GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

leave no parent behind

NYC parent forms national group to push for ESEA change


Education historian Diane Ravitch spoke to the Parents Across America audience last night.

One of New York City’s most vocal parent activists is launching a national organization, enlisting parents in cities across the country in a fight against the Obama administration’s proposed changes to the Elementary and Secondary Education Act.

Called Parents Across America, the group was developed jointly by Leonie Haimson, the executive director of Class Size Matters in New York, and Julie Woestehoff, of Parents United for Responsible Education (PURE) in Chicago. Its formal launch was at a forum last night in a public school in Tribeca, where parents from as far as San Francisco and Seattle traveled to share their unfortunate experiences with local education laws and policies.

Parents Across America’s platform is against much of what Secretary of Education Arne Duncan has done, such as his competitive grant program Race to the Top, and the federal School Improvement Grants he’s given to states to turn around their lowest-performing schools. The organization also opposes Duncan’s blueprint for what he wants out of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act’s eventual reauthorization.

A letter written to Duncan last spring, and signed by many of the organization’s leaders, admonishes the Secretary for keeping parents at arm’s length. It states:

A central flaw in this administration’s approach is the complete failure to encourage parent involvement in decision-making. Studies show that the more involved parents are at the school level, the better their children’s outcomes. Yet the proposed education budget would eliminate the sole funding dedicated to family engagement, and the ESEA Blueprint removes essential mechanisms for engaging parents at the school or district level.

PAA’s other suggestion is that the federal government push for small class sizes to increase student achievement. In her opening remarks to the middle school’s filled auditorium, education historian Diane Ravitch placed these ideas in opposition to those supported by groups like the Gates Foundation.

“This is a group that has no interest other than the well-being of children,” she said, noting that for “corporate reformers,” “children are an abstraction.”

Some of the parents who spoke said that the federal government’s reliance on standardized testing and the support for charter schools had hurt their and other children’s schooling at the local level.

One mother from New Orleans, Karran Harper Royal, said she had to sue the city to get public transportation for her son to and from his charter school. She hadn’t wanted to send him to a charter school to begin with, she said, but after Hurricane Katrina hit, his school was reopened as a charter and she wanted to keep him in the same building “for normalcy,” she said.

Haimson explained that when she and Woestehoff began looking to fight issues like charter school expansion and standardized testing at the federal level, they hadn’t found any larger groups with which to align themselves.

“We were looking for a group on the national level that reflected the point of view of the majority of public school parents and we could not find a single one,” Haimson said.

There are national parent associations, but Haimson said they are “pretty much silent” when it comes to issues she and Woestehoff believe are important. And after years of working together to changes policies in New York and Chicago, they both wanted to target federal policy.

“A lot of the issues we’d been fighting on the local level were now being imposed nationally,” Haimson said. “And there’s no point in trying to stop Bloomberg or the State Education Department if they can say, ‘Oh no no, the Obama administration is making us do this.’”

Haimson said the organization has plans to travel to D.C. to lobby for changes to ESEA and is also focusing on building local chapters around the country. For financial support, it is relying on contributions from its membership and from the country’s largest teachers union, the National Education Association, which helped pay for the forum.

  • KitchenSink

    “no interest but the well being of children” and the NEA’s membership. And the latest culture wars drone on…

  • Bobbie

    Leonie Haimson just went from parent advocate to union consultant in one day; from independent to dependent on the NEA. RIP Leonie. Your message will forever be distrusted from this day forth. 

  • Mustafa

    ^^^Complete nonsense, both of the comments above. Leonie’s fighting a noble battle against corrupt individuals with deep pockets. You couldn’t be more wrong.

  • http://nyceducator.com NYC Educator

    It’s nice to read something here about a group that is not insane, or yet another front Gates-funded “grassroots” organization.

    We’d like to hear more about visionary people like these, please.

  • Akademos

    It’s nice to get a glimpse of the true future of education after all of this ongoing toxicity, deterioration, nonsense, and death.

