GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

breaking news

Live-blogging Joel Klein’s “sayonara”; hello Cathie Black

Cathleen Black, the new schools chancellor.

Cathleen Black, the new schools chancellor.

We’re live-blogging Mayor Bloomberg’s press conference right now at City Hall, announcing Schools Chancellor Joel Klein’s resignation.

4:11 pm. Bloomberg’s last words to Black, he says, were to the point. “I told her what I tell everyone and that is, don’t screw it up,” he said.

4 pm. Asked what her greatest challenge will be, Black tells the press: ”With the help of the eight deputies in the office, we will spend a good amount of time prepping me and making sure I understand all of the issues thoroughly. The change, the opportunity to make a difference, is really what has compelled me to want this position.”

3:53 pm. The next question is, What about a public search for such a public job? “I did have a public serarch and I picked the best person,” Bloomberg answered, inscrutably. He also said, “In the end, it is the mayor who picks the chancellor.” And he added, “I have looked for people of all backgrounds.”

Also: Who was the first person Black met in this process? Teachers union president Michael Mulgrew, Bloomberg declared.

“Mulgrew has met her,” Mulgrew spokesman Dick Riley just confirmed.

Black’s children went to private boarding school in Connecticut.

3:51 pm. The mayor et. al are now taking questions from the press, starting with, Why not an educator? ”Joel has built an amazing staff of pedagogical experts. That’s not our problem here,” Bloomberg said.

He said the new chancellor’s expertise needed to be dealing with the tough economy. ”Jobs, jobs, jobs. That’s exactly what Cathie Black knows about,” he said.

3:46 pm. Among Black’s first remarks: ”New York has the best teachers in the country.” She is also running through the objectives Bloomberg announced at NBC’s Education Nation event, which did not sound at all different from Klein’s.

“My main goal will be to build on the work of the Bloomberg administration and chancellor klein’s tenure,” she said.

3:45 pm. Klein will remain on until the first of the year to help Black with her transition, Bloomberg said.

3:44 pm Klein to Black: ”I also am comfortable in saying I’m leaving you the best team ever assembled in education.” This seems to indicate that his preference is for the eight deputy chancellors to remain in place after he leaves.

3:40 pm. Klein has accepted an offer form NewsCorp, Rupert Murdoch’s news organization, and will serve as executive vice president and on the board of directors. His main responsibility will be to “put them in the burgeoning and dynamic education marketplace. I do believe, as I said, that that is the future.”

“Cathie, let me congratulate you and thank you for taking on this important assignment,” Klein added, looking to Black, who is wearing black. Just saying.

“I also am comfortable in saying I’m leaving you the best team ever assembled in education,” Klein said to Black. This seems to indicate that his preference is for the eight deputy chancellors to remain in place after he leaves.

3:39 pm. Making his remarks, Klein hasn’t yet mentioned his next plans, although he did say, “To me education will always be at the core of my life’s work.”

3:38 pm. Black is the first woman to lead New York City’s school system, the largest in the country, our resident education historian Philissa Cramer just confirmed from Israel.

3:34 pm. Cathleen Black, who was president at the magazine publishing company Hearst, is the next chancellor of the New York City school systems. “I know the first thing she’ll want to do is reach out toparents, teachers, princpal and and adminsistartors to get the benefit of their wisdom,” Bloomberg said of her. He also said, “She is also someone who has had a long active, e ffort in civic affairs,” including work in youth literacy.

Chancellor Joel Klein exits as schools chancellor. He will move to News Corp, the news organization owned by Rupert Murdoch, where he will expand the company's education business.

Chancellor Joel Klein exits as schools chancellor. He will move to News Corp, the news organization owned by Rupert Murdoch, where he will expand the company

3:30 pm. In doling out credit, Bloomberg just named several top officials at the Department of Education — but mangled Chief Schools Officer Eric Nadelstern’s name. He also named Deputy Mayor Dennis Walcott and Chief Operating Officer Sharon Greenberger, who is a recent appointee. Sources told me Greenberg was placed at the suggestion of the mayor.


  • David Patterson

    Nadelstern should be the replacement. A teacher, a principal, someone who has ideas about how to improve learning.

  • Jeff S

    Does this woman have the proper certification? Does she have the proper experience in education to have a clue as to what she is doing unlike the former unqualified lawyer who spent nine years masquerading as an educator? Will we hear from SED that they will not issue a waiver again?

  • Invictus

    I have a quiet cheer and private round of applause that the Dear Leader has stepped out of this circus at the helm of Tweed….but I am observant at the ways the new leader will act.  Watch her words and whether they match her action and there you will see whether it is a true change or just a change of face.

