her connotation,her taste,her pursuit of her life, understanding.Christian louboutin sandals is a woman’s life cannot resist temptation of summer follow sandal high is undoubtedly the most powerful-naked fiber foot,Dan red nutmeg, summer air fragrance in stimulating fashion masters of inspiration,the perfect cheap christian louboutin shoes,in people the envy of look in the eyes supports a pieces of living color.Delicate the luxury of girl for oneself of each clothes to acquire a   pair of high heels to match, but always than a double take christian louboutin high boots to reality. A pair of shoes match different dress, you can mature,can also be lovely, shoes with a woman share experience, no matter you are in the life which stage, whether a portly figure or thin,louboutin pumps sale store always with you.christian louboutin wedges is not a mere extrinsic dress choose just.
    Many people like the Nike,many people want to buy a pair of cheap nike shoes.Every year nike australia will launch a lot of discount promotions.nike shoes australia online store tailored specifically for the Australians,as long as you to our nike shoes online store you can find that fits your style.2012 new nike heels,nike free,nike air max all arrive.Our goal is to make every Australian wear nike shoes affordable.
    Just do it!Like sports should have a pair of nike shoes.You like to run it?Enjoy that feeling of freedom on the run.But many times because the expensive price prohibitive.Now have a new way to shop, you will buy one pair of your favorite cheap nike shoes.2012 nike australia has launched a lot of the latest style, basketball fans dream of air jordan series,like the nike free running movement series,the influx of people love nike dunk series.nike shoes australia store audience are sold at a discount,you do not have to worry about quality.
    Whether you are what kind of woman need to wear a pair of christian louboutin pumps on the red carpet,your choice,we are unable to intervene,but you should know that Mr.Bhutto’s name.christian louboutin shoes today has five stores in the United States,two in New York the rest of South Beach Plaza in Los Angeles,Las Vegas and Orange state,some christian louboutin sale stores are planning to open in the Bal harbour,Boston and Chicago.The famous U.S. talk show host Oprah Winfrey,christian louboutin sandals is an art,christian louboutin outlet,recent and famous director David Lynch co-operation,his collection of shoes do one called Idol exhibition.R B singer Ciara,Jay-Z’s song with the lyrics of christian louboutin canada content.
    Red soled Christian Louboutin’s signature logo,highlighting women’s lovely,beautiful,quieter and mature sexy christian louboutin sale store favorite with a variety of bright colors,especially open-toed style won him favor with the soleNama red flag,the performance of a woman with high heels the sexiest,swaying side.No wonder so many stars are even willing to free to speak for him,showed off alone belong to the christian louboutin outlet‘s style on the red carpet.
    Frenchman christian louboutin high boots world is absolutely impossible to ignore.It is a favorite of European and American actress!”Red shoes” to identify high,another advantage is that the female stars free advertising.See the red soles of christian louboutin uk,the fundamental need to find the logo.christian louboutin sales store has a beauty of the girl should have at least seven pairs of christian louboutin shoes,seven deadly sins,like a pair of fun, a pair to flirt,a pair of work wear, a pair of holiday with a pair for Spring Night time,a pair of never worn and a pair of you do not like to have one pair do not like shoes,you can remind ourselves not always perfect dress.

  • 1051235615

    叙事詩。 Websterの辞書には、エルメス 財布 通常のまたは普通特に大きい、または範囲を超えて延びている叙事詩が定義されています。それはかなり適切に環境ジョーダン11をまとめている。この靴は確かによくあなたの一般のフィールドホッケーの靴を超えています。尺度履物精通すべてのカテゴリーで。品質、デザイン、ファッション、F50 アディゼロ パフォーマンスと名前。多数の叙事詩のcolorways低下したと広く最高ヨルダン、最高のバスケットボール靴、今までに作られたものとみなされます。この靴は、この男自身は、マイケル·ジョーダンジョーダン主演のも、映画 “スペースジャ エアフォース1 ム”内アンサンブルキャストの一部でした。この靴は叙事詩の定義である可能性があります。は、まず1995年から1996年のNBAシーズンにリリースされました。 ジャックパーセル のシーズンはマイケル·ジョーダンの来るの背中を見た。 4年間の引退とサッカーを楽しんだ後は、ヨルダンはカムバックを作って、最高の有名ながNBAファイナルトーナメントするために、このシカゴ·ブルズを製造し、UGGブーツ 導いたスポーツhardcourtに戻った。また、彼はNBAのいつものシーズンMVPとオールスターゲームMVPとなっています。

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

11 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031