  • GC

    Kitchen Sink: Aren’t 16 years of the failed reforms out of Chicago enough? That is Arne Duncan’s platform. Arne Duncan, who thought Katrina was the best thing to happen to New Orleans. 16 years of privatization in Chicago, breaking down big schools etc. has resulted in no change at all. It didn’t work in San Diego or Philly (Edison Schools), it’s not working in NYC or New Orleans. No Intel/Westinghouse semi finalists in NYC for the 1st time ever, grade inflation, lowering cut scores to get the Mayor elected again, the gap in achievement racially (Klein’s Civil Rights issue – right) wider than ever, phony gains touted by politicians, cheating scandals, good principals tossed out to get federal money, parents shut out of decisions re: their tax money and their children, Charter School magnates running a few schools making half a million a year from taxpayer money while Cuomo calls for a limit on Supt. salaries in traditional districts, spending money on advertising schools, people have had enough, this was bound to happen at some point. People are tired of rich folks playing with their Blackberries when they should be listening.

  • Mustafa

    ^^^How do you like them apples?

    Well said, GC.

  • http://www.classsizematters.org leonie haimson

    Thanks for this report. Parents Across America stand for a whole host of reforms that have been proven to work and that will strengthen our public schools, rather than undermine them.

    I urge people to look at our website and read our statement, “What we believe” and if you agree, join with us!

    http://parentsacrossamerica.org/what-we-believe

  • http://Gotham Queenie

    GC, sing it brother!

  • Lisa

    Thank you! It seems there may be some hope for our children, after all.

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ norm

    GC
    Why would Kitchen Sink be concerned about the 95% of the kids getting screwed as long as he has his own little gig? Oh, those lamentable culture wars. One day just for a laugh, I have to extract that tape of Kitchen Sink at the Perkins charter school hearing last March whining away about his awful 4 years in 2 different public schools before slinking away with his tail between his legs.

  • http://www.foxnews.com Alex Trenton

    Can we dispense with the pretense that this group represents any “parents” outside of a few mostly-white, middle-aged, wealthy, liberal, union-funded busybodies? 

  • Mustafa

    Alex, give us a break. The Tweedies are out in force tonight. Getting paid overtime maybe?

    Norm, I’d like to see that video.

  • Alan

    I wouldn’t care if this group represented people from Mars. They are trying to change this education secretaries policies. Go get them.

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ norm

    I started posting videos of the meeting at Ed Notes and will post some more tomorrow. I challenge Alex or other ed deformers to find one thing they say over 2 hours that doesn’t make sense. Their reports made me feel I was watching the Broad Academy version of the Night of the Living Dead – and we have just such a poster up on ed notes.

    If I get time Mustafa I will dig through the archives for that video.Maybe I’ll put up a picture of a kitchen sink over audio.

  • GC

    Alex, Can we dispense with the Deformer motto “Children First” – how about “Profits First”. Interesting your use of the term “liberal”. Don’t Obama and Duncan profess to be liberals? I don’t think they would be members of this organization. And about that term “white’. Whitney Tilson? Bill Gates? The Walton Family, Eva Moscowitz, Mike Bloomberg, Joel Klein, Eli Broad, Warren Buffet, George Soros, almost the entire Tweed bureaucracy, Cathie Black, Arne Duncan… and about those terms you are tossing about, middle aged, rich…See the problem with stereotyping? How your comments parallel those of Mayor Hosni Moneybags about democracy – people being “busybodies” as you put it are doing just that, just as those making noise and protesting at a public meeting are.
    How annoying the “little people” are to you and your pals. And about your use of the term wealthy – if they are so rich why do they need funds from unions?

  • Pingback: “Night Cap” | NYCORE: Who’s Schools, Our Schools Conference | Our Schools NYC

  • Pingback: Parents Across America forum featuring Diane Ravitch « Parents Across America

  • Ellen

    When I clicked on Alex Trenton the link took me to the “Fair and Balanced” Fox News site….interesting

  • Taxpayer in PA

    Advocates for so called public Charter schools are those who see mega public $$$ to be had if they buy off enough politicians to do their bidding. Look at those who are involved…None with educational backgrounds…Gates, Waltons, Bloomberg, Broads, Saros. Billionaires whose sole goal in life is and always will be the accumulation of money. It’s not about the children or educating them: it’s about destroying the American dream and creating a 2 class society. It’s about turning education into profitable business ventures for the Wall Street crowd at the expense of the welfare of nation’s children and taxpayers nationwide.

  • Tiffany

    Thank you from one parent in California who is happy to see other parents standing up against the rising tide of privatization. I have two children about to enter the public school system next year, and i’m worried what awaits them. I believe strongly in our public institutions and what a good education provides.

  • Pingback: Notes from New York – Our forum with Diane Ravitch (& other tales) | Seattle Education 2010

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

From Our Jobs Board

Featured Employers
Recent Jobs

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

June 2013
M T W T F S S
« May  
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930