    Perhaps it is easy for the Supreme Leader to shed his albatross, after the news media no longer publishes only glowing reports about what is happening in NYC schools.  

    I expect that the road map to educational reform has been laid out for the next couple of years and that she will not diverge from it.  

    PS:  Nice knowin’ ya, DeKlein!

  • B

    Black and Bloo[m]?

  • Peter

    WOW! A chancellor, who requires the approval of Steiner, with absolutely no school experience, clearly a Bloomberg choice.

    Klein’s unrelenting battling with the union and the community sealed his doom … if Bloomberg is to move forward ( a Jewish Ross Perot??) he has to “resolve” this festering wound …and Klein was enjoying the battling too much.

    The Klein team will undergo substantial changes, it will become the Bloomberg team … I suspect over the months ahead many of the “sore points” will be eased …

  • Eliot Ness

    This is absurd! No experience in education, kids went to private school… what exactly does she know about education and the department she’s taking over?

    I see another rich person taking a post bestowed upon them by a friend. Bloomberg had a chance to make it right and wasted it. How are parents and teachers supposed to respect this position when there’s no experience or trust?

    I’m sure she’s a great lady and has done great things elsewhere but THIS IS OUR CHILDRENS’ EDUCATION we’re talking about!!!!!!!!!! Pick someone who knows something about education! Agh!

  • Jeff S

    I didn’t hear the entire press conference so I don’t know if her loack of the proper certification came up but if it didn’t then there are 2 things to ponder…

    1. Bloomberg has already spoken to SED and gotten the assurance they will issue the waiver.

    2. Bloomberg is so arrogant that he thinks what Michael wants, Michael gets.

    It’s time SED stands up to him.

    As far as the arrogant, inept Klein is concerned, it is obvious he was becoming a detriment to Bloomberg with his constant inability to get along with the UFT and the alienatin felt by almost the entire professional staff Bloomberg realizes he needs some cooperation from the UFT to push some parts of his agenda. It will be interesting to see how much he gets.

  • Oh My!

    Gargage In, Garbage Out!

  • Invictus

    Look at one clear line….”NBC Education Conference”…anyone who took part of that farce has NOTHING in common with true educators across the US.

  • MissUnderstood

    BLIND SIDE!

  • John G

    She, at least, sounded modest about not knowing much about the whole education thing … Points for honesty.  She also said nice things about teachers … twice (so did Joel … but he spread it out over 9 years. She did it in 90 seconds).
    Bloomberg came right out and said at the press conference that the education chancellor didn’t need to have a background in education, so much as a background in management. I bet that one doesn’t get much coverage!
    She lives in New York. but sent her kids to boarding school in Conn. … yuk! … yuk!!! even the governor sends his kid to a public school.

  • Tim

    So Klein heads off into the sunset and joins forces with the publisher of the New York Post, while Bloomberg conducts a completely opaque search and determines that the best person to replace Klein is someone with no experience in education and who has probably not set foot in a public school, at least not in 50-odd years.

    This *really* makes me feel like I’m taking crazy pills.

  • Esteban Rodriguez

    Bloomberg’s “jobs jobs jobs” comment says it all. He is just clueless on education.

    Klein going to Fox. The former head of Seventeen magazine in charge of our seventeen year olds? The ridiculousness of it all. I feel like I’m being punked.

  • Diana Senechal

    She is the author of BASIC BLACK: The Essential Guide for Getting Ahead at Work (and in Life).

    A quote from the book:

    “The point is not that you should rush out and buy designer clothes. It’s that you should know whom you need to make an impression on, and figure out how best to do it. That includes everything about your appearance–jewelry, shoes, hair, what bag you carry. You don’t have to be a fashion plate, but you do need to show your employers and colleagues that you’re attuned to your environment. And here’s another hint: when in doubt, wear black. You can’t go wrong with basic black.”

  • http://teachinginnyc.blogspot.com Ms. M

    Jobs, jobs, jobs? I thought this was about educating our children. Well, at least he told her not to “screw it up” so that makes me feel reassured.

  • Invictus

    Jobs!(get the old folks to the center of the circus), jobs!(get rid of tenure), jobs!(throw those useless ATRs under the bus)….  or else?

  • Ms. Smith

    NaNaNa Na Hey Hey Hey good-bye.

  • Pingback: Schools Chancellor Joel Klein Steps Down, Replaced by Hearst’s Cathie Black | The Stoop

  • John Hancock

    The devil you know is better than the devil you don’t.

  • relieved

    Thank god they picked someone who is smart and not “certified” … god help us.

