GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

human capital

Principals given more latitude in hiring, but only in the Bronx

Teaching jobs in the Bronx have been so slow to fill that the city today released many from year-old hiring restrictions.

The Department of Education informed Bronx principals this morning that they are now free to hire English, chemistry, math, social studies, and science teachers from outside the current teaching corps. In other boroughs, a hiring freeze in place since May 2009 require principals to fill most vacancies with teachers who are already working in the system.

When Ramon Gonzalez, the principal of MS 223 in the South Bronx, heard about the change, he snapped up four teachers in six minutes.

Gonzalez said he had been holding off on hiring from within the system because none of the 40 teachers he had interviewed met MS 223′s exacting standards. Plus, he already had four strong candidates ready to sign on with the school the moment he could offer them jobs.

Two of the English and social studies teachers had worked in temporary positions at MS 223 last year, one as a substitute and the other as an intern. Another wanted to move to a city school from the suburbs. And the last was coming off a stint as teacher trainer at Teachers College. Gonzalez had been stringing them along all summer, even offering them part-time work in hopes that they’d wait out the hiring freeze.

Gonzalez knew that if he lost out on the four teachers, he wouldn’t be able to find others. MS 223′s South Bronx location deters many applicants, he said, so he had been badgering the DOE’s human resources office for months to relax the rules for hard-to-staff schools like his.

“Today my calls have been answered,” he said.

“They could have pooh-poohed [my concerns] but they understood they had to do something different” in the Bronx, Gonzalez said. “The needs are far greater and the candidates are not coming so readily. … We just cannot attract the same number of candidates as a school in Manhattan.”

Gonzalez still has two slots to fill, but he’s now optimistic that he’ll be able to land strong teachers.

“This opens up a different pool,” he said about today’s policy change. “It frankly gives us first crack at the pool. I’m still coming off this high.”

  • roma giudetti

    Oh please.  All of the principals are waiting until they get the go ahead to hire young, cheap, and untenured teachers.  I’d like to know, of the top ten lowest scoring schools you listed here recently, how many of them have staffs made up of mostly young, inexperienced teachers?  The most vulnerable and most challenged kids in the system are being taught by teachers with the least experience.

  • celso garcia

    This principal openly states defying hiring older teachers and even following Chancellors Klein order to hire Absent Teacher Reserve Teachers. The principal was hiding these vacancies and keeping them empty so remember its not about kids it is about helping people they know. The kids in the Bronx deserve better than unexperienced teachers. Why is there such high turnover in the Bronx? Why are teachers not given more suppourt to stay in these tough schools? The crime rates, poverty, diseases (AIDS,ASTHMA, STI’s to name a few). Low parent involvement, high teen pregnancy rates cause many to avoid the south Bronx. Eventhoigh the Bronx has improved it is years behind the rest of the city this is sad that we live in two cities and a school system that is suppoused to be “separate but equal”.

  • anathema

    Celso, where you learn who to spell-lol. You spelt half you’re words wrong! You must be a teacher?!

  • anathema

    I meanted to say how not who. Sorry.

  • anathema

    Eventhoigh—- huh? that aint even a word! lmfao!

  • John G

    40 applicants for four positions does not seem to qualify as a hard to staff school to me. It sounds more like he refused to hire from the current pool until the DOE blinked and let him play by different rules. The principal here sounds more dishonest than not in his efforts to move his school forward.

    But hey, thanks for celebrating that type of behavior!! That’s very productive :D

  • Joe Schmo

    The principal from MS 223 claims that none of the 40 applicants met “exacting standards”. What he really means is that none of the applicants he interviewed from inside the DOE system were young, untenured, and easily bullied teachers. This kind of situation did not exist prior to the last contract when excessed teachers would be placed in schools according to license. But those days are long gone. Now we are facing the age of getting teachers on the cheap. Who would have thought that the teaching profession in NYC would become so watered down that veteran teachers are now seen as a problem rather than an asset in schools?

  • celso garcia

    It is sad that all you can speak about is my spelling but not the content of my words or the content of the article. Those who hate teachers when we are right resort to name calling remember personal attacks are what people resort to out of desperation. Just me by my character not cosmetics. “power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely” Voltaire. This is the case with the DOE micromanaging schools and using principals to do their dirty work for them. It is not about kids as they claim it is nepotism at its best.

  • vm

    As a person who student taught at MS223, I can vouch for Gonzalez. He does have mostly young teachers at his middle school, but the all the teachers have incredible energy. The teachers’ energy keeps the energetic students motivated. It’s very hard to get that energy level out of a 20 year veteran (not impossible, but hard). There are a few teachers at the school that have 10+ years teaching.

