GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

MARGIN NOTES

The Cuomo-Duffy ticket: pro-charter, pro-mayoral control, and one union blessing

A Photoshopped combo: Robert Duffy, Andrew Cuomo's selected running mate, alongside an image of an anti-mayoral control poster. Duffy supports mayoral control. (Via Flickr)

A Photoshopped combo: Robert Duffy, Andrew Cuomo's selected running mate, along with a photo of an anti-mayoral control poster. Duffy supports mayoral control. (Via Flickr)

Newly announced gubernatorial candidate Andrew Cuomo’s choice of running mate, announced this afternoon, seals the deal on his education position. The Cuomo ticket is in basically the same camp as Barack Obama and Joel Klein: in favor of charter schools and mayoral control and not afraid to challenge the teachers union.

The running mate, Robert Duffy, mayor of Rochester, has advocated for bringing mayoral control of schools to Rochester, against teachers union opposition. To defend his argument, he has cited the school system “down the Thruway” — the New York City schools under Chancellor Joel Klein. A former Klein staffer, Jean-Claude Brizzard, is Rochester’s schools superintendent. And in his State of the City address earlier this month, Duffy singled out Uncommon Schools’ Rochester charter school, True North, for praise.

That’s in keeping with what Cuomo has been saying about education since officially announcing his candidacy this week. “I believe public education is the new civil rights battle and I support charter schools,” he declared, announcing a list of core principles that also included his support for gay marriage and abortion rights.

Cuomo has also received the blessing — and a so-far undisclosed donation — from the lobbying wing of Democrats for Education Reform, Education Reform Now. DFER Executive Director Joe Williams told me today that he’s “impressed” with Cuomo, who breakfasted with Williams’ hedge fund board members in April.

There may be some small ways in which the new ticket steps aside from this camp, though. When I called up Rochester teachers union president Adam Urbanski this morning, he told me he thinks that Duffy “will make a terrific lieutenant governor.” He said he strongly disagrees with Duffy on mayoral control, and that he expects the union will clash with Cuomo and Duffy on charter schools. But he said the two men have a wide range of agreements:

He is in favor of neighborhood schools to the extent possible; he is in favor of schools serving as centers for the community and neighborhoods – in other words he is in favor of comuntiy schools. He’s in favor of strong discipline and school safety. He’s in favor of rigor.

Indeed, in the same State of the City speech, Duffy endorsed the idea of a neighborhood school:

We will guarantee a place for elementary school children at their nearest neighborhood school, if that is what the family wants. There will be choices of other schools with special programs and services, but every young child will be able to attend a neighborhood school if their parents choose. That will reduce transportation costs overall, and allow us to provide transportation for all families that need it.

He also endorsed the idea of “community schools”:

The school buildings themselves will become bridges to neighborhood-based services – instead of islands that sit vacant every afternoon, weekend and over the summer.

  • http://www.classsizematters.org Leonie Haimson

    Unbelievable how bad it’s gotten and how much public education has been undermined by the hedge fund privateers that its considered a positive sign that Robt. Duffy, the candidate for lieutenant governor with Cuomo, can assure parents that their neighborhood schools will not entirely disappear:

    “We will guarantee a place for elementary school children at their nearest neighborhood school, if that is what the family wants. There will be choices of other schools with special programs and services, but every young child will be able to attend a neighborhood school if their parents choose. That will reduce transportation costs. ”

    Some vision of public education!

  • http://www.sinksalive.blogspot.com KitchenSink

    Reading between the lines, I think he means, “a safe, rigorous neighborhood school for every family that wants it.” Unfortunately, we most decidedly do NOT have that right now.

    I would add one thing about neighborhood schools: it’s not about school buildings sitting vacant during the weekends and evenings; it’s about strong communication and partnerships among school officials, teachers, social service agencies and families. Like HCZ. That isn’t about just an empty school gymnasium; it takes real work, during the school day and outside the regular hours, and until it becomes a real resource (time) commitment on the part of the larger system, schools will remain “islands.”

  • http://gothamschools.org/author/arthur-goldstein/ Arthur Goldstein

    Perhaps if they didn’t load neighborhood schools to 200% capacity they could perform some of those functions. And perhaps if we could dump cohorts that fail to meet our goals, as Canada did, we’d all have higher test scores, or whatever it is they’re measuring us by this week.

    But I think the idea of reaching out to the neighborhood and being a resource is a very good one. Reading between the lines, though, I think Cuomo simply wants the support of people who will give him money. I’m going to write in Leonie Haimson if I can’t persuade her to run.

  • Pingback: Once Again, Don’t Count on Democrats Supporting Public Education « On the Edge

  • Polo Colon

    LIARS ALL!
    If they really were in favor of “community schools” and that school could be the center of the community, they would relinquish their mayoral control failure in favor of community control (with added “controls” to prevent corruption)! It is a scam and a sham, a now job and a shell game; and an education pozi scheme! An impact study needs to be done BEFORE allowing these monkeys and legalized thugs to do any further damage to the students, parents, teachers, schools and communities! Funny how the rest of the country wants to replicate the failure of Bloomberg, Klein and Companies! Their real agenda: privatization of public education to be run by incompetent robots for profit and greedy, arbitrary, malicious and capricious administrators-gone-wild to continue their bombastic and disastrous programs!

  • http://www.parentadvocates.orgnycteachers.com Polo Colon

    The recent reports of cover-ups and failure in NY PROVES that they LIED from the outset and it was all just a ploy to get mayoral control, galvanize and expand Bloomberg’s financial empire and bring in the corporations for education-for-profit deals! The hapless victims: the entire City of New York, its students, parents, teachers and communities! Bloomberg and his robot, Klein could care less about the chaos they’ve created and the generation that has been lost by their INCOMPETENCE! The gangs in the the Banana Republic of New York at the new Tamany Hall, Tweed and their sycophants have had their day, as every dog will, but the chickens are now coming home to roost!

  • Pingback: An elephant in Cuomo’s room? « The Buffalo Puerto Rican Press

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jan  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829