GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

making their case

City formally asks state to approve Black’s bid for chancellor

Mayor Michael Bloomberg has formally asked the state to approve his choice for chancellor, publishing executive Cathie Black.

Because Black lacks the education credentials legally required to be chancellor, State Education Commissioner David Steiner must grant Black a waiver allowing her to take the post. State law allows the commissioner to waive the requirements for chancellor candidates who are “exceptionally qualified.”

Black has almost no experience in public school systems in New York or elsewhere, and the mayor’s surprise appointment of her last week has caused an uproar from critics who believe the chancellor should have experience in schools.

In a six-page letter to Steiner released this evening, Bloomberg makes the argument that Black’s extensive experience in the magazine publishing world, including fifteen years as the head of Hearst Magazines, will translate into the skills she will need to run the nation’s largest public school system.

For example, Bloomberg argues that Black’s experience starting a digital media unit at Hearst shows that she can help schools teach students more technologically advanced skills and improve the way that schools track and improve student progress. He also contends that because Black saw Hearst through financial challenges that precipitated layoffs and the closure of struggling magazines, she will be prepared to handle the steep budget reductions city schools will likely face in the next year.

The next step will be for Steiner to appoint a panel that will review Bloomberg’s case for Black. The panel will issue a non-binding recommendation to Steiner, who will then announce his decision. It’s not clear when Steiner will appoint his panel or when he will make his final decision.

We will have much more on the mayor’s formal case for Black tomorrow. (Tonight we are throwing a party!) But in the meantime, the mayor’s letter to Steiner is below. Please share your observations on the letter in the comments!

  • Ms. Smith

    What a joke! The mayor cries meritocracy in the schools while being a totally nepotistic! What a hypocrite.

  • peter

    David Steiner can determine the legacy and the future of the mayor, in his heart of hearts he cannot approve of Black, but, power brokers whisper you don’t want Bloomberg as an enemy ..sleepless nights for a decent, caring guy.

  • Jerk

    Anybody have a copy of the waiver request for Klein from back in the day?

  • Invictus

    Next, if Black is given a go, then, perhaps all those who potentially want to work with NYC school children but have other impediments, such as criminal records (ranging from shoplifting, to murder and even more disturbing offenses) will be allowed to ‘teach’ with a special ‘dispensation’/waiver, from NYSDept of Ed?  

    Our Supreme Leader is daring and as egotistical with this move as many madmen before him.

    Peter, powerbrokers or not powerbrokers should not even be an issue.  Nothing short of a denial, will probably doom NYSED from what little educational credibility they have left, regardless, not that they have much left of it anyway.  

  • baseball fan

    Gee, with those qualifications, I think Cathie Black should be the manager of the Yankees.  I wonder how that would go over.  Her extraordinary qualifications override the fact that she knows very little about playing baseball…

  • bookworm

    I have to wonder, if this goes through, about the ramifications for school districts throughout the state. The precedent would, theoretically, allow any school board to appoint any chosen political crony as superintendent and then ask for a waiver. The waiver could become the norm, not the exception. And isn’t this the type of situation the reason why a good many of our state education laws were written in the first place?

  • Mustafa

    The dog that used to urinate on the tree by my neighborhood school has a greater connection to public schools than Cathie Black. ;)

  • An Effective Teachers Says…

    “For example, Bloomberg argues that Black’s experience starting a digital media unit at Hearst shows that she can help schools teach students more technologically advanced skills and improve the way that schools track and improve student progress.”

    Hmm… assigning experts in computer technology to transform magazines to a digital format is the same thing as doing it herself thus making her an expect on technology. Good for her. And obviously being able to turn on a computer makes her an expert in statistics and data interpretation too. I heard she can leap small buildings in a single bound.

    “He also contends that because Black saw Hearst through financial challenges that precipitated layoffs and the closure of struggling magazines, she will be prepared to handle the steep budget reductions city schools will likely face in the next year.”

    Children First! Let’s start the layoffs and building closures! So this is what she’s really an expert in then! Firing teachers across the board and closing down public schools – heck why not? She never needed a public school in her life.

  • Allen

    Wow what an impressive resume!!. What 99 % of it has to do with education has got me. When was the last time she stepped into a nyc classroom. Actually rumor has it that she was once a principal for a day. Did not see that on the letter. So I guess that one day qualifies her to be a principal at least. And of course she is a financial whiz, although by her own admission she always has hated dealing with numbers. And as far as dealing with diversity, does she even know what the racial mix is in the nyc schools. Before we make her chancellor I would love to have her spend a day in one of my classes and see the obstacles we face as teachers to get students to want to learn. If you ask me this whole process in an insult to the intelligence of all the constituents of nyc who see how qualifications do not matter and its all about political connections.

  • Pingback: Deciding who should lead NYC’s schools - EdVANTAGE Blog - The Official Blog of the New York State Council of School Superintendents

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031