GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

second job

In annual address, Cuomo appoints himself students’ lobbyist

Gov. Andrew Cuomo delivering the State of the State address in Albany today

Students have a new representative in Albany: Gov. Andrew Cuomo.

Right now, Cuomo is delivering his second State of the State address, titled “Building a New New York … with you.”

Education issues account for one and a half of the speech’s 33 pages of prepared remarks. As expected, the governor is calling for an education commission to propose reforms to the state’s education system. That commission will look for ways to boost “teacher accountability and student achievement” and “management efficiency” — both topics Cuomo targeted during his first address a year ago — and will work with the legislature.

He’s also appointing himself chief lobbyist for students, calling them the only group in schools that don’t employ lobbyists of their own.

“This year, I will take a second job — consider me the lobbyist for the students,” he says in the prepared remarks, which he has been known to depart from. “I will wage a campaign to put students first, and to remind us that the purpose of public education is to help children grow, not to grow the public education bureaucracy.”

Some educators are already taking umbrage at the idea that students’ interests aren’t being represented.

A slide that accompanied Cuomo's speech displays a photoshopped mock sign to the office of his new job.

“I vowed to be a lobbyist for students when I became a teacher 42 years ago. Haven’t stopped yet. There are thousands like me,” wrote David Greene, who now mentors Teach for America teachers for Fordham University, on Twitter.

Martha Infante, a Los Angeles teacher, suggested another lobbying force for students and a reason they might be of particular interest to Cuomo. “Their parents? Who vote?” she wrote on Twitter.

We’ll have more about Cuomo’s proposals later today. The full text of Cuomo’s prepared remarks about education is below.

Education Commission to Promote Performance and Accountability

As we reimagine government, we must focus on our core values.

The future of our state depends on our public schools. A strong, effective school system is the hallmark of a healthy democracy.

We must make our schools accountable for the results they achieve and the dollars they spend. I learned my most important lesson in my first year as Governor in the area of public education.

I learned that everyone in public education has his or her own lobbyist.

Superintendents have lobbyists.

Principals have lobbyists.

Teachers have lobbyists.

School boards have lobbyists.

Maintenance personnel have lobbyists.

Bus drivers have lobbyists.

The only group without a lobbyist?

The students.

Well, I learned my lesson. This year, I will take a second job — consider me the lobbyist for the students. I will wage a campaign to put students first, and to remind us that the purpose of public education is to help children grow, not to grow the public education bureaucracy.

Today, we are driven by the business of public educationmore than the achievement in public education. Maybe that’s why we spend more money than any other state but are 38th in graduation rates.

We have to change the paradigm. We need major reform in two areas:

  • Teacher accountability and student achievement. We need a meaningful teacher evaluation system. The legislation enacted in 2010 to qualify for Race to the Top didn’t work.
  • Management efficiency. We must make our schools accountable for the results they achieve and the dollarsthey spend.

We cannot fail in our mission to reform public education,because we simply cannot fail our children.

I will appoint a bipartisan education commission to work with the Legislature to recommend reforms in these key areas.

  • VGW

    Glad to know I wasn’t the only teacher rolling my eyes at that “lobbyist for students” line.   And when he says he will “wage a campaign to put students first,” is it just coincidentally also the name of Rhee’s group?

  • http://perdidostreetschool.blogspot.com/ reality-based educator

    What does bipartisan commission mean?  Both Dems and Repubs have been bought off by the same corporate interests that took former NYSED Commissioner David Steiner to London to be wined and dined for free.  Politicians in BOTH parties push the same corporate-friendly. test-heavy agenda.

    If Cuomo REALLY wants a commission that will look out for students interests, he’d put students on the panel, parents on the panel, education experts who have not been bought off by Pearson and News Corp. and McGraw-Hill and Microsoft/Gates.

    If Cuomo REALLY wanted to look out for the interests of children, he’d ask them if they want to take both city and state tests in every subject four times a year (a total of 20 standardized tests) so that their teachers and schools can be evaluated using these scores and Cuomo’s corporate buddies can rake in the dough.

