GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

black's basics

“Superstar manager” Black arrives with short education resume

Cathie Black published an advice book for women in business in 2007.

Cathie Black published an advice book for women in business in 2007.

The next New York City Schools Chancellor surpasses Joel Klein in at least one regard: the amount of mystery surrounding her views on education.

While Klein had graduated from the city school system and taught math to sixth-graders before being appointed chancellor, Cathleen Black’s experience appears to be limited to a less than year-long stint on a charter school advisory board.

But in appointing Black, Mayor Michael Bloomberg may have been looking for someone who will steer a calm and steady course forward, rather than someone to bring bold new ideas for education reform.

When he announced Black’s appointment this afternoon, Bloomberg trumpeted her track record of “building on successes and leading teams to even greater achievements.” And Black vowed this afternoon to build on the work that Klein has rolled out over the past eight years.

Black, 66, is a formidable figure in the publishing industry. Before going to Hearst in 1995, she had worked as the publisher of both New York Magazine and USA Today,  as well as the head of the Newspaper Association of America.

She has very little experience in public service or in public education. Her two children both attended private boarding schools, and she attended parochial school as a child on Chicago’s South Side.

A book she published in 2007, “Basic Black,” summarized the principles she followed to become a leader, from the importance of choosing battles carefully to her belief that one should “lead with affection – but don’t call it that at the office.”

At the press conference this afternoon, Black was warm but direct, speaking in short, to-the-point sentences that contrasted Klein’s more passionate, meandering style. “I have no illusions about this being an easy next three years — quite the opposite,” she said.

Black oversaw periods of both rapid growth and financial challenges during her 15-year tenure at Hearst. Last year, when Crain’s New York named her the 16th most powerful woman in New York, the magazine noted that the company’s ad sales plummeted 24 percent during the first half of 2009. But during the same year, Black oversaw the company’s most successful magazine launch in nearly a decade, of the Food Network Magazine.

Black was also known for avoiding some of the internal tumult and turnover that has plagued other top magazine publishers, said a media reporter who covered Hearst. She has kept a low public profile and has described her managerial approach as non-confrontational.

“She looks you straight in the eye, she’s tough, she’s demanding, she works very hard, she’s a motivator, she’s highly respected, she’s very articulate, she has supreme confidence about who she is and what she represents,” said Edward Lewis, the co-founder of Essence magazine and chairman of Harlem Village Academies’s board.

Black joined the Academies’ national leadership advisory board earlier this year after making several visits to the schools. Lewis introduced her to the schools’s founder, Deborah Kenny, and later Black watched a presentation Kenny gave on education at Allen & Company’s 2008 Sun Valley Conference.

“She was just immediately passionate. I mean, immediately: How can I help?” Kenny said in an interview today. “Just immediately engaged and interested and passionate about education reform.”

Bloomberg argued today that Black’s experience as a top-tier manager will prepare her for the challenges of overseeing the city’s largest agency. Still, the number of people Black supervises will skyrocket from 2,000 at Hearst to more than 135,000 teachers and agency staff.

Black will also be the first woman chancellor of the city’s schools in the history of the system.

“It’s really good to have a woman running that place,” said a DOE source. “That is a silver lining. The boy’s club will get a bit of an awakening.”

One of the most important relationships Black will have to build will be with the city teachers union. Bloomberg boasted today that United Federation of Teachers president Michael Mulgrew was the first education official Black met.

But that meeting wasn’t planned, nor did the teachers union president know he was meeting the future chancellor, Mulgrew said today. The two met as Black was leaving a meeting with the mayor and Mulgrew was arriving, Mulgrew said, and Bloomberg introduced Black as the head of Hearst Magazines, not as a future colleague.

Mulgrew said that he planned to prioritize discussing the city’s over-reliance on standardized tests and developing more early interventions for struggling schools with the new chancellor.

“When I met her, I thought she was very nice and I’m looking forward to working with her,” Mulgrew said. “When someone is new you have to be optimistic. You can’t go in with any preconceived notions and that’s the only way I am going into this.”

At the mayor’s announcement today, Black acknowledged that she has had “limited experience” working with unions and that it would take time for her to learn the ins and outs of the city’s labyrinthine public school system.

“What I ask for is your patience as I get up to speed on all of the issues facing K-12 education today,” Black said. “What I can promise is that I will listen to your concerns, your interests and your expectations. In turn, I ask the same of you.”

Because she isn’t certified as a school district leader, Black will need a waiver from State Education Commissioner David Steiner before officially taking the chancellor job. A spokesman for the state education department said today that the commissioner had not yet received the mayor’s formal request for the waiver.

It’s not clear when Black will officially begin her duties. Hearst’s Chief Executive Officer Frank Bennack, Jr., told his employees today that the company is coordinating Black’s exact departure date with the city but expected it to be before the end of the year. Bloomberg said this afternoon that Klein would likely stay on through the first of the year to ease the transition.

  • P

    this is just the most blatant example of taking the business model too far… contrary to what bloomberg may believe, the free market can’t solve all of our problems! this is just nuts!

    is there going to be any kind of protest/rally? i’ll be the first on the picket line.

  • Mustafa

    UNQUALIFIED!!!

  • Mustafa

    “The Chancellor Wears No Clothes!” by Cathie Black

  • http://ednotesonline.blogspot.com/ Norm

    “Black acknowledged that she has had “limited experience” working with unions and that it would take time for her to learn the ins and outs of the city’s labyrinthine public school system.”