    On the financial side, Gonzalez is great at getting and managing funds. Because of the school’s location and success, his school is worthy of emulation. This makes it very possible for him to attract grants. Is it possible that he likes saving money by hiring younger teachers? Perhaps. But being in the school for several months really puts the idea that his main goal is cheap teachers to rest.

    I also had the “wonderful” experience of being temporarily assigned by the ATR to a position at Unity Center for Urban Technologies. It happens to hold a place on the lowest 10% of schools in the state. It is ranked in with many of the large failing schools, but only has 170 students of its own. This was a school in which there are many veteran teachers. The worst teachers in the school were the ones that had been on staff for more than 2 years. Most of them had many years in teaching. But the new teachers that were hired around my time were not chosen for their excellence. They were never asked to do demo lessons. Not to say they were bad teachers, it just wasn’t something that could be proven in the hiring process.

    So I think Gonzalez is being truthful when he says he was waiting for the right people. Plus, the people that show up in the ATR are of two kinds: old teachers from shut-down schools, and the newest teachers at schools that are downsized. There is no financial incentive to skip over the newer teachers, and there are issues of concern in hiring a 20 year veteran from a failing school to work at a high energy middle school serving poor students in one of the city’s poorest areas.

  • ASTRAKA

    vm,
    regarding “The teachers’ energy keeps the energetic students motivated”. What exactly do you mean? Do the younger teachers work many hours without pay? Do they work on weekends doing tutoring? Do these teachers have children of their own? Do they have time to take care of other family members? Please, let us know.

  • HM

    anasthema you’re right on again

  • HM

    Take a peek at ms 223′s CEP school demographics and Accountability for 2009-10 under STATISTICS. It doesn’t look like many teachers have been in the system for more than two years-maybe not the best place to work??

  • HM

    teachers on the cheap in the Bronx-again no consistency in the lives of the kids

  • Pogue

    “So I think Gonzalez is being truthful when he says he was waiting for the right people.”

    No new hires should occur until all ATR’s are placed.  Principals have a process if a teacher is truly slacking.  The union is there, (cross my fingers), to make sure that due process is a fair one.

    If new hires are allowed, the UFT better not give in to any DOE plans to get rid of ATR’s.  Economic hard times or not, the DOE created this problem and the UFT should not collaborate.

    Simply lower class sizes and all shall fit.

  • Phyllis C. Murray

    Once teachers have rolled up their sleeves…the process of education begins with commitment, dedication, care, and concern for a human soul. For the students who have found teachers who are there to support them on their educational journey, I say, press on! These students are the fortunate ones because it is their teacher who must dream for them before they can dream for themselves. It is the teacher who prepares children for a future which is not his/her own.

    These exceptional teachers are fortunate because for every ounce of energy that they use to invest in the child, if they remain in that school, they will see the rewards of their investment in the child’s continued growth and development throughout the year.

    These are the words of our students.

    WHAT IS A TEACHER

    Written by Bibana ~Ashanti ~~Jamal~~Ellenah
    > ~~Diana ~~John Henry ~~and Mohammed

    >
    >
    > A teacher is a symbol of learning: a leader of learners
    and a miracle to education.
    >
    > A teacher is an educational god that leads us to goodness… while caring for our learning spirits.
    >
    > A teacher is the captain of our educational journey; Exact
    > about everything.
    >
    > A teacher has the courage enough to teach; And knows
    mostly all the answers.
    >
    > Teachers become our heroic inspiration.
    >
    > Teachers educate us with all of their knowledge. Smart and
    > spirited, teachers can make our brains work like computers.
    > Yet, our teachers can also hold our hands when we need it.
    >
    > Teachers reach to the sky to get what we need; And exit a
    > subject just at the right time.
    >
    > A teacher possesses the academics and grace that we all
    > love. Teachers care for us in every imaginable way.
    >
    > Our teacher is the hero in our learning lives.
    >
    > Education is the key to success. That is what our teachers
    > have taught us.
    >
    > Teachers are a class struggle in liberty: Believing in
    > kids; Reaching out to kids; And instilling pride within
    all of us.
    >
    > Our education is important to our teachers. Therefore our
    > teachers struggle hard to teach every student: Checking
    > exams after school; explaining things so they are easier;
    > And reading to us or teaching us how to read.
    >
    > Each one of our praises we give. And for everything our
    > teachers do, we will thank them today, tomorrow and always.

    Phyllis C. Murray, Chapter Leader
    P.S. 75X
    District 8 South Bronx

  • Nicole

    Thanks for posting the words of your students.

  • L

    Where can you find available jobs as a not in the system teacher?

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031