    If Cuomo REALLY cared about kids, he’d make sure there was enough funding for all children in NY State to eat healthy food, live in a neighborhood safe from crime, go to schools with adequate funding that could be used IN the classroom as opposed to hiring consultants and developing data systems.

    But Cuomo is NOT interested in that. 

    He is interested in helping out his corporate buddies finish off the Shock and Awe they’ve been doing on the public education system for the last ten years since NCLB.

    He is interested in making money for his best buddy, Rupert Murdoch.

  • Transformation Teacher

    Those two bullet points suggest two things: Find more ways to fire teachers, and close more schools. I guess it is true what they say, “great minds(or in this case self-loving tyrants) think alike.

  • Pingback: Cuomo Calls for Education Commission, But Is Vague on Details – New York Times | Best News Feed - Daily News Magazine

  • I noticed that…

    Now that Cuomo has created this new title for himself as Students’ Lobbyist.  It is time for all the students from phasing out schools or schools with grades of D’s and F’s to go up to Albany, knock on that door and to tell Big Brother Andy not to close their schools, to reduce class size, to fund the schools as per the ruling of the Campaign 4 Fiscal Equity Lawsuit decision.   Once he does that he can add to the title Students’ Lobbyist – Accountability Expert, where politics is last.

  • http://nyceducator.com/ NYC Educator

    Well, jeez, Gotham Schools, give the guy a break. You can’t expect him to just come right out and say, “I’m gonna do whatever the hell my corporate hedge fund backers tell me to do.” Give the guy a break. You know, “Students First, No Child Left Behind, Children First, Always.” You don’t go treating THOSE folks like they actually MEAN any of this stuff.

  • old teach

    Governor Cuomo undoubtedly has his eyes on a run for the presidency something his father failed at. If he believes taking on education is one road to that end he is going down a dead end. All of mayor Bloombergs expenditures and publicity could not turn the problems facing education around. Siding with the education reformers will not only lead to failure for a presidential run, it will rapidly diminsh his legacy ala mayor Mike.

  • SickofBloomberg

    Dear Governor Cuomo,

    Allow me to help you correct your obvious ignorance:

    1) Teachers are the de facto lobbyists for students in schools.  We have dedicated our lives and careers to the advancement of our students and for a lot less money than you receive.

    2) Parents are the de facto lobbyists for children in and out of schools.  They have a much better undersatnding of their children’s needs than you will ever achieve.

    3) Last I checked, there is no dearth of qualified students to fill the seats available in colleges or to fill job vacancies requiring college degrees.  In fact, you have failed miserably to provide jobs for those students that are succeeding.

    Keep trying, though.  Your family will get something right one of these days.

  • Los Flerpos

    2016 is a long way off, but I’m pretty confident that future historians won’t be concluding that Cuomo’s presidential run failed because he “sided with the education reformers.”

  • Los Flerpos

    To state the obvious (all too often necessary here):  By “lobbyist,” Cuomo does not mean “people who should care about students,” or “people who say they care about students,” or even “people who really care about students.”  He means professional lobbyists — people who make their living trying to influence legislators and other government officials in a way that benefits the people and institutions that pay for their lobbying activities.  That is the kind of “lobbyist” that students and parents don’t have.  If they did, maybe billions of dollars would be flowing into schools rather than the pockets of retirees. 

    Obviously, Cuomo’s using the term as a cliche and for cheap rhetorical value.  But get the cliche right.

  • Pogue

    Yes, he wants more oligarchy and less democracy.  You nailed it.

  • Nycdoenuts

    Do you mean the same education reformers who he failed to mention also have lobbyists?

  • Nycdoenuts

    or into the pockets of private corporations, and the pockets of private consultants and the pockets of the CEOs of 503c organizations, (who make the same as CEOs of regular corporations).

    Six of one, half billion of the other I guess.

  • Anonymous

    I think if we were focused on teacher achievement and student accountability, we’d be able to provide our students with a much better education in a much more supportive environment.

  • Koozy14

    “This year, I will take a second job — consider me the lobbyist for the students:”  Does this make New York officially a “nanny” state?

  • Koozy14

    $23 billion dollars flows into NYC schools….they need more?

  • http://twitter.com/SoBronxSchool Bronx Teacher

    D’uh, really?????