    Why not experiment with a million kids? She even has less training than Teach For America recruits.

  • Sue

    The NYC education system is elitist and is promoting discrimination because of the charter schools. We need neighborhood publci schools back and an educator in the chancellor seat. I don’t understand this. It’s the most insane thing I’ve seen yet.

  • Huh?

    “short education resume”? I think “nonexistant” is more accurate.

  • Private

    If this woman has any chance, she will have to demand to Bloomberg to FIRE that POISON staff of deputy chancellors – ESPECIALLY Eric Nadlestern!! That elite 8 staff is horrid!

  • Pingback: Win That Deserving Scholarship For University Education. | College Scholarships Guide

  • Michael M.

    The reviews are in!

    # Cosmopolitan >> “Twenty-Three Ways to Impress your New Boss”
    # Country Living >> “Boarding School Mom to Save the Inner City”
    # Esquire >> “What to Get Your Boss for Secretary Makes Good Day”
    # Food Network Magazine >> “Less Sugar in Schools, More Sweetness at Tweed”
    # Good Housekeeping >> “Charter Schools to Get Fresh Paint”
    # House Beautiful >> “Non-Charter Schools to Get Less Fresh Paint”
    # Harper’s Bazaar >> [GS Reader Contest]
    # Marie Claire >> [GS Reader Contest]
    # O, The Oprah Magazine >> “How to Star in a Field You Know Nothing About.”
    # Popular Mechanics >> “Does Every High School Grad Need College?”
    # Redbook >> “Knitting Your Way to a Bigger School”
    # Seventeen >> “How Many Years as a High School Senior is Enough?”
    # Town&Country >> “Out-of-State Alternatives to Public Schools Close to Your Weekend Chalet.”
    # Veranda >> “New Chancellor Promises to Build One at Tweed.”

  • Furt Go

    Will she address how being able to pay for test prep — instead of actually measuring ability — skews who gets into the specialized high schools? AND MOST IMPORTANTLY, what’s she going to do when her reforms and spreadsheets don’t work because good teachers can’t get bad kids out of their classrooms in order to teach the others who are ready to learn? How will she react to outraged parents of victims on one side and the outraged self-righteous in-denial parent of the bad kid on the other? It always seems the schools can’t hurt the bad kid’s feelings, even if it destroys the learning opportunities of a whole class, a school, a neighborhood, a society!

  • Ms Rivera

    Yes that group of Deputy Chancellors needs to be destroyed and removed. They are not healthy for a new beginning like this should be. Remove these 8 individuals. Let’s get a movement here for this group to be removed!!

  • ?

    “What I ask for is your patience as I get up to speed on all of the issues facing K-12 education today,” Black said.

    Absolutely not! She deserves no patience. If she is not prepared with an understanding of the system’s needs and challenges, the Mayor should not have offerred the job and she should not have accepted. The public has every right to be demanding and impatient with both the Mayor and Black.

  • FormerTeacher

    Is ANYBODY happy about this? Anywhere? I would assume even the business-minded, pro-Charter folks can’t be pleased with this PR nightmare. At least pick someone from the business sector that’s not from a crumbling industry (magazines). Oofta.

  • Michael M.

    So…. What happens if she does NOT get a “Waiver?”

    Should her title be:
    a) “Acting Chancellor”;
    b) “Chancellor-In-Waiting”; or perhaps
    c) “Chancellor-Gosh-Darnit…. until a lawsuit prevails and a Court says that yea verily I am in fact unqualified”?

    Is there some sort of “Credit Recovery” for Chancellors?

  • Ms Rivera

    Credit Recovery, that was a good one. My daughter had credit recovery at a high school in Queens that gave her a bunch of credits for handing in something off the internet. She showed me and laughed how her and her friends got free credits while the other kids had to take the class from February to June and got the same actual 1 credit per class. I’m planning a lawsuit when she graduates without stepping into a classroom.

  • I noticed that…

    Ms. Rivera,

    You should report this. The principal is using your child and other children to give credits away, denying them an education, so the school can statistically good. This is unfair to your child, and to every child that deserves a good education.

  • Invictus

    and this credit recovery BS is as common as weed in a Spring/Summer lawn!  Perhaps politicians and upper echelon educators were all too happy to comply with the demands of the middle class, of educational improvement at any cost….. Without realizing that they will be given what they ask by cunning and manipulating politicians.  

    We can only blame our sense of “smug” that we beat the system, working less and getting more, for being in the state we are in now.  

    Many young students know the easy way out and will take it once given the choice…without thinking about the consequences of living under such moral compass.  

  • jodama

    Credit recovery is rampant.  The increased graduation rate goes along with the narrowing of the achievement gap and the rise in test scores.  Does anyone believe anything that comes out of the mouth of the people at Tweed anymore?  How about a story on the Great 8 who have such remarkable education expertise?  Does the public know who these 8 Deputy Chancellor’s are and what qualifies them?  

  • Invictus

    There needs to be massive cleaning house in the DoE and Tweed!  The corruption and conflict of interests there are so blatant that no matter what, I do not understand how Bloomy will be able to get away from all the filth that has been building there for whatever he is planning in 2012.

    Going back to the suspect “8″, the only thing that the public needs to know is the dealings they had with the now Gone DeKlein.  That is a highlight in their resume that will haunt them wherever they go.  

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031