GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

case closed

Shuang Wen School inquiry reveals deep “dishonest behavior”

A parent stands in front of the Cherry Street entrance to the Lower East Side's Shuang Wen elementary school.

A sprawling investigation into the leadership of a controversial dual-language school in Chinatown concluded that the school’s principal had falsified attendance data and accepted money from a non-profit hired to administer after school language lessons.

The Department of Education will move to fire Ling Ling Chou, who was removed from the school in September while as many as 16 different investigations were underway.

According to the report, she frequently faked numbers when reporting information about the school to the city and the United States Department of Education, including student attendance records and the length of the school day. The report does not conflict with a different report released last year by the special commissioner of investigations, which found that Chou and other staffers committed multiple improprieties, but did not outright steal public money.

“For years, Principal Chou engaged in dishonest behavior, unbeknownst to her students and school community,” said Chancellor Dennis Walcott in a statement. “Principal Chou’s conduct has failed to meet the standard we set for our principals, and I am filing charges to terminate her employment.”

Shuang Wen consistently boasts some of the strongest test scores in the city, but divisions between the staff and parents at the Lower East Side school have led to numerous allegations of and investigations into misconduct.

Among other substantiated allegations, investigators found that Chou accepted thousands of dollars from a non-profit that administers the school’s after school program, called Shuang Wen Academy Network, for performing administrative duties for the organization and serving as summer director of its after school programs. Chou said she resigned from serving on the organization’s board on the advice of a principals’ union representative, who warned that her actions could lead to an OSI investigation into conflicts of interest.

A parent reported to OSI that Chou had removed his children from the school’s roster when they took a vacation to Disney World, then re-enrolled them upon their return. Investigators found that hundreds of students had also been similarly discharged for taking days off from school, and that Chou had encouraged teachers to mark students as present at school even when they left less than halfway through the school day.

For example Chou once falsified attendance records to show near-perfect attendance at the school when in fact more than half the students had left “en mass” after attendance was taken to attend Chinese New Year celebrations.

The exterior of Shuang Wen was quiet in the hours following dismissal this afternoon, and the dozens of parents and staffers who filed out remained tight-lipped about the news.

Two parents, while climbing into a car parked outside on Cherry Street, said they had heard the news, but had not had time to form an opinion yet.

“We have to see what happens next,” one said before driving off.

Several teachers would respond to GothamSchools only with a firm, “no comment.”

Below is a letter the city sent to parents today. The OSI reports are available on our Scribd page.

Shuang Wen Letter Re Chou Disciplinary Charges – FINAL (4!20!12)

  • Shuang Wen parent

    This was a witch hunt, pure and simple.  Please report fairly on the facts and not just on the DOE’s results of the witch hunt.  Your insinuations that she “did not outright steal” public money makes it seem that there was money taken but not quite theft.  In fact, the procedural votes were not recorded right and no money was missing at all.  They recommended accounting training.

    For the other charges, these are similar practices that i have seen in many many schools.  Ms Chou was accused with stealing hundreds of thousands of dollars and the resulting investigation found that children were marked present on their cultural holiday when they left early?!?  

    Finally, there was not division between staff and parents, but a division between 4 parents and the combined rest of the parents/staff.  4 parents were upset and 596 were united with the staff  (see many petitions, letters and rallies by the parents)

    This was a great principal who was incredibly honest, sincere, and wonderful to work with.  The way that the city and the media have treated this story has been a complete travesty.  Ask some of the parents about the truth before “reporting”.

    –Parent at Shuang Wen

  • Ken Hirsh

    I look forward to comments from the anti-charter “proof by anecdote” contingent.  

  • bee

    My don’t we have a smarmy way of getting our jollies….

  • SWS Parent

    I cannot for the life of me figure out what the DOE’s purpose was in all this. Years and thousands of tax dollars spent for investigations and all they found was that Ling Ling- while running one of the highest performing schools in District 1 and the entire city, with some of the most limited resources- marked some students as present when they left early for the day? Really? 

    I’m a district one resident and Shuang Wen parent and I am incredibly thankful for Ling Ling Chou. She built a strong, academic school in a district marred by numerous sub performing schools. I am so grateful to have the ability to send my children to the school that she built. 

    Shame on the DOE, and for the press for not getting the story right.  

  • Eagleeye

    Reporting that a student was present when they left the school and in fact was absent is stealing money from the Federal government.  It is a class B felony for each count so please get your law straight, as far as the transfer the P.T.A. was told that they were not allowed to do this so I for one will enjoy when the indictments come and they can’t come soon enough.  It seems that your emotions outweigh your intellect, nothing more to say

  • OneShuangWenParent

    Ed Primus, you don’t know what you don’t know.  And last time I looked, you were the ONLY one facing criminal charges.  Dream on.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031