GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

red on black

Legal challenges to Black appointment could come within days

Protestors gathered on the steps of Tweed Courthouse to demand that Mayor Michael Bloomberg withdraw his appointment of publishing executive Cathleen Black as chancellor.

Wearing red to demonstrate their opposition to Mayor Michael Bloomberg's choice of publishing executive Cathleen Black for chancellor, protestors gathered on the steps of DOE headquarters at Tweed Courthouse today.

Although publishing executive Cathleen Black cleared the last formal hurdle to her appointment as chancellor on Monday, opponents of her appointment aren’t giving up yet.

More than 100 people converged on the steps of the Department of Education’s headquarters at Tweed Courthouse this evening — the largest protest yet against Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s choice for chancellor — and legal action to block the appointment may be coming within days.

Roger Wareham, an attorney working with City Councilman Charles Barron and the Freedom Party, said he plans to file suit against State Education Commissioner David Steiner, who this week waived the legal credential requirements that Black needed to become chancellor.

Wareham said that the lawsuit, which will likely be on behalf of four parent plaintiffs, would be filed “in the next few days,” and will accuse the commissioner of abuse of power, arbitrary and capricious actions and abuse of discretion.

The group that organized the rally, the Deny the Waiver Coalition, is also working with civil rights attorney Norman Siegel to explore legal options to block Black from assuming office in January.

And rally organizers said that they planned to increase the pressure on the mayor to simply withdraw his appointment of Black.

Barron, who led the rally, said that protests are planned outside of Tweed for each day next week, followed by protests the following week outside of the residences of Black, Bloomberg and Steiner. Legislation has already been introduced in Albany by Assemblymen Hakeem Jeffries and Marcos Crespo to change the waiver process, and at least one other legislator is preparing similar legislation.

Black had visited Tweed earlier in the day, but left before the protest started, a DOE spokesman said.

City officials have repeatedly characterized the opposition to Black’s appointment as politically-motivated and driven by opponents of mayoral control, and some observers have argued that the opposition is limited to a few outspoken education activists.

And while many of the speakers at today’s rally were veterans of protests against Bloomberg’s education policies, many were parents or teachers who said that they found Bloomberg’s appointment of an education outsider to be an insult to their years of service in the classroom and the graduate degrees they are required to hold for their positions.

“We have doctorates,” yelled two Brooklyn teachers standing in the crowd. “She won’t be our boss.”

“In every area of the city, teachers are being laid off, one by one by one,” said Donald Hudson, the pastor of a Long Island church. “And they are qualified.”

  • NYCParent

    The photo looks like it was taken between 4-4:30, while there was still daylight.  Your article states about 100 people showed up.   By 5:00, by which time it was dark, and by my personal “groups of 20″ crowd count, I estimate 400-500 people were filling the steps of Tweed.  Let’s keep doubling the count NY!  We have five rallies at Tweed next week — one night for each borough.  (Monday– Manhattan, Tuesday — Brooklyn, and Fri — Staten Island.  Can someone chime in with the order for Queens and the Bronx?)

  • Teacher of LD kids

    Good for you, NYC Parent! Keep us posted – when I can, I WILL show up. I’m tired of Bloomberg and his high-handed arrogance. Black is neither “qualified” nor “otherwise qualified” for this job. I have a 58-credit masters degree, two State licenses, and a national Board certification. Why should Black be the boss of ME?

  • Teacher in Red

    Approx 85,000 teachers + who know how many retirees, only total up to a few hundred on the steps of Tweed? I was there! How can we get the word out so its not this embarassing?
    This was less than 1% showing. The mayor is saying ok, less than 1% of teachers are protesting, that’s not an issue at all. Looks like 99% are ok with Ms. Black then.

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ norm

    People were asking, “Where’s Mulgrew?”
    The UFT has a blanket on news to the members. Get active in your schools and pass the word. There are 1700 schools and there needs to be one person in each school to counter the Unity Caucus spin. Come to the GEM meeting on Tuesday and/or the Teachers Unite meeting on Weds and join the movement for Real Reform.

  • question

    Why exactly are you upset about Black? Is it because you’re angry with Bloomberg or because you have concerns about Black’s performance in her old job? 

  • Michael M.

    question,

    Answer: Neither.

    It’s because I — and many, many, others — have concerns about Black with respect to her PENDING job.

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ norm

    I’m not upset at all. As an organizer against the mayor having control of the schools she is the best thing that could happen. Now I as a self-contained classroom teacher in elementary school, had decent managerial skills – though I will admit I saw people with astounding skills in managing a class of children they taught all day in almost all subjects. I wonder if you would be upset if I was hired to manage the building you live in due to my classroom managerial skills? When you call to tell me the toilet is running I’ll just say, “Go catch it.”

  • question

    I think neither of you fully understands what it means to run an organization. 

  • Michael M.

    Q,

    Are you suggesting there’s no difference between publishing magazines and educating kids? If all organization managers are interchangeable, then why not hire Joe Torre, or insist CB has at least an MBA?

  • Michael M.

    Oops… have.
    If I’d gone to an ischool or a charter that wouldn’t have happened.

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ Norm

    When you run a classroom you are running an organization. And principals run schools and Supt run multiple schools. I call all of that running organizations of various sizes, some way bigger than anything Black has done.
    I would trust many of the teachers I worked with to run the schools than I would Cathie Black -

  • http://theinsurgentteacher.blogspot.com Maria Rosa

    As Adam Clayon Power, Jr. said, “keep the faith, baby!”   “The people united never defeated!”
    “El pueblo unido jamas sera vencido.!”   “Keep hope alive!”

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

17 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031