GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

war of attrition

Walcott: Projected $64 million cut to schools only temporary

Schools Chancellor Dennis Walcott repeated a promise not to touch principals’ budgets next year, saying that a proposed cut in school funding that would cost the city more than 1,100 teaching positions would likely disappear once the city finalizes its budget later this spring.

Of the 5,000 teachers who typically leave the system each year, the preliminary 2013 budget projects that only about 4,000 would be replaced, which would save about $64 million, according to the city’s preliminary budget . But Walcott said that funding would likely be restored in time for the final budget and that principals would be able to hire for any vacated positions.

City Council members pestered Walcott about that and much more at a hearing this afternoon on the agency’s $19.6 billion budget, a 1 percent increase that won’t cover the added expenses the department expects. While last year’s hearings focused almost solely on opposition to a proposal to layoff thousands of teachers, the concerns raised by elected officials today spanned a range of the city’s education policies, including increased class sizes, the small schools initiative, spending on technology and contracts, and Medicaid collection.

But they reserved most of their early criticism on the $64 million cut in areas that directly fund schools. The decreased sum represents a headcount reduction of 1,117 teacher positions, according to the city’s projections.

“Year after year the DOE has made cuts to school budgets,” said Education Committee Chair Robert Jackson. “How are schools supposed to make do next year given the loss of funding proposed in the budget?”

Walcott warned that preliminary projections were just that and insisted that principals would not have their budgets slashed for a fifth straight year.

“It’s my goal and our hope to make sure that the budget stay flat without having any cuts to our schools,” Walcott said. “We’re going to work very hard within the system that any type of absorptions be done centrally.”

It’s a brighter fiscal situation this year, thanks to funding that is being restored at the state level. Last year, the city lost a total of $1.7 billion in state and federal aid.

This year, the city is getting back $224 million back from state aid, a figure that was locked down today when the state legislature and Gov. Cuomo signed off on a final budget for the 2012-2013 fiscal year.

“These funds will begin to provide some much needed breathing room for our principals and school communities who have been forced to make tough decisions with regard to school staffing and programming over the past several years,” Walcott said in his testimony.

It’s a pledge that Walcott has made several times since the end of last year’s budget cycle, when the education department slashed $189 million out of individual schools’ budgets, a 2.4 percent decline that resulted in the reduction of more than 2,000 teaching positions and hundreds of school aide layoffs.

Mulgrew criticized the projected cuts and attrition, saying that was another example of misplaced priorities on the part of the DOE.

“All this is part of the larger disinvestment in our public institutions and our communities,” Mulgrew said in his testimony.

Brad Lander, who released a report yesterday that found class sizes have risen in already large elementary classrooms, said he wants the department to study the effect that class sizes were having on academic achievement, an idea that Chief Academic Officer Shael Polakow-Suransky welcomed.

“I agree that teacher quality matters enormously, but parents don’t want their kids in classrooms of 30 or more,” Lander said.

Other Council members used the opportunity to plug schools in their district. Bedford-Stuyesant’s Al Vann outlined Boys & Girls High School’s recent athletic championships – city, state and national championships for the boys track and field and and basketball teams – and then promised that academic progress would soon follow. “Mark my word, within a few years, Boys & Girls will be one of the highest-rated schools in the city.”

In a heated exchange about college readiness for black and Latino students, Brooklyn Councilman Jumaane Williams said the city’s policies had failed that segment of the population.

“They’re either too dumb to get educated, too dumb to be able to get a job, deserve what they get when they’re in the hands of police or something is wrong and we’re not addressing it,” Williams said. “We get teflon commissioners or teflon chancellors who say all the right things, but time and time again, things are not changing.”

Walcott took issue with Williams’ characterization. He said his work on education in the Bloomberg administration, which launched the $127 million Young Men’s Initiative last year, has focused on that student population.

“I will never ever be lectured by any individual as far as my role, our role, in trying to improve the outcomes for black and Latino students,” Walcott said.

