GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

allocation appeal

Creative budgeting not enough to close gaps, principals say

Principals are famously told to “be creative” during school budget season. This year is no different, but with cuts to city, state, and federal funding all taking their toll, some school leaders are saying creativity isn’t enough.

Some of them are pushing back, filing appeals with the Department of Education to restore hundreds of thousands of dollars back into to their schools.

Joseph Nobile, a veteran principal at P.S. 304 Early Childhood School in the Bronx, said he and his budget liaison tweaked projections, shuffled funds, and excessed staff to stretch his $4.7 million as far as it could go.

“After all of the moving around, we were still down $350,000,” Nobile said. So for the first time in his 12 years on the job, Nobile said he had no choice but to file an appeal.

Nobile said the money he requested would go toward retaining the school’s lone curriculum coach, as well as four special education specialists. The additional personnel is especially important at P.S. 304 because it is part of a citywide pilot to move as many special education students as possible into mainstream classes.

Schools are feeling the pinch more than ever because of third consecutive year of budget cuts. Adding to that, the city made it tougher for some schools with large percentages of poor students to qualify for federal aid.

As a result, the number of appeals this year could far outnumber last year’s total of 166.

A DOE spokeswoman said she wouldn’t know how many appeals are being filed until July 22, when the final budgets are due.

At P.S. 3, a growing school in the West Village, principal Lisa Siegman said her budget would not have allowed her to open in September.

“I couldn’t staff the school for the classrooms,” Siegman said of her $5.4 million baseline budget.

Enrollment from students zoned for her school was projected to increase and she is required by law to provide seats for that population. To satisfy those mandates, Siegman has to hire to new teachers, but there wasn’t money in her budget for it.

Siegman, who estimated that her appeal was for about $245,000, said her hands were tied when it comes to these budget requirements and class size limits.

“I can make creative decisions. I can have a teacher doing two different jobs within a school. I can decide to have  a literacy coach or not a literacy coach,” Siegman said. “But I can’t allocate more funds. I can’t go to larger class sizes.”

  • It’s Unreal

    Dear Mr. Decker,

    Nice article you have here, however, if you’re going to write about principals, you might want to do a breaking story of how a number have retired and are retiring and being allowed to pick their replacement.  Why do they pick their replacement?  They do so on purpose with the understanding that the new selected principal (and fiend) will hire them back at “F Status” for $$$$.  Do you have any idea how many principals were placed into their positions with this understanding?  This is a rampid practice.  I put you in AND you owe me!  There are former principals all over the city working as “consultants” or “mentors” at various locations where they placed their replacements strategically.  These principals are making the “F Status” rate which is around $400 – $500 daily!  You can double check the F Status rate.  It’s all about the “Kickbacks” and it is happening EVERYWHERE!!!

  • SparkleMotion

    Don’t forget about retired principals working now as quality reviewers!

  • anonymous

    and consultants, and network leaders, and working for companies that do business with the DOE, it goes on and on—strangely unreported but rampant corruption. This is one sitting principal that finds it disgusting.

  • Ms. A

    Wow…..how incredibly disgusting. And to think our mayor and his minions continue to purport that this department of education puts “children first”. What an absolute joke!
    When will this stop? It is all so maddening….

    By the way I have been looking for a principal who puts children first, who is principled and still values integrity. So “anonymous” if you need a school counselor, I’m available….let’s change the world! 

  • Ms. A

    Wow…..how incredibly disgusting. And to think our mayor and his minions continue to purport that this department of education puts “children first”. What an absolute joke!
    When will this stop? It is all so maddening….

    By the way I have been looking for a principal who puts children first, who is principled and still values integrity. So “anonymous” if you need a school counselor, I’m available….let’s change the world! 

  • A47

    What is the impact on students with special needs when this happens?

  • Arihsteinfeld

    I think the bigger question should be how and why Principals need more money. If you argue that they need more money to keep class sizes down and provide necessary school based activities for the students that is fine, but most Principals want the money so they can hire friends to become Assistant Principals and take care of those who have allegience to them. The number of supervisors in this system has exploded since Principals were given the authority they now have, and most of these jobs are part time positions at best. They should have the money but the authority of Principals has to be stripped away. They have proven that self interest takes precedent over school needs.

  • Cmorris50

    That’s “rampant” practice, not “rampid” practice!

  • Coespinoza

    For everything that a Principal does believe me the pay is not enough!!!  It is interesting that teachers or insubordinates think they are going through these tough times by themselves. At least you have union protection where administrators don’t.  Let’s not froget our contracts are longer and we are one person trying to make sure fifty to hundred of you have all the necessary means and accomondations to educate our #1 priority (students!). Principals are not out to get you, they are about assuring ways to maintain organizational control so you can do your job effectively.  FYI budget cuts affect everyone no matter where you are.   

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031