  • MIC Siegfried

    She has even less experience in education than Klein, if that’s possible. She went to Catholic school, and sent her kids to private BOARDING school. I’m sure she knows EXACTLY how middle class parents of school children feel. Yeah, right.

  • I noticed that…

    It’s time for the NYC school system to have an education leader that understands curriculum, teaching and learning, community/parent involvement, and labor relations with all union members that work in schools and the union leaders. Unfortunately, the mayor did not canvass the city nor the nation to find that education leader and I don’t know if once again the mayor sidestepped the procedures that I assume should be followed when seeking a chancellor.

    The new chancellor is NOT an education leader nor does she have any experience in teaching and learning. Why didn’t the mayor, in his finite wisdom, tap Eric Nadelstern for the position? Eric has over 38 years of experience in education and he has the certification to prove it. Yet, another media crony is hired and I wonder if she’s going to reorganize what was reorganized to nth power.

    If anyone thinks that Klein is going to ride into the sunset, think again. He will be managing the schools and creating education deforms by proxy of Black. Bloomberg had to get Klein out because of all the problems he’s bringing to Bloomberg’s future political career. I see Bloomberg going for a fourth term in office and he will use the platform of saying that education is on track because of Black.

    Bloomberg, do you really think that you pulled a fast one with all the teachers that you wronged by having an incompetent, arrogant, lawyer masquerading as educator replaced with another an incompetent, arrogant, news media CEO masquerading as educator? Steinner are you really going to give her a waiver? Steinner are you not an educator? Don’t you believe that education should be led by a qualified education leader?

  • Support John Dewey HS

    …..clog her email to make your stance against the closing of the large high schools such as John Dewey….maybe we can stop the madness with the new Chancellor

  • http://www.charterreformer.blogspot.com john

    Does anyone know where to find a transcript from the press conference?

    Questions for Bloomberg:

    Could you not find anyone with experience in education and management?

    When did Bloomberg first meet her. Is he giving a friend a job here?

    When is the last time she was in a public school, under what circumstances?

    What are her plans for raising student achievement?

  • Diana Senechal

    I foresee some news articles praising the DOE.

  • Pingback: Hello, Cathie Black « Education Is…

  • Ellen

    Joel has built an amazing staff of pedagogical experts. That’s not our problem here,” Bloomberg said.
    It must be nice to be that much of a blind optimist. One deputy chancellor is a pedagogue, Laura Rodriguez. The other pedagogue is Eric Nadelstern but I think he’d be better described as a demigod (in hi own mind anyway)
    Did she publish Scholastic? Is that her qualification for the position?
    And bet on this: Steiner has already given the waiver. Shame on the NY State Regents.

  • Vote NO

    Changing the person is not the problem. The policies have to change. If Ms. Black continues with the same policies, and hostility towards the people working in the classroom, the system will continue its downward spiral.

  • http://www.anurbanteacherseducation.com The Reflective Educator

    Public search?  Exactly what is Bloomberg’s definition of ‘public?’  

  • http://justinwedes@me.com Justin

    Please sign my petition 2 hold Mayor Bloomberg & Chancellor Klein accountable 2 Schools & State Law! http://www.petitiononline.com/DenyWaiv/

  • Jennifer

    We should be very worried that all these reformers come from and/or have children in private schools. What are they concerned about? That there are actually public school students who do as well or better than their private school counterparts?

    What has been obvious to NYC parents for the past eight years is that there has been a concerted attempt to dumb down the curriculum. Rather than ensure that all teachers come well-prepared in their subject matter and devoted to teaching it, they have focused on stop-gap hiring measures and superficial teaching methodologies that don’t lead to meaningful, lasting change. Some of NYC’s teachers are the absolute best; others, well, frankly, are not so great. Black’s blanket statement about NYC having “the best teachers in the country,” well, that’s an overreach and a cheap attempt to improve relations with the teachers’ union.

    It’s interesting that Klein’s resignation coincides with NEAP scores showing that the very groups the chancellor targeted with his “reforms” are performing worse than ever. I used to joke that Klein’s strategy for reducing the achievement gap was to lower the top. One wonders what the motives were, given the results. Of course, as long as we avoid dealing with the real issue — poverty — we will not improve the academic performance of disadvantaged students. We also need to make sure that we are promoting the most rigorous curriculum for our average and above average students. High, but age-appropriate expectations and rigorous instruction will raise scores across the board.

