GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

compare and contrast

Common Core’s impact grows clearer with sample test items

City and state officials have promised that new curriculum standards, known as the Common Core, would de-emphasize rote learning in favor of critical thinking. But exactly what that would look like wasn’t clear when the Common Core first entered the conversation.

Now the picture is growing clearer. Earlier this winter, Department of Education officials testifying before members of the City Council during a hearing on college readiness aired a slideshow presentation that showed how the same skills are tested now and how they would be tested once the Common Core is fully rolled out.

For example, the high school English Regents exam currently asks students to answer a series of multiple-choice questions that require them to locate pieces of information in texts. On a Common Core-aligned test, they would have to read several different passages and write an essay analyzing their arguments, bringing in information from other sources to bolster the analysis.

The Common Core would reshape math tests, too. A sample fifth-grade question asks students to read a paragraph and draw out the relevant information to adjudicate a dispute about three friends’ pizza consumption. In contrast, a current exam question simply asks students to add fractions that represent the sizes of two people’s meals.

The state is scheduled to roll out Common Core-aligned tests in grades 3 through 8 next year. Regents exams are supposed to start reflecting the Common Core’s focus on real-world situations, problem-solving, and informational texts in the 2013-2014 school year. The state is also weighing whether to adopt brand-new, Common Core-aligned tests for the 2014-2015 school year that are being developed by a consortium of states that have adopted the new standards.

Schools across the city and state have spent the year practicing connecting instruction to the Common Core, and this spring, every teacher is supposed to assign one “task” that is linked to the standards. This afternoon, Elizabeth will be asking Department of Education Deputy Chancellor Shael Polakow-Suransky and State Education Commission John King how the pilot year is going during a panel discussion at WNET’s Celebration of Teaching and Learning.

The pages from the city’s slideshow presentation are below.

  • Guest

    Some of my high school students don’t have the reading ability for the common core 5th grade math questions.  This should be interesting.

  • Mike

    I thought the English Regents already contained essay questions.

  • http://twitter.com/BNiche B

    Thank you Philissa for this article! My question though is… these are only two pages of the slideshow. Are there any other examples of question vs. question slides where we could see the changes between the other grades and their tests? Also, how about the other pages of the slideshow?

  • guest

    wake up people.  The Obama administration is directly behind these
    changes.  The future of public education is to be determined by a small
    group of political insiders with conflicts of interests galore.  They
    will pad their ranks by offering patronage to their friends and family. 
    As long as you stay silent, you will keep your position.  If you
    thought the Republicans were bad, you haven’t seen anything yet. 
    Remember, it is the enemy within that destroys.  Where is a Senator
    Wellstone when we need him.  Who will stand up and cry, “Hold on.”

  • Guest

    It would be nice to see the rest of those slides

    That exact prompt has been at my school since January. We
    are supposed to give it to students this spring.

    In the future I wonder if we will have access to the prompt
    ahead of time. If we do have access to the prompt ahead of time, I imagine that
    teacher will be spending a lot of time on that one topic. The assessments would
    be a huge lever for the state to change the focus of a curriculum from year to
    year. If we don’t have access to the prompt ahead of time the teachers who
    happen to teach that topic in a given year will be in luck. Their students will
    perform well because they won’t need to be able to read the passages on the
    test to write about the topic. Fewer topics and questions on the assessment
    mean that the assessment will be less reliable even if it is more valid. This
    might be desirable, but it is an important trade off to keep in mind. I wonder
    if the state will be releasing new content standards for ELA and Social Studies
    to demystify the possible prompts.

    Are the city and the state both developing new assessments? How
    well aligned are they with national and international assessments? I imagine
    there are some intriguing power struggles in the world of common core
    assessment creation.  

    I don’t think there is much to dislike about switching the
    assessments from multiple guess to reading and writing but I’m not sure how you
    develop a value added score for a purely written assessment. Someone is going
    to demand multiple choice questions so teachers can be a given a numerical
    evaluation.

  • GUest

    Under mayoral control the DOE is just a mayoral propaganda machine.  Any claims they make on their own site MUST be taken with a grain of salt as in the past they have proven to be outright lies.  Methinks it is time for some independent oversight.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031