GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

guest perspective

The Special Education Reforms From A Student’s Perspective

Growing up with a disability, I am very familiar with the term “special ed.” I am also aware that the phrase “special education” has a negative connotation.

I remember an incident in middle school where one of my math teachers wrote on the board, “All special ed students will report to room 420 for the state exam.”

Another student who was in special education screamed out, “Don’t call us special ed!”

This incident shows the struggle with identity that students who need Integrated Co-Teaching often find themselves in. (An ICT classroom contains a mixture of students with disabilities and nondisabled students. There are two teachers, one licensed in the general education content area and the other licensed in special education who is responsible for working with students with disabilities.) Many students do not want to be considered any different from our non-disabled peers, but the fact is we are different.

Citywide, the graduation rate for students with disabilities is around 30 percent while the graduation rate for nondisabled students is over 60 percent. The statistics suggest that just because I have a disability, I am half as likely to graduate.

I attend NYC Lab School, a selective high school that is located in Chelsea and was an early adopter of the inclusion model. During my freshman year at Lab, I received a letter during homeroom. The letter said that my school had been selected to participate in the Phase 1 of the Department of Education’s special education reforms. At the time, I didn’t know much about the reforms or how I would be affected.

But during my sophomore year of high school, I realized the benefits of the reforms, which aim to push schools to integrate students with disabilities more often and in more substantive ways.

In my school, only a handful special education students decide to take more than one year of foreign language because the advanced courses do not offer the same level of support, but I knew that I wanted to continue taking Spanish. Participating in the pilot of the reform caused my school to look at special education as a service and not just a place and because of this I was able to request that my Spanish class be supported with an ICT teacher. Knowing that this Spanish class would be ICT-supported allowed my classmates with disabilities and I to be comfortable with taking on the risk of continuing our Spanish studies.

This year, I was able to challenge myself in Advanced Placement U.S. history and Advanced Placement English language and composition because of the special education reforms. Before the reform, students with disabilities were often excluded from taking AP courses because these classes were not always supported with a special education teacher. Now, many schools, including mine, are starting to think flexibly about how to support students with disabilities who want to challenge themselves.

For example, this year at my school juniors who need ICT support were enrolled in an advanced English course that had a special education teacher as well as an English teacher. But any student who wanted to challenge themselves by the taking an Advanced Placement course could sign up for a weekly seminar that allowed us to go beyond the standard curriculum. The AP component was taught by the general education teacher who collaborated with the special education teacher to make sure that the AP curriculum was manageable for all students. This model was extremely successful and encouraged more students with disabilities to take the AP component. Next year, the school has decided to move the AP U.S. history classes onto this model as well. This probably would not have happened without the special education reforms.

Like any movement, the special education reform has attracted some skepticism. Some might fear that the inclusion of students with disabilities could delay the progress of nondisabled students or that teachers have not been properly trained. But as the student representative to the Citywide Council on Special Education, I know that the Department of Education has been holding workshops weekly to train teachers and principals in how the reform will work and how to support students with disabilities in their classes and schools. I also know that that training for the reform will continue throughout the summer and for years to come. The reform is constantly evolving and the city is working with advocacy groups to address their concerns.

I feel that anyone who is “putting all students first” should agree with the goal of the special education reforms, which is to “raise the bar for all students.” I applaud Deputy Chancellor Laura Rodriguez; Lauren Katzman, the former executive director for special education; and the Department Of Education for taking the bold step of working to close the achievement gap between disabled and nondisabled students.

  • Ms. V.

    One of the best pieces published on this site… nice.

  • Ellen

    Go get ‘em Bryan

  • Celia Oyler

    I love that you are still in high school but are already taking up a stance as a public intellectual and disability rights activist! It’s so important for educators and the general public to hear directly from students with disabilities about what it is you want and need. You also do an excellent job of identifying prejudice and discrimination. I look forward the day when special education is seen as a set of services that can be delivered to any classroom. 

  • Patty Nemko

    Great input from a student, I love hearing your views on special education!!!! Wish more students would speak up!!!! Continue writing!!!You’re awesome!!!

  • Dawn Greenfield

    Why isn’t this kid the Chancellor? 

  • Dohistory

    techers hvnt been train in many many schools

  • ldm1025

    Bravo!!

  • Jstone

    Bryan when is your next article coming out?  I love reading your views!!!!
    Janet

  • Lori Podvesker

    Rock on Bryan!!!

  • Prof. Laurie Lehman

    I applaud your advocating for more and more supported inclusion at your school and throughout the NYC school system,

  • Dominique Lawton

    Thank you for speaking out but if you want to change the negative connotation of special education you actually do have to let every know you are “special ed.”  When they see that you are talented in addition to being special ed the attitudes will begin to change.  Why is there anything with calling a student who receives special education services a special ed student?  The political correctness continues to get out of hand.  Please don’t encourage it.

  • Joan Proctor

    I applaud you for having the writing skills, as well as the voice to speak for those often cannot speak for themselves!!!
    Joan

  • Special Ed Advocat

    He is not “special ed”- he is a student with a disability.  Our students spend so much time dodging this title that it is stifling them in more ways than one.   If we continue to place ”special ed” before the students we are, in fact, disabling them and consequently keeping them from being as successful as Bryan.

  • Brooke Jackson

    Bryan, Since originally reading and admiring your article, I have enjoyed reading all the encouraging comments in response.  So proud to be your Principal!  Love, Brooke 

  • Concerned Paren

    The Department of Education should listen to their students more often

  • Anonymous

    Bryan, I encourage you to go further and answer some questions that those of us who are not as knowledgeable about special education might have.  What, exactly, does the ICT teacher do to support student learning?  which types of disabilities can be accomodated with this co-teaching model?  there is a tendency, among those who write or talk about supports for students with disabilities to lump all disabilities together and to use very generic language when speaking of special education services.  The general public can get confused by this and tune out.

  • Anonymous

    Bryan, I encourage you to go further and answer some questions that those of us who are not as knowledgeable about special education might have.  What, exactly, does the ICT teacher do to support student learning?  which types of disabilities can be accomodated with this co-teaching model?  there is a tendency, among those who write or talk about supports for students with disabilities to lump all disabilities together and to use very generic language when speaking of special education services.  The general public can get confused by this and tune out.

  • KitchenSink

    I don’t know what Bryan will say, but I would say that good special education teaching is simply good teaching.  The tier I supports that all good teachers use in classrooms to differentiate learning and make sure that each student can access the general education curriculum are simply used constantly rather than as a strategy to apply here and there, as in a general education room.  At our school in ICT classes both teachers are responsible for all the students–but the special education teacher brings with him or her gifts for reaching, engaging and pushing students with IEPs that are then shared by both teachers.

  • Anonymous

    Kitchen Sink, I’m a teacher too (though I haven’t taught in an ICT classroom).  I need more specifics in order to understand what is going on in these classrooms.  I can use accomodations like seating choice, visual prompts, altered assignments, etc.  So is the special ed teacher there mostly to up the amount of individual attention that’s available?  What does s/he use this extra time to actually do?  Does s/he make it possible for students who need ASL or CART in order to participate?  Is s/he helping students with cognitive disabilities by creating a parralel curriculum?  I’m serious when I say that this just amounts to ” more supports” leaaves many in the dark.

  • Rcarroll1

    when i was in school i was special.  I was so special,, i was in special ed.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031