  • Laughing

    Can we get a chancellor one day who sent his/her kids to the NYC public school system? Is that too much to ask for? How bout someone who can RELATE to the MINORITY groups who are STRAPPED! How bout someone who did not send his/her kids to a private school in a DIFFERENT STATE. You cannot make this up as this could ONLY happen in NYC. What’s next in line for this circus we call the Department of Education??

  • Truth

    I can tell you why he left. Next year’s graduation rates are going to take a drop back to the stone ages because all students will need to earn a 65 or higher on every regents exam!

    I guess it is not his problem now.

  • Ms. Smith

    Anyone watch the news conference? Revisionism at its best.

  • jodama

    He said the new chancellor’s expertise needed to be dealing with the tough economy. ”Jobs, jobs, jobs. That’s exactly what Cathie Black knows about,” he said.  Has Bloomberg lost his mind.  What does the creation of jobs have to do with running the public school system?  Is anyone as confused as I?  What in god’s name qualifies this woman to run our schools?

  • Lawrence Littlefield

    Surprisingly, Jay Walder showed up and was blindsided by the fact that he was running the Metropolitan Debt Service Authority, and his job was to cut ancillary functions such as transportation to make sure the debts got paid.  He thought he was being hired to manage transportation.

    Does this woman, whoever she is, realize that she is being hired to run the Department of Early Retirement, and ancillary functions like education are going to be eliminated on her watch?

    Deck chairs on the Titanic.  At the MTA, its about the debt.  In the NYC public schools, its about the 2008 early retirement deal.  The rest is PR.

  • Ms. Smith

    The most hated man in education now works for the most hated man in media. What a team! The Union better watch out. They’ll be coming out with guns a blazin’ after our pensions.

  • Lawrence Littlefield

    “It’s time for the NYC school system to have an education leader that understands curriculum, teaching and learning, community/parent involvement, and labor relations with all union members that work in schools and the union leaders. ”

    Irrelevant.  The union has dictated that more and more money go the retire at a time scarcity, with the acceptance of elected officials looking for its support.  What both it and the politicians want now is excuses for a radical decline in expectations in education, as money goes to the retired.  Game over.

    Educational policy doesn’t matter.  The baked in financial disaster does.

  • Ellen

    ENRON: The Smartest Guys in the Room
    Anyone read that? The premise is that you don’t need to know squat about what you were hired to do, just be a smart guy/gal.
    And we all know how well that worked for ENRON

  • Ellen

    Look at the photo carefully
    Klein has his hands folded over his body to protect himself
    the Mayor is looking down with his arms across his body
    the new appointee is looking out with a smile and a twinkle in her eye….i am the Momma here

    interesting body language

  • Mustafa

    The benevolent Klein is leaving. What caused this? Was it for Rupert’s millions? Or is he leaving office before some piece of information becomes public?

    Bloomberg, you suck. How about picking an educator?

    Steiner, if you granted a waiver then you suck too. I don’t care that your boss Merryl is Bloomie’s neighbor. For shame!

    Nadelstern, ha ha! You didn’t get the position you’ve always wanted. Want to guess why? You suck too!

  • Smith

    I wonder if she’ll let us use Youtube in our classrooms.

  • Private

    Next step: Fire those dopes who call themselves “Deputy Chancellors”. What a bunch of SELLOUTS!!

  • Pogue

    Klein and Black are Bloomberg’s puppets. It is he who calls the business shots in regards to NYC students’ education. And, it is about business and not children.

    It is interesting that Klein is leaving at this arbitrary juncture. Something’s up.

    Be careful, Mulgrew.

  • Pogue

    Cathie Black, magazine editor, as New York City Public Schools chancellor?

    Didn’t Bloomberg know Wade Phillips was available?

  • Mustafa

    Teachers, get ready to stand with your union! I don’t trust this and I think they’re about to attack. It’s time to put little differences aside.

  • Invictus

    She will speak with action which means getting at the heart of the union.  While DeKlein was a lawyer, he was careful with his speaking, her actions will speak much louder than DeKlein ever did.  I agree with Pogue, the Union needs to be extremely careful and push back if it has to.  

    The 47 slated for closure it is the tip of a huge iceberg and CB will push the iceberg against the union…

  • GGW

    Pogue = great line.

    Q for Cathie Black:

    Teachers have good days and bad days. Same with you. You had some successes in publishing, and some flops — including Lifetime, Shop Etc., and Tina Brown’s Talk, which was really brutal. What did you learn from the flops that you can apply to the schools?

  • Hmm

    Yes, toward a presidential campaign.

  • Linda/RetiredTeacher

    I am interested in knowing if New York schools really did improve under Klein. Did more students do better on the Regents? How about the SAT and ACT? Did more students graduate? Thank you.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

17 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031