GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

forward march

Union opposition won’t stop school changes, city officials vow

“Everything you ever do, there’s going to be days where it just doesn’t work,” Mayor Bloomberg told a group of high school students today. “There’s going to be days where somebody says something you don’t like or something goes the wrong way.”

Bloomberg’s message to an 11th-grade English class was meant to inspire students for the future. But it could have just as easily been a self-esteem booster as he slogs through a battle over teacher quality that he started waging when he became mayor 10 years ago.

“Successful people,” Bloomberg told the students about adversity, “recover from that and they learn how to deal with that.”

The visit to the Urban Assembly School for Applied Math and Science was the mayor’s latest stop on a publicity tour to promote a strategy to retain effective teachers and fire the least effective ones. It began in the Bronx last week, at the Morris High School Campus with his State of the City Speech, and continued into this week with a speech on Martin Luther King Day.

In the process, he has picked up substantial support from state officials. Yesterday, both Gov. Andrew Cuomo and State Education Commissioner John King demanded that the state teachers union, NYSUT, drop a lawsuit challenging the state’s teacher evaluation law. King also backed Bloomberg’s plan to win back suspended federal funds by removing teachers at 33 low-performing schools through a process called “turnaround.”

Implementing these plans will require overcoming the opposition of the United Federation of Teachers, which has criticized both the turnaround plan and the city’s preferences for its teacher evaluation system.

Today, both Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Dennis Walcott reiterated their intention to plow ahead, whether they have union support or not. Bloomberg made it clear that he had the political will to get it done, too.

“Now you have the President of the United States, who has made education one of his signature issues, you have the governor and you have the mayor all working together,” Bloomberg said.

Walcott provided some preliminary details about the Department of Education’s plans to handle the turnaround school improvement process. He said a “cross-functional management team” was in place to prepare required descriptions of how the schools would be affected and notified communities in time to meet legal deadlines.

“This process will continue and move forward,” Walcott said. “We can’t just stop because these children need to have high-quality schools and high-quality teachers, plain and simple.”

The union has threatened to sue over the plans because they say that the city is misinterpreting a contract provision, known as 18-D, that governs rehiring at schools that have been closed. Bloomberg said today he hoped the union and its leader would come around.

“We are committed to working with the UFT, which I’ve said before is ably led by the head of the union, Michael Mulgrew,” he said.

Inside the Bathgate Educational Campus, a colorful and gleaming school building in the Claremont section of the Bronx, Bloomberg and Walcott toured two classes led by teachers that the mayor said were particularly effective. In a physics class taught by Allen Hubbard, a third-year teacher who entered the profession through the city’s Teaching Fellows program, students were building a generator made from magnets, copper spring coils, and a hair tie.

“Ever seen generators at a power plant? It’s the same thing,” said Bloomberg, who told the students he was most interested in the sciences when he attended public school in Boston.

Hubbard, a Texan in his mid-twenties who is already in his second career, said he was intrigued by Bloomberg’s proposal of $20,o00 raises for teachers who get top scores on new evaluations. But he said he didn’t need the extra money to stay in the field.

“I worked in consulting before this and made more money but I didn’t enjoy it,” Hubbard said. “And now I enjoy this. It’s absolutely worth the move.”

  • Irony

    So the Mayor spends a few minutes in the classroom of a 3rd year teacher who is in his mid twenties and describes him as “particularly effective”. (I wonder if that is a new category in the proposed teaching evaluation ratings system). 

  • guest

    Wonder if the kids have to build a generator on the physics regents?  Hope your students pass the exam Hubbard or you won’t make it to your 5th year.  Oh he is from the teaching fellows – he wasn’t planning on staying 5 years anyway.

  • Philip Nobile

    Yesterday Bloomberg dipped into excrement to describe the UFT’s position on teacher evaluations. This afternoon Mulgrew continued the street talk at the Delegates Assembly, calling Bloomberg “a baldfaced liar,” who had his “ass beaten” and that his educational ilk “20 years from now will be dragged through the mud of history.”  Mulgrew compared his biweekly breakfasts with the mayor to chapter leaders who have to meet with principals “you hate.” In the not so old days, Klein had a flunky at Tweed dig up dirt on Randi and leak it to the press. In turn, Randi was venomous toward Klein and routinely ridiculed him. Mulgrew mocked him a “Chancellor numb nuts.”
    Shut up. The conversation about the civil rights issue of our day deserves higher consideration. Education is too important to be left to the generals, especially the ones we have in the city, state, and Regents.  

  • Jteach

    You can bring on this evaluation system and we will all find ways to survive…  We will isolate the students who are the most in need of guidance, because their scores will be the most difficult to move.  We will stop challenging the students at the top, because their scores cannot move too much, just give them enough test prep to maintain.  We won’t do the clubs and activities we once did for free, because that is not part of our evaluation.  We won’t take our kids on field trips because that will not help their test scores.  We will bombard our administrators with complaints about assemblies and other events that cause students to miss class because we will lose test prep time.  Above all we will pray… pray that our numbers bounce the right way so that we can all survive till retirement.  But of course the new system will make sure none of us make it.

  • s87j

    Jteach,
    I’d love an honest answer to a question in regard to your last statement. “ Above all we will pray… pray that our numbers bounce the right way so that we can all survive till retirement.  But of course the new system will make sure none of us

    make it.”  A thought out answer and not a rushed and passionate one.  A good portion of the teachers who are fearful or concerneced about the ramifications of this supposed new evaluation have homes, mortgages, bills, children etc etc.  Do you or anyone else  truly believe that hundreds maybe even thousands of teachers who would be hard pressed to find another good paying career (after all we did STUDY to become teachers)  would be let go and have our mortgages or rents go down the drain?  Is this really a reality or is it just natural fear on the part of us that may just be natural worriers?  I ask this in sincerely. 

  • Jteach

    The bottom line is that we just don’t know.  Maybe if this evaluation idea wasn’t being forced on us by someone who we all completely don’t trust (Bloomberg) and maybe we had confidence that our principals were all objective and experienced enough to rate us our worries would be less.  The fact is that we just don’t know and for those of us with 20 years left and mortgages to pay its very scary.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jan  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829