GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Tsk Force

Officials form parent leader task force after botched elections

Poorly-handled Community Education Council elections has prompted elected officials to form a new task force of parents that promises to “overhaul” their role in the public school system.

Borough President Scott Stringer and Public Advocate Bill DeBlasio spearheaded efforts to organize parents into the task force over the last several weeks. Today, they announced the group will hold first meeting next week.

“We need real parental involvement, and that begins with making the CECs more democratic and meaningful,” DeBlasio said in a statement.

In advance of the June 22 meeting, a survey was emailed out to hundreds of newly-elected parents this morning to solicit their opinions on how to improve the CECs. Officials said they weren’t sure how many parents would make up the task force, or how long it would last.

Details on what specifically needs to change are also vague. Some parent leaders, such as Noah Gotbaum, an outspoken critic of the CEC structures, have called for an entirely independent office from the DOE.

Others, such as Mary Silver, a CEC member in District 2 since 2005, believe smaller-scale changes could make a big difference.

“Training is key,” said Silver. “My experience has been – because it’s a two year term – it takes parents about a year and a half for them to figure out what exactly their role is. By then, they’re about ready to leave.”

The CECs are made up of volunteer parents and participation often wanes. Many struggle to fill the seats needed to operate as official functioning bodies.

Parental involvement is uniformly hoisted by education advocates as key contributors to a child’s education, including Schools Chancellor Dennis Walcott. But the department has tightly managed their voices since Mayor Bloomberg has controlled of the school system..

And critics believe that the mishandled elections are a more realistic barometer of the city’s educational priorities.

The perception of a dwindling parental role seemed to be punctuated earlier this month at the city council budget hearing for education. As part of alternative cuts proposed to Chancellor Dennis Walcott, Speaker Christine Quinn suggested the DOE slash nearly $1 million from the budget for Office of Family Information and Action, which oversees the parent leadership.

In making the task force announcement, Stringer and DeBlasio – and the four other borough presidents with a hand in creating it – weren’t specific about what kind of changes they’d like to see.

“I am confident our new Task Force will give light to the voices of those who are most affected by decisions about our schools – and develop a set of strong, smart recommendations for enabling these bodies to play the role they were intended to in our educational process,” Stringer said in a statement.

  • Marat

    Geoffrey Decker, I’m seeing you be more critical of Bloomberg’s Ed reign than any other “reporter” on Gotham Schools has ever been. I like it. Keep going!

  • Michael M. (parent still)

    First, a sincere welcome to GD.

    I dare say Noah Gotbaum is NOT “an outspoken critic of the CEC structures.”  Clarification needed? 

    As the current President of CEC3 and a leader of the loose band of CEC members and candidates who worked together with Manhattan BP Stringer and Public Advocate de Blasio to try and keep this CEC-lection fiasco from hitting the rocks (to little avail, given even the redo had problems), Noah may have been better characterized as an outspoken critic of the office OVERSEEING the CEC structures, namely OFIA, which oversees the leadership structures more than the leadership proper.

    As a participant in that ad hoc group, this is one reason I, and a number of the others, hold the opinion that future CEC elections should be taken out of DOE’s hands.  This election — a fundamental responsibility of OFIA and its head — was a multi-month train wreck in slow motion.  With plenty of us waving warning flags in futility.

    I look forward to working with the new “Tsk” Force, so that future
    elections aren’t such a farce, but more importantly, that parent
    participation in policy-making is encouraged, given full voice and a fair hearing, mayoral control or no. 

    P.S.  Parent “training” would help, most certainly.  But no amount of training
    would have changed frequent “no” or “abstain” votes to anything
    productive.  PTA selectors in D2 took note.

    Michael D. Markowitz, P.E.
    Member, CEC2, 2007-2011
    Member-select, CECD2, 2011-2013

  • Ellen

    “Parental involvement is uniformly hoisted by education advocates as key
    contributors to a child’s education, including Schools Chancellor Dennis
    Walcott”

    A case of being hoisted on their own petard?  Who is kidding who here?  The issue is parents as partners, not participant or trainees.  We are not passive, but passionate!  Parents, with a multi-tiered involvement, least to most, have information and guidance to offer the DOE at the classroom, school, district and citywide level.  The unfortunate part is that the the system has grown so suspicious of any outside interest that even the most basic of partnerships have been drastically damaged.  As parents we are dismayed at the shutout, as staff members, there is so much fear that communication is minimal.
    Friction, such as the friction of a piston in  an engine, impels movement and can bring the conversation from accusation to action.
    Friction is a necessary, but not an evil, element of physics.

  • tired parent

    Are the elections still botched  when the accusers win? Oh Please

  • Michael M. (parent still)

    I’d prefer to think of it as the elections were botched… and a number of winners are trying to fix if for the next generation.

    I can only imagine what you’d say if those of us still carrying the issue… had lost.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031