GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

line by line

Mayor’s budget keeps after-school cuts, counts on teacher evals

Advocates protest the city's proposed cuts to after-school programs during a rally outside City Hall today.

The city would spend $387 million more on its schools next year and hire more teachers under the budget proposal Mayor Bloomberg unveiled today.

But it would also slash spending to after-school programs, leaving 27,000 children who currently attend city-funded programs without care.

“I’m concerned,” Bloomberg said about the after-school cuts during a press conference about the budget today at City Hall. He said the programs are “extremely valuable” for working families but had unfortunately fallen victim to scarce resources. “We cannot do everything for everybody,” he said.

Advocates from Upper Manhattan gathered on the steps of City Hall in protest right after Bloomberg’s presentation, and critics of the mayor’s budget said the child-care cuts would prove short-sighted.

“These are dollars that allow parents to go to work and pay taxes; cutting them will only force more families to seek public assistance and add to taxpayer costs,” said Manhattan Borough President and mayoral candidate Scott Stringer in a statement.

But both the mayor and City Council Speaker Christine Quinn signaled that the toll could be lessened by the time a final budget is set by July 1.

At a press conference shortly after Bloomberg’s presentation, Quinn said reversing the child-care cuts would be her top priority during the next two months of budget negotiations. Last year, the budget negotiation process ended with some restorations for child care and, at the last moment, averted thousands of teacher layoffs that Bloomberg had threatened.

“If there is an openness to negotiations then I’m very optimistic,” Quinn said about the opportunity to shift more funds to after-school programs. Reversing the cuts would be a political win for each City Council member and especially for Quinn, who is seen as Bloomberg’s choice to succeed him.

Robert Jackson, the council’s education committee chair, vowed to turn back the cuts, which would eliminate thousands of child-care slots in his Northern Manhattan district. “If we have to dance to come to the end and reach an agreement, we will dance,” he said.

Quinn and other members of the council took credit for one change that happened between Bloomberg’s preliminary budget proposal and now. As Chancellor Dennis Walcott had promised and City Council sources indicated on Wednesday, the city is not calling for any reduction in the size of the Department of Education’s teaching corps. Instead, Bloomberg said today, it would actually add teaching positions for the first time after years of budget cuts.

Last year, the city lost 1,800 teaching jobs to attrition. Bloomberg said today the city would replace all teachers who leave and also likely add positions, for a total of 2,500 new hires.

The mayor’s preliminary budget, released in February, had also called for a $30 million cut in funds for overtime payments to Department of Education employees. That cut was eliminated, and a Department of Education spokesman, Matthew Mittenthal, said principals could opt to pay for after-school programs of their own using the “per session” funds.

United Federation of Teachers President Michael Mulgrew gave the budget a positive review but did not address the after-school cuts. ”New York City has lost thousands of teachers over the last few years and it’s good news to hear that we will be adding educators to the system,” he said. “I can’t thank the City Council enough for making education a priority.”

But Mulgrew chided Bloomberg for saying during his press conference that he hoped the union would engage in “serious discussions” around new teacher evaluations, noting that the city, not the union, had walked out of talks in December.

“There’s no substantive reason why a final agreement should not be reached very quickly,” Bloomberg had said. ”The longer the UFT waits, however, the longer it will take our schools to get the money they need and that they deserve.”

That’s because Gov. Andrew Cuomo has pledged to attach next year’s increases in school aid to teacher evaluation agreements: Districts that don’t finalize new evaluations by January 2013 won’t see their state aid grow. Not meeting the deadline could force the city to forgo $300 million for the year — nearly the same amount by which the DOE’s budget is slated to grow — and make deep midyear cuts to the Department of Education.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tommy-Calderon/100000263260717 Tommy Calderon

    OK, so let’s review:  Bloomberg announces no cuts to schools based on $300 million of increased state aid.  That aid is contingent on an agreement on bogus teacher evaluations based on flawed and error filled state tests that Cumo requires.  If the agreement (read capitulation) doesn’t happen the state aid vanishes necessitating cuts to schools. 
    Hey kids, can you spell B L A C K M A I L , S C H E M I N G, and C O N N I V I N G?

  • Msfwhcl

    It’s ALL GOOD, no worries.  Quinn will really do us in!!

  • Vicki

    Things like this show the obvious need for reform of the educational system. I have become so desperate to make sure that my children get a proper education that I enrolled them in supplementary classes. I recommend this to any parent!

    I live in Brooklyn, NY, and I use Brainy Academy (http://www.brainyacademy.com) because I like their system of teaching. The curriculum they give out is personal, based on an assessment of the child’s skills. Children work at whatever level they should be, and at the pace that they need. They utilize the Singapore Math Method, and the Montessori system to educate children. 

    Try them out, or any other supplementary classes. While the above BS is going on, we need to make sure our children are getting what they need. 

  • Turnaround Teacher

    GS, any idea if this will mean the hiring freeze is lifted in all license areas, or will it just mean more new Special Ed teachers?

  • enpassant

    Everyone see the stories about the I.S. 318 chess team all over the media?  The team that Bloomberg celebrated with himself at City Hall?  They win the National Chess Championship then have their program de-funded by the City!

  • Fantastic

    YES, that’s true Enpassant.  It’s a disgusting move that City Hall has made. We can only hope that the City Council does their job and restores after-school programs.  The mayor fiscal policies are short-sighted in the sense that it will cost the city more monies in policing the kids that are NOT in afters-chool programs.  Crime rates will rise and so will gang memberships.

  • Reed Richards

    It is alleged that the mayor would restore half of the money that has been “de-funded” by his Executive Budget.  He has proposed that the other half of his budget cut to the DYCD would be paid for by parents.  He would like to set up a “fee based” system for After-School and Early Ed programs.  In my opinion public programs should not be fee-based.  I believe parents who live in school areas with high rates of poverty can not afford fee-based programming.  I.S. 318 is a Title 1 school, Universal Lunch and is in a “Priority Zip Code”.  Fee based after-school won’t work in areas like that because parents can’t afford it.  This furthers the idea that the mayor is only interested in privatization of public monies. That’s bad policy!

  • lets be honest

    It would be better to be honest and take the cuts in september than have the
    Midyear annual turmoil to programs, personnel and class sizes

  • Mr. Flerporillo

    I don’t think you’d enjoy the cuts that would happen if the City were truly honest about its finances. 

  • Had enough!

    He’s cutting After-School Programs in Public Schools to get Parents to sign-on to Charter Schools who WILL receive all the funding he wants.  Why?  Because it’s all about the $$$$$$$$$$$!!!!!

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

3 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031