GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

decision time

City adds 14 schools to planned closure list, bringing total to 26

The city announced plans to shutter an additional 14 schools this morning, making a total of 26 schools that may either close entirely or begin to phase out starting next fall.

Yesterday, city officials announced their plans to close 11 district schools and recommended that the state not renew the charter of Ross Global Academy, a Manhattan charter school.

The final list of planned closures includes most — but not all — of the schools the city originally proposed to close last year before it was blocked by a lawsuit brought by the city teachers union, the NAACP and other groups.

Citing improvements the schools have made over the past year, the city is sparing four of the 19 schools the city proposed closing last year: the Choir Academy of Harlem, W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School, the Middle School for Academic and Social Excellence and the Business, Computer Applications and Entrepreneurship High School.

The city is proposing that most of the schools on its list stop admitting new classes next year and phase out over time. For two schools, KAPPA II and the Academy for Collaborative Education, the city plans to shutter all grades at once at the end of this year.

City officials culled the final list of 25 district schools to close from a larger list of 55 schools that they targeted for possible closure earlier in the fall. Of the 30 schools on that list that were spared today, 14 may still undergo one of two federally-approved strategies for school improvement.

One of those scenarios, known as the “turnaround” model, requires that the schools’ principals be replaced and its staff and teachers re-apply for their jobs; only half may be re-hired. The other model, known as “transformation,” relies on replacing the principal, bringing in outside support services and experimenting with new teacher training and school schedules.

The city and union are currently in talks over which schools might use each model.

Here is the final list of schools the city wants to close. The schools highlighted below were announced today.

picture-2

  • Mitch

    “Oh what a tangled web we weave…”

  • NYC Teacher

    Happy to see that my school was not on the list (we were one of the 55.)  However disappointed that the city once again is choosing to close rather than help schools.  As many have stated in other posts, some of these schools (JFK, Beach Channel) were once among the top public schools in NYC. Unfortunately the city chooses to ignore them and let them fail rather then put more effort and resources into them.

  • bookworm

    Three generations of my family went to John Adams, as did many of my friends in my old neighborhood. I work at a school now that feeds into Adams, or would if there were still zones. It’s heartbreaking to see so much history being disregarded in the name of “progress”. I also had many friends who went to Lane (now closed), Richmond Hill, and Beach Channel, also from families who had gone to these schools for generations. Richmond Hill, Adams, and Beach Channel always had great reputations when I lived in that area of Queens. I’ve spent a good part of my teaching career trying to teach in the schools that I attended as a student, only to watch it all get torn apart with no regard for the school’s history or community pride.

  • Leonie

    How cab they legally close zoned elem and middle schools w/ out CEc assent?

  • Ms. Smith

    Wow, pretty soon the ATR’s will outnumber the appointed staff in NYC. Hum? Wonder what the 2 Mikes have in store for them? Not anything good I’m sure.

  • Howard

    Mike Klonsky is the guest tonight. Michelke Rhee’s attention grabbing students first organization among topics to be discussed.

    blogtalkradio.com/bronx-teacher/2010/12/08/the-mind-of-a-bronx-teacher

  • Peter

    It was interesting to look at what teachers say about their closing schools on the Environment Surveys (posted for each school on the DOE site) … haven’t looked at them all but in the one’s I scanned the teachers in the closing schools were highly critical of the school leadership, parents were generally positive about the school.

    The Progress Report also list schools in the peer group, schools with similar student populations.

    It would be interesting to know why schools with similar populations perform so differently.

  • Alan Coles

    With the closing of all these school’s, what’s the sense in belonging to a union that is not going to fight for it’s members. I think it’s time for these union members to stop contributing their union dues to a union that’s just watching as many lose their jobs.

  • Truth

    What is install for the remaining schools?

  • richard mangone

    The Department of Education has failed not the schools that are being closed. This is a political agenda and the students and communities are the victims. Beach Channel High School by the year 2014 will cease to exist. Along with Far Rockaway High School these two schools serviced the academic needs of the Rockaway peninsula. By 2014 there will be no large Academic High School to service one of the poorest minority communities in the city. How many students will now be forced to travel long distances to attend high school? How many will drop out or worse turn to a life of crime? Will the new smaller learning communities wish to accept the community students if they are not on track? Will they be accepting only the students who will make their new schools look like a success? This is the legacy of the Klein administration. There has been renovations taking place at Beach Channel for the past 4 years. What were they preparing for? The community should be outraged and the NAACP and minority parents should be contacting their local political leaders to fight this travesty.

  • Ms. K.

    LOOK OUT:
    Layoffs coming BIGTIME for teachers. Guess who said, “ATR’s going first but NOT by seniority”. Whoa.

  • Michael M.

    Re Leonie @ 4:07 pm.

    Indeed, that was one of the two related reasons that CECD2 (of which I was then and am still a member), certain of its members individually (not including me personally), and Randi Weingarten as then-President of UFT… SUED (filed a Petition and Complaint) the Board of Ed (aka the PEP) and Chancellor Klein back in May 2009.

    www (dot) cecd2 (dot) net. Click thru to “Lawsuit.”

    “(ii) opened and closed schools and added and ended programs in District 2 without consulting CEC District 2.”

    Withdrawn without prejudice in Sept 2009, on advice of counsel. Sigh.

    The thinking was that there is a whole new Mayoral Control law, let’s see if Tweed shapes up. Hah. See scorpion and frog at the river, etc.

  • Jerry Wasserman

    The New York City Mayor and school chancellor are systematically destroying the New York City public school system. It has apparently been their agenda to do this and let Blumberg’s millionaire friends take over the system with charter schools. SHAME !

  • Mr. Teacher

    I am in a school on the state list — Dewey. We have not yet been chosen for any model… and so we wait. The closure of more large comprehensive high schools is a sham. Closing large schools as a strategy to fix education is unbelievably short sighted. It disrupts the continuity of communities and the students are not benefitting from these long commutes that “school choice” forces upon them. Many of my students have family responsibilities and need to be in their communities. Boombug with his billions doesn’t understand how difficult it is for struggling families and at-risk students. Having a bunch of young inexperienced teachers will not fix our educational system. We need to bring back real and meaningful parent involvement and get rid of PEP or the Panel for Educational Puppetry. I hope people will get active. Now is the time if we are to keep the public in public education.  

  • Pingback: Insideschools.org : Blogs

  • Pingback: Insideschools.org : Blogs

  • Pingback: Insideschools.org : Blogs

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

3 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031