GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

(circum)navigation

How to get around the cell phone ban at Automotive High School

Today in Williamsburg, I ran into two high school seniors on their way back from summer school. The students — Miguel, 18, and Edward, 20 — both carried cell phones.

I asked them to explain how they got their phones into Automotive High School, which has lines of security guards and metal detectors at the entrance. Like all city schools, Automotive abides by Chancellor Joel Klein’s cell phone ban.

Here is what they told me.

  • Math teacher Bklyn

    End the cell phone ban, I have many lessons ideas then can use cell phones in math. They also teach in many colleges already different ways to use a cell phone in the classroom.

    It this to werid of an idea?

  • VG

    What about taking out the battery, or putting the phone near your belt buckle, or any of the other 1000 ways students get their “electronic devices” in?

    I used to feel that the ban didn’t keep the phones out, but when I began teaching several years ago it usually kept them hidden. It’s hard to carry on a cell phone conversation in the middle of class without the teacher noticing. With the rise of texting, however, which is quieter and easier to conceal, the ban (in my recent experience) has ceased to keep the phones inside the backpacks.

    Not that I know what the answer is; the problem remains one of gaining and keeping students’ attention. Another teacher recently told me that phones can be used as “clickers” with interactive white boards; I may be entering the SMART zone in another month.

    Anyhow, even those with sidekicks still sometimes pass hand-written notes (albeit in text-ese).

  • http://nyceducator.com NYC Educator

    I really like seeing real words from real kids here. More of this please.

  • Mustafa

    Perhaps it wasn’t the best location with the “Coors Light” sign in the background.

  • Dan

    If Klein really wanted to get serious about limiting cell phone use in school, he could put in signal jammers. I know of at least one high-school in the Chicago area that does it, and I believe that some hospitals do the same.

  • Nel

    Maybe there should be a fne imposed to he Childs parents if there caught using a cell phone in there school. This will help with there school budgets so we can get supplies to help better educate these kids. Lehman highschool in the Bronx has day labor workers standing all around the school from open to close. How can your child call for help if they have no means of communication. Please help protect our kids don’t restrict them!!!!!!!

  • Larry

    Dan, you have nothing to worry about from the “day laborers”, think about the amount of endurance it takes to stand around all day with just the hope of getting a day job to make some money. There might be many economic, immigration and social issues with the existence of day laborers in the US, but the last thing you need to worry about is these workers hurting the students.

    You need to worry more about the fact that hundreds of kids had their programs incorrect and missed three days of school and that the guidance counselors were the only ones who could correct the programs and they were overloaded with hundreds of kids each.

    Worry more about the level of professionalism and abilities of the staff at Lehman than these workers.

  • http://www.roadwarriorsonline.org Okie Suparno

    Car reviews can provide invaluable insight into a vehicle. Each review is written by an auto industry professional who has reviewed hundreds of vehicles, so they know how to thoroughly check how the car measures up to the competition and if it does indeed meet the claims of the manufacturer. Automobile Magazine provides a comprehensive collection of car reviews for you to peruse at your convenience. Find out today if the automobile you are considering was rated highly by the industry professionals

  • Pingback: Getting Cell Phones into HS Fortresses

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Feb. 10: You’re invited!

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

  • RT @sarcasymptote: Just realized I will be starting the trig unit on valentines day. My valentine to my kids is 6 weeks of hell. 5 hrs ago
  • ” you don't want to come to class? Have a packet. You don't like your teacher? Have a packet” - @leoniehaimson 7 hrs ago
  • .@leonileoniehaimson brings letters from anonymous teachers with damning tales.of credit recovery: giving out CR ”packets” like skittles.. 7 hrs ago
  • At credit recovery town hall hosted by Regents. Testimony so far by principal, and 2 former teachers. Principal support; teachers critical 8 hrs ago
  • Our report about the city's decision to keep two schools open, complete w/ co-location worries & political speculation: http://t.co/RO59PMh1 8 hrs ago
  • More updates...

Archives

February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jan  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829  
?>