GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

context clues

Dominican families balance schooling with extended trips home

Gregorio Luperon High School serves newcomer students, most of whom come from the Dominican Republic.

It begins in early December. Students pop into the attendance office at Gregorio Luperon High School for Science and Mathematics brandishing plane tickets like doctor’s notes. Then the absences start, weeks before the winter break begins. And then comes the rolling return of students, stretching to the waning days of January.

The annual ritual that takes place at Gregorio Luperon also plays out in other pockets of the city that, like Washington Heights, have many students from the Dominican Republic.

Extended mid-year absences are by no means limited to Dominican students: The New York Times reported this week about post-vacation enrollment flux at Chinatown schools. But educators and community organizations say the phenomenon is especially pronounced at schools with many families from the Dominican Republic — and that the impact can be significant.

About 15 Luperon students missed some amount of school this December and January because they were in the Dominican Republic, according to Luperon’s attendance teacher, and two still hadn’t returned last week.

“They want to see their families back home, especially if they haven’t seen them in a long time,” said Mireya De La Rosa, an assistant principal at Gregorio Luperon who immigrated from the Dominican Republic herself.

Gregorio Luperon — a bilingual school that accepts recent immigrants from Latin America, the majority of whom are Dominican — has made efforts to curb the practice. Teachers broach the issue with families during orientation by telling them that it is not an acceptable for students to miss chunks of school, then remind students in the weeks before winter break about the consequences of missing school. Teachers are discouraged from doling out make-up work to students, so there are real consequences for leaving the country.

Now, only a “micro-, micro-minority” of Luperon families pull their children from school to return home over the holiday season, De La Rosa said.

But, she added, “For us, even five kids is a problem, because those five kids won’t do well when they come back and take the finals.”

Younger children don’t have final exams to grapple with in January, but they still lose out by missing a few days of school, said David Grisevich, an assistant principal at P.S. 152 in Washington Heights.

At P.S. 152, the scattered extended absences during the winter are like “a nagging toothache” for teachers, Grisevich said.

De La Rosa and Grisevich both suggested that the long vacations happen because young, working-class families try to squeeze the most out of a plane ticket by booking outside of peak travel days.

But the explanation for the phenomenon is more complex than just finances.

Joshua Ceballos and Jeyco Consepcion, eighth-graders at the Mirabal Sisters Campus, a Washington Heights building with three middle schools, both missed several days of school this year to spend extended time with their families in the Dominican Republic, Ceballas returning mid-January, Consepcion returning last Monday.

The boys each said that spending time with family was the primary purpose of his trip. “Everybody is there,” Consepcion said. “It’s like home.”

“Over there, it’s better. It’s more active, kids spend their time outside,” Ceballos said. He added that the fresh food is another draw: “Over here the food is fake. Over there, I go with my grandpa to the farm and we get the beans and corn and then my grandma cooks it.”

The boys also explained that schools are different in the Dominican Republic. There, schools hold four-hour shifts in the morning, afternoon, and evening from which students can choose.

Shondel Nero, an associate professor at New York University who directs NYU’s program in multilingual and multicultural studies, explained that in part because of “shift” schooling, missing school is generally not seen as a major problem in the Dominican Republic.

Religion also plays a role, said Nero, who facilitates a study abroad program in the Dominican Republic. Because most Dominicans are “staunch Catholics,” they celebrate holidays well into the month of January, she said. After Christmas and New Years, there are El Dia de los Reyes on Jan. 6 and Our Lady of Altagracia Day Jan. 21.

“Culturally speaking, family and faith are two of the most important things to Dominicans. Sometimes to the detriment of education,” Nero wrote.

Vianca Caceras, a mother of three who works at Turissa Travel in Washington Heights, has pulled her two oldest children out of their Bronx elementary school in the past for a lengthy trip back home. Many of her family members – including her youngest child – live in the Dominican Republic, and she said that it was worth the money and time to travel home with her children.

“The children have 180 days in school, so five days with their family is not a big deal. The family makes sure that the child grows up healthy. It’s important,” Caceras said.

“It’s difficult because two things are important,” she added. “Seeing my other family and my country and making sure that my babies go to school.”

  • GUest

     Yeah, yet another ignored piece of data.

  • Sssss

    That is so sad!!! That is some ignorant stuff!!

  • CkornNYSUT

    Interesting. Maybe the next piece could delve into how these students’ standardized tests scores will be factored into teachers’ evaluations. Whether the students are in the Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, China or in DisneyWorld, how can you hold teachers accountable for test scores when their students are away for lengthy periods of time?

  • Yep

    They don’t take a couple of days, they take a month off. 

    Wealthy parents take kids out for extended vacations, too. A week here, a week there…

  • http://wearenewyorksbrightest.blogspot.com/ Bronx math teacher

    I teach at a middle school in the Bronx and many of my kids make those vacations during mid-December through mid-January. True, it is harder on the students to catch up and for me to work with them for everything they missed, but we work things out before and after the trips. It’s important for kids to see their family back at home… I know because I’m an immigrant to NYC from China and everyone in my family lived in China except for myself and my parents. From my experience, the kids that make these trips are often more refreshed and motivated when they come back. Family and school is hard to juggle together nonetheless.

  • Another Bronx Teacher

    I had several students take over two months off this year.  They are 11th graders, and they wonder why they are failing and have no clue on what’s going on in class.  I sent assignments to them over email every day, and of course I get the usual response, “Oh, I didn’t know I was supposed to bring my textbook with me”.  Two days before the end of the marking period, they show up with a mountain of copied homework and demand full credit because “they were out”.  I wish I could take a two month vacation from work in the middle of the school year, walk back into my principal’s office, and say that I’m not responsible for the work “because I was out”. 

  • Anonymous

    It isn’t just Dominican families. When I worked in a school with a high Caribbean population kids left for Jamaica and Trinidad for a month or two all the time. The fact that the school in the article is seeing less families do this has nothing to do with the school’s discouragement, it is simply a temporary reduction in travel because of the bad economy. Teachers are forced to make a hard decision: do you give out makeup work (which is NOT a substitute for instruction or classroom experienced) and encourage this behavior, or do you fail the child and punish the kid for the irresponsible behavior of the parents. Fine the parents for educational neglect, I say. 

  • Matthew Levey

    The parent and student comments in the essay remind me of the the lines from America, the Sondheim song from West Side Story. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnQR7BLwO2I

    If life back home is so much better, does it not beg the question of why one would leave?

    And if the goal is to make a bigger success here than one could make there, might that not require some sacrifices or compromises?

  • Eddy45

    I think the kids already get several week-long vacations and something called summer off…ain’t that enough?

  • Indianist Online

    Can someone explain me what is study abroad program..plz…

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

11 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031