GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Who will New York’s Race to the Top dream team be?

The names of the five people who will make the final pitch to federal officials in New York’s bid for coveted Race to the Top funds are due at noon tomorrow. But state education officials are still finalizing who will take the field trip to D.C.

It’s an important decision. U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan has said that the competition’s judges are looking to see whether states’ representatives are capable of carrying out the reforms they’re promising. That could make all the difference in determining the winners, he has said.

Board of Regents Chancellor Merryl Tisch will be appointing members of the team, she told GothamSchools today, but she said she was still in conversations with possible representatives.

States can bring up to five people “with a deep knowledge” of the application and may not bring consultants, according to the rules USDOE officials sent to finalists. “State teams may include elected officials, State education executives, district superintendents, teacher leaders, and others with ongoing leadership roles and deep knowledge of the State’s application,” the guidelines state.

Other states are reportedly breaking out the big guns for the presentations. For example, the governors of North Carolina, Georgia, Delaware and Tennessee are definitely planning to make the trip, Education Week has reported.

So who are New York’s big guns?

The obvious answers are Tisch herself and State Education Commissioner David Steiner. They have been the primary public faces for the states’ Race to the Top efforts, and Tisch has expressed confidence that the state is competitive because Steiner’s and her priorities for reform often neatly match those of the Obama administration. Even before he was commissioner, Steiner has also long been known for innovations in the way teachers are trained, the area on which Steiner has said the state will likely focus its Race to the Top presentation.

Deputy Commissioner John King is another likely candidate, especially given his past work as the former director of the charter school network Uncommon Schools. Regent Lester Young, who helped shape the Board of Regents’ reform agenda for Race to the Top alongside Tisch, could also be tapped.

State education officials could also choose to tap some higher-profile names — specifically, New York City Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, or even Mayor Michael Bloomberg. Bloomberg has been aggressive about promoting the reforms he thinks are necessary for the state to win. And Duncan has often cited New York City as in some ways the poster child for the kinds of sweeping, accountability-based reforms the Obama administration would like to see spread elsewhere.

Unlike other states, who are recruiting their governors to show how serious they are about reform, New York officials may choose to leave their leader at home, as scandals surrounding the governor could prove a distraction.

Who do you think the state will send? Who do you think the state should send?

  • Andrew S.

    The state absolutely should send Dr. John King, owing to the fact that he basically authored the RTTT application for New York State.  He might not be the most well-known figure among those being considered, but to leave him out would be foolish with the combination of his law and education experience.

  • http://www.SpecialEducationMuckraker.com Dee Alpert

    On December 9, 2009, Merryl Tisch, Chair of the Board of Regents, was quoted as follows in the NY Times: “I don’t believe that anyone who looks at these scores, that anyone can say they understand the full picture,” Ms. Tisch said. She said it was particularly frustrating that despite an increase in resources and efforts, black and Hispanic students continued to lag. “Right now it doesn’t look like much of what we are doing has done anything much for our children,” in response to NY’s dismal showing on the NAEP math scores. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/09/education/09scores.html?_r=1&scp=6&sq=tisch&st=nyt

    From what I’ve read, USDOE has stacked the deck for the reviews of RttT applications by requiring reviewers to look only at the applications themselves. Given NYSED’s dismal history of spending – or should I say mis-spending – billions of dollars in federal funds designed to improve the objective school performance of children of color, children with disabilities, etc. while accomplishing virtually nothing positive for those kids …

    As long as Chair Tisch goes to Washington and tells the truth …

  • Jack

    If they want to add star power then send one of three media darlings: Dave Levin, Geoff Canada, or Eva Moskowitz would be dark horse candidates who could effectively state New York’s case for dramatic reform. Mayor Bloomberg would be a natural pick as well.

  • Ellen

    Did anyone there ever think that a parent could be part of leadership? Jeez Louise, it’s their kids! for the others, it’s and experiment…a good one, but still an expriement. The NY State PTA has great leadership. Will they think to bring a parent?

  • http://www.SpecialEducationMuckraker.com Dee Alpert

    NYSED claimed its RttT application was designed after input from a wide field of stakeholders, including parents. However, examination of the application’s details showed no parents were actually consulted.

    Remember the near-riot at a Board of Regents meeting – it was either last year or 2008 – when NYSED had approved some district’s C4E plan without holding public hearings, although such hearings were allegedly legally required?

    The NYS Ed. Dept. would rather die than take legitimate parental input into account when it did/does anything. If they did bring a parent to DC for the RttT dog-and-pony show, you can be assured it would be a well-trained one who did nothing unless prompted (or pinched) by a NYSED handler.

    NYSED thinks parents are only good for two things: provide its client districts and BOCES with child fodder and pay school taxes without complaint. In fact, from watching its workings for around twenty years now, I feel comfortable saying that NYSED’s real ideal school would be one in an upper middle class white community, fully funded and then some, with no students. All a school is really supposed to do, in NYSED’s view, is pay adults and give out contracts, not all of which have to go to the lowest bidder. Children and their parents are, in this weltgeist, mere inconveniences and distractions on the road to getting more paid adults on staff and giving out even more contracts, not all of which have to go to the lowest bidder.

  • Peter

    If they don’t take someone from the state teacher organization (NYSUT) they’s be making a mistake. When the dust settles the teachers in the classrooms have to implement whatever is decided in the lofty citadels of power. Teachers turn to their union for advise.

    I’d recommend Maria Niera, a NYSUT vice president with a long history of working with the SED on just about all the state intiatives.

  • Doug

    “If they want to add star power then send one of three media darlings: Dave Levin, Geoff Canada, or Eva Moskowitz would be dark horse candidates who could effectively state New York’s case for dramatic reform. Mayor Bloomberg would be a natural pick as well.”

    Jeez man, give us a break. Why not just send Derek Jeter instead. [sarcasm]

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031