  • SickofBloomberg

    ” people who make their living trying to influence legislators and other government officials in a way that benefits the people and institutions that pay for their lobbying activities.  That is the kind of “lobbyist” that students and parents don’t have.  If they did, maybe billions of dollars would be flowing into schools rather than the pockets of retirees. ”

    Allow me to help you correct your ignorance also:

    1) Retirees contribute towards their pensions and their pensions are part of their employment contract and is valid compensation.
    2) Lobbyists do not lobby for “interests”, they lobby for money.
    3) Last I heard, colleges are still turning away qualified students, have wait lists, and there is no dearth of qualified college graduates to fill positions.

    Drop you right wing dommsday rhetoric.  No one is buying it.  The only ones suffering are those cheated of vocational degrees because it’s not politically correct.

    Cuomo is just another hack like Rhee, Bloomberg, Klein, et. al. looking to line the pockets of their cronies at the expense of hard working teachers.

  • MB

    Again and again you bring nothing to the table.
    Go far away to lawyer land.

  • Dsico

    Here’s my attempt to mimic the genius known as SickofBloomberg:

    “Allow me to shoot my mouth off a little more as I pontificate about the corporate take-over of the education system.”

    That was fun.

    Since you are such a committed teacher I wonder if you might spend a little more time on the lesson planning, and a little less time writing your pointless drivel.

  • Guest

    Cuomo’s list of lobbyists gives us a clue as to who he might appoint to his education committee. He forgot to mention lobbyists for testing companies, online learning ventures, neoliberal billionaires and conservative think tanks. Perhaps those special interests will be the ones represented on the education committee.

  • http://www.casinogrinder.com Casino Grinder

    And most of it will remain only talks.

  • Joe

    “We need to re-focus where it should be-on the victims. We need to find them; we need to help them; they are our children…When it comes to the safety of children, there can be no margin for error, no hesitation to act.” – Gov. Tom Corbett
    Governor Cuomo and the legislature have made enormous progress in New York State over the past year. This year, there are a few different areas they are hoping to continue their success; pension reform, holding schools accountable, improving the ethical standards of our government,  and thanks to the debacles at Penn State and Syracuse, consider updating the states archaic laws about child abuse. While these appear to be completely separate goals, I would like to suggest a starting point where there is significant overlap.
    There is a Special education teacher in Nassau County in New York State whom pleaded guilty to possessing over 200 child pornography videos on his computer and is now a registered level one sex offender. The titles that were found on his computer cannot be printed but clearly indicate the perversity of this individual. Between the time he was arrested and ultimate resolution of his case, he “retired” and now receives a New York State pension of close to $60,000 a year. In addition, I was stunned to learn, that as far as I know, there are not any requirements for a school to do an investigation to identify any victims. As is often the case, it turns out, this perpetrator spent his lifetime putting himself in a position to have access to children but there was never any attempt to identify victims. Given that a typical perpetrator can abuse 100 victims, this is a scary thought. 
    This is one of many horrific cases that never reached the level of notoriety as some of the recent ones, although it raises a number of specific questions.  When it comes to pension reform, has anyone looked at how many convicted child sex offenders are collecting money from the New York State pension system? Can anyone say we are living up to our moral and ethical obligations when victims of sexual abuse suffer an entire lifetime while perpetrators live off of tax payer money? If we are going to increase school accountability, how about developing guidelines of how an investigation must be conducted and potential victims identified after a school employee has been convicted of a sexual offense so they can get the help they desperately need?  Why not take the money we are currently giving convicted child sex offenders via public pensions and use it to offer treatment to the innocent victims?
    As Governor Corbett said, when it comes to the safety of our children, there can be no margin of error or hesitation. Our Governor and State Legislature will hopefully have the strength to live begin consideration of these issues, which are in fact more aligned with their stated goals than even they may realize. 
     

  • Los Flerpos

    I’d be very surprised to find that there are significant numbers of sex offenders receiving pensions.  It’s a horrible thing in individual cases, to be sure, but I’ve seen no evidence that it’s a systemic problem among NY teachers.   

  • Gov

    Perhaps one year later the Governor will have the courage to actually walk into a public school and see for himself.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

5 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031