GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Outside the Cave

What I Want for My Students

If I have learned anything in the seven years since I first stepped foot into the classroom as a teacher, it is that there is always something more important and foundational than what I think is at any given moment. I first thought teaching was just about academic knowledge, then I thought it was about that and academic skills, but I am beginning to realize that more foundational than either of those things is the need to help student learn to cope with life.

As a student teacher, I kept my full focus on helping my students to have the knowledge and habits of mind necessary to be critical of society and to create a more just world. These are worthy goals, but I realized very quickly in my first full year of teaching in Virginia that none of this mattered if my students could not read and write well.

When I moved to New York and joined the Bronx Lab School for its third year, I added much more focus on improving students’ skills. Over the past four years, as both a history and English teacher while still working towards my original goals, I worked with my students to become better readers and writers so that they would have the academic skills necessary to succeed in college and their careers. Again, these were worthy goals, but last month, as I watched the advisees I’ve had for the past four years walk across the stage to receive their diplomas, I realized that, once again, none of this matters without more fundamental foundations.

Thinking of the students I’ve known who just graduated, here are some of the things I want for them before I think about their academic skills or knowledge of the world:

  • I want my students to have a set of tools to deal with conflicts other than fighting, yelling, or shutting down.
  • I want my students to seek support or help for clinical depression and other mental illnesses.
  • I want my boys to use condoms, and my girls to have the courage to refuse a boy who does not.
  • I want my students to choose to be tested for HIV and other STI’s, and to make sure their partners are too.
  • I want my students to eat healthier food and get enough sleep.
  • I want my students to have a system of organization so that they can manage everything they need to do in their lives.
  • I want my students to have a way to keep track of their schedules so they don’t end up in jail because they forgot a parole officer appointment.
  • I want my students to have the courage to leave behind physically abusive parents the second they can.

In other words, I want my students to be able to deal with the most challenging parts of the world in a healthy way. I want all that in addition to wanting them to be effective communicators, thoughtful readers, and active citizens working to improve the world. I was immensely proud of the scholarships my advisees won and the college-bound path they all are on, but I will take more pride in the moral and healthy choices I hope they will make throughout their lives.

  • Akademos

    Excellent points, though I’m concerned with the possibility of layering on more and more duties on top of the academics for teachers. 

    The truth is that well-being transcends academics from start to end. We as a society are way too caught up in competition and testing (which is slightly redundant: a competition is a test). Look at Race to the Top in name and action; look at our insane hyper-emphasis on testing as a be all and end all, instead of what it is, a highly individually inaccurate and ugly necessity at this point in time.

    Imagine talking to your own child and managing to really explain something so that they not only understand it in their own terms and world but this relieves them of anxiety of it, gives them a sense of belonging and confidence and individual empowerment on their scale. Then imagine giving them a test on it. A test with serious consequences for both of you. What would that, done regularly, do to those moments? Again, though, it is pretty much a necessity at this point for assessment, but, really, what an ugly thing it can be. Those on the winning end often become unduly preoccupied with it and sometimes smug and overconfident, those struggling (often with in part the artifice of testing itself) often lose confidence in both themselves and the system, sometimes becoming frustrated and angry.

  • http://www.classsizematters.org Leonie Haimson

    This is great, but also how about this: “I want my students to have curiosity and a real desire to learn.”

    “I want my students to show persistence and determination to meet their goals.”

    These are the values that we should focus on, rather than narrow academic or test-taking skills; because these are the qualities that will lead them to success in life.

  • Akademos

    I would only add that having curiosity and passion for learning and determination to keep pushing forward and coping with what life brings as best as one can is a natural feature of well-being, while disaffection and disillusionment are natural reactions to many aspects of reality. That’s pretty much the struggle in a nutshell.

  • http://hechingerreport.org/ Justin Snider

    Stephen — I like your list and appreciate your thoughtfulness in creating it, but I’d argue that it could be even stronger if it were worded slightly differently in a few places. I’m thinking specifically of these two points:
    1) I want my boys to use condoms, and my girls to have the courage to refuse a boy who does not.
    2) I want my students to have the courage to leave behind physically abusive parents the second they can.
    I’d argue they should read something more like:
    1) I want my students who engage in sex to do so as safely as possible, and to refuse to participate with partners who won’t use protection. (There are more than just boy-girl relationships in this world, of course, and there are also now condoms for females.)
    2) I want my students to have the courage to leave behind physically, verbally or emotionally abusive parents the second they can. (Physical abuse is terrible, but verbal and emotional abuse is also terrible and shouldn’t be tolerated.)

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

17 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031