GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

peer pressure

As anti-closure rallies expand to high schools, students jump in

A screenshot from the Facebook event advertising a rally to support Juan Morel Campos Secondary School

Community meetings at schools that the Department of Education is considering closing have started attracting a new constituency: students.

That’s because the meetings, which the DOE calls “early engagement conversations,” are now being held at high schools. Until this week, all of the meetings had happened at elementary and middle schools, for which the city released a shortlist of potential closures in September.

One meeting took place Monday evening at Wadleigh Secondary School for Performing Arts, where some members of the school community are arguing that its progress report data aren’t bad enough to warrant closure. Last night, students made the case for keeping Manhattan’s High School of Graphic Communications Arts open. And today, students have recruited crowds to defend Juan Morel Campos Secondary School in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

Tiffany Munoz, a Juan Morel Campos junior who was student body president last year, said students were alarmed when they heard that the school could close and quickly invited hundreds of current and former students to a Facebook event, “Save Juan Morel Campos Secondary School (I.S. 71) From Being Closed.” Tonight, when the school’s superintendent meets with community members, 150 students who RSVPed yes plan to let her know that the school is a tight-knit community with a thriving arts and music program where teachers push students to do their very best.

They’ll be joined by parents and teachers who say they also plan to fight for the school.

“The students are very upset. A lot of them are telling me and my kids if they had to look for another high school they wouldn’t do it,” said Carol Diaz, the mother of two Juan Morel Campos high school students and the secretary of the PTA.

A rally before the engagement meeting was organized in conjunction with advocacy groups from the Coalition for Educational Justice, which has helped parents at a number of schools at risk of being closed push back against the DOE’s characterization that the schools are low-performing. Instead, the rallies argue, budget cuts have held the schools back.

Munoz said she has attended the school since she was in sixth grade and has seen supplies and after-school clubs dry up.

A high school teacher said budget cuts had slashed funding for teachers to run after-school programs or offer late-night tutoring. An evening class for new immigrants that bolstered the school’s graduation rate for English language learners — who make up nearly a third of students — was canceled last year, the teacher said.

“If we had more of the resources that we had in the past, a lot of graduation issues — I’m not going to say it would do everything — would be resolved,” said a high school teacher who asked not to be identified.

The school’s 4-year graduation rate last year was 45.6 percent. But its 6-year graduation rate was 76 percent, suggesting that the school holds on to many students rather than letting them drop out. Just under 60 percent of the members of the 6-year cohort had graduated on time in 2009.

  • Owen

    One way to interpret this data (without a deeper analysis) is, as you suggest, that the school is holding on to kids, rather than letting them drop out.  But that wouldn’t be the cause of the low grade.  Also, I think that interpretation sort of implies that other schools in the peer group would let similar kids drop out, which is probably not accurate. 

    What the numbers suggest to me is that the school is refusing to hand out diplomas until the kids have earned them.  That’s likely what separates them from their peers and that’s a real score killer when it comes to Progress Reports.

  • guest

    Regarding Campos:

    The city is acting especially sloppy in gunning for this sweet, sweet Williamsburg real estate.  JMC includes two distinct, separate schools.  All data used to justify Campos being on the closure list is from the High School side (three C’s in a row is the fatal flaw).  The middle school is not at risk of closure given all criteria – yet the city is presenting the closure of the entire campus – someone at Tweed simply didn’t do their homework.

    Second, the six year graduation rate and decrease in funding are both worth looking at as mentioned above.  Additionally, IS 49 and IS 33, two D14 phased out middle schools have shifted a substantial number of struggling students in the district to the JMC middle school, again which is not “failing” even given the increased burden on the school.

    This school has been a strong anchor in the community for decades and serves the community well, whatever Tweed “war room” the educrats salivated in, looking at a potentially marginal school a short train ride from Chambers Street simply jumped the gun on this one. 

  • Spqr

    Schools centered on the arts shouldn’t be held to these idiotic standards.
    If the students like the school, that alone should be reason to keep it open.
    Bloomberg and his stooges are doing their best to destroy arts programs in schools, and have all but wiped them out in most elementary and middle schools. By the time kids reach high school, they have no training whatsoever.

  • Pingback: In Case You Missed It… « EdVox

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031