 

  • a. non ymous

    Here we go… they can fill that 64 million dollar budget gap by getting the Race to the Top funds restored… here comes the pressure for that evaluation deal.  And that 1,000+ atr pool that’s coming thanks to the 33 turn around schools- guess what people?  Bloomberg will put the pressure on to eliminate the 64 million dollar budget gap by ending the atr pool.  This didn’t prevent the PEP from approving more than 20 million dollars for those EPO’s!  Why is the D.O.E. and their maneuvers always six months ahead of our union?  The UFT is so inept and weak you have to wonder if they’re in on this nonsense.  

  • Troublesome

    Will anyone ask Walcott why after ten years of Bloomberg the Fair Student Funding formulas STILL have not been implemented.  Ten years!  Go on the DOE website and try to figure out why some schools receive 95% of their budget and other schools receive 82%.  Ask why the DOE maintains a slush fund called  TEMPORARY SHORTFALL that it doles out at their discretion.

  • teachmyclassmrmayor

    Since when are ANY budget cuts temporary? Mr. Walcott, do you really think we are all fools? All the HS teachers being forced (yes they get paid for it, but there are people teaching seven classes) to teach extra classes or lose jobs, when they are allowing the system NOT to hire people. All of those elementary & junior highs being illegally allowed to hide the fact that they are breaking state law by NOT having a licensed P.E. teacher on staff. All of this being done to not have to hire people, pay them benefits and cut class sizes. Please DO NOT believe a word that anyone, let alone words that come from the upper echelons of the DOE.
     

  • Leonie Haimson

    First of all, Council staff projected a loss of 2600 gened teaching positions due to the budget cuts, not . Secondly, even with flat budgets, schools will have to lose teachers, b/c costs go up each year and a larger percentage  of their school budget will go to cover mandated special ed classes.  Without an actual INCREASE in school budgets, we will lose gened teachers and see larger classes next year once again.

  • OhMyEd

    the fix is in and you’re paying for it with your dues. 

  • Z111m

    Walcott talks about not being lectured to BUT after 10 years of his “work” in this area
    The population he mentions is still in dire straights…He should stick to making
    Candy ass soy milk waffles as he is uncertified and unqualified for the office he holds..
    The panel that gave him his waiver found Cathie Black to be equally qualified..

    PS : Can anyone find out when where and for how long Walcott actually taught kindergarten…
    I have heard that it was very briefly in a private school and that he hated it!!! Does anyone have info on this?

  • Pogue

     So, Bloomberg and the city get ripped off for upwards of 1 Billion dollars in the City Time scandal.  The crooks will pay back $500 million to avoid prosecution and schools across the city have to take a “temporary” 64 million dollar cut….

    Now, that’s what I called shared sacrifice.

    Tests First.  Children Last.  Making teachers Miserable in between. Always.

    End mayoral Control.

  • Disgusted

    Did any council member ask about the $200 million Title I money NOT allocated to the schools? How about the last minute changes to qualification that deprived large schools of millions in this federal money this year and gave it to Central and to new schools? Anybody read the DOE’s own allocation memos?

  • Anon

    The cuts are preliminary (not temporary), meaning that they expect them to be restored before city budgets ate finalized and before school budgets for 2012-13 are released.

  • Anon

    They account for rising costs already in projections. The DOE budget has risen annually throughout the period when School budgets have been cut, but those increases haven’t kept pace with rising costs (both in salaries and other non-discretionary costs like pensions and special education services). The DOE is saying this year that school budgets won’t take a hit relative to rising costs, meaning a reduction in staff (even via attrition) won’t be necessary.

  • Anon

    Gotham Schools said temporary; the DOE said that this was a preliminary budget and that the money showing as a cut now would be restored before the budget is finalized.

  • Anon

    FSF was introduced ahead of the 2007-08 school year, not 10 years ago. The implementation was contingent upon budget conditions (that was the only way to create parity without cutting overformula schools which the city committed to in negotiations with unions and advocates.) Because bugles gets started taking a hit with the mid-year cut in Jan 2008 the full implementation was never realized. They gave underformula schools 55% of what they were owed in sept 2007 (up to $400k) and were supposed to restore the balance the following year. It is my understanding that they made additional gains toward equity over the past few years but the only way to implement the rest of the restoration without significantly cutting certain schools’ budgets was to have more money flowing in from the state. That didn’t happen.

  • Anon

    Budgets, not bugles. Apologies for errors — I am typing on my iPhone.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031