GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

unchartered territory

In Brooklyn school city sees worst case of charter violations yet

A Brooklyn charter school that has the dubious distinction of committing the worst charter violations city officials say they’ve ever seen is about to be closed.

New York City rarely closes charter schools, but yesterday Department of Education officials told East New York Preparatory that it intends to revoke the school’s charter when the current school year ends in June. The K-4 school was authorized by Chancellor Joel Klein in 2006 and would only be the fourth charter school in the city to close.

Director of the city’s office of charter schools, Michael Duffy, said DOE officials began noticing problems last year when parents contacted the department and the school was put on probation in February.

“It’s certainly the worst in New York City that I’ve seen,” Duffy said.

Rather than using its probationary period to turn around, the school’s problems seemed to multiply, Duffy said. Its founding principal, Sheila Joseph, is accused of inflating her salary from $120,000 to $180,000, which she could easily do as vice chair of the school’s board of trustees. According to the DOE’s charter revocation notice, Joseph had Mercer Givhan, the father of her child, placed on the board, which DOE officials said put the board’s independence in doubt. He was paid $5,500 that the school cannot explain.

Last year, a review by the State Education Department found that 48 East New York Prep students were discharged before the state’s standardized tests were given. Among the students who left were seven low-scoring third-graders. That same year, 86 percent of the school’s students scored proficient in English and 100 percent were proficient in math.

An review conducted in 2007 noted that “the percentage of special education students is much lower than in other schools,” and that there were no English Language Learners enrolled.

The school’s teacher turnover has also been extreme. Between June of last year and September of this year, East New York Prep lost every teacher it had, Duffy said. In their stead came new teachers, most of whom are in Teach for America.

It’s not clear whether teachers left voluntarily or were fired. Joseph did not return calls for comment.

The school’s board has 30 days to respond to the DOE’s accusations and then Klein will make a final decision. Duffy said the department plans to hold a public meeting at the school on February 3 to explain the closure to parents and to offer help getting students placed into other schools or entered into other charter schools’ lotteries.

  • Leo

    @Former Teacher, I’m sorry you has such a horrible experience at ENYP but, Did’nt you have a chance last year to speak? & on Feb 3th….the meeting is over what else are you fighting for? the decision will be made on March 5th….

  • Worked at ENYP Hell in Summer 2008

    Just because we dont work there anymore, doesnt mean we dont care anymore about what happens. Unlike Jospeh, we are concerned about the students! Our concern for education for children in this city, doesnt stop just because we have moved on to more effective schools.

  • Leo

    OK…..

  • http://gothamschool.org ENYP A Joke School

    Hello parents and current and former teachers,

    I used to work at ENYP. I absolutely loved teaching the children, and communicating with the parents. ENYP has a large African parents who value education and want to make a better life for their children in America. GO PARENTS!

    However, many of the parents are very unaware of the things that are going on at ENYP. Also, many parents are aware of these problems too. They took their children out of school.
    The school enrollment has gone down from last year.

    ENYP Problems:
    1. Ms. Evil Joseph was not allowed to add a kindergarten this year because she was on probation from the NY State.

    2. MS. Evil Joseph lied and told the parents there will be no kindergarten because of no school space. A LIE LIE LIE ….

    3.Ms. Evil Joseph hired and fired teachers like there is no tomorrow. There were even teachers who went to lunch and never came back because they hated the school so much.

    4. I worked there for one year and we went through 4 principals. I guess she is not great at hiring people or is the school that horrible?

    5. She fired the Special Education teacher. Many of the students did not receive services, such as speech, special edu. or counseling. The school for at least a year did not have a counselor.

    6. There no computers for the students. They receive no computer instructions. She fired the computer teacher and as result the children had no computers.

    7. In my class , 100% of students (literally) were reading below grade level. Since some parents and Evil Joseph claim ENYP is the best school, how could that be possible? All of the children received no reading remediation. Children will perform poorly if they have four or five teacher in one year.

    8. I was hired the second month of school and the students had gonna through 3 teachers in a two month span. I was their fourth one. Can the teachers be that horrible? JOSEPH IS HORRIBLE.

    9. Evil Joseph never showed up at school on time. She always claimed to have meetings. She was never there to greet the children.

    10. Many times she refused to see the angry parents and she was so good of manipulating them.

    11. This year Evil Joseph has hired 95% brand new teachers, and the sad part is that 95% of them have no teaching degrees, but just a college degree. (Sorry teachers, nothing against you)

    12. Also, Evil Joseph claims, that she grew up in the projects and that is why she has opened a school in ENYP. This is truly a lie. She grew up in Long Island, in at least middle class neighborhood.

    13. Dont have time to list all them, but I will next time.

  • Concerned Parent

    Well at least I know my child was not in your class…..

  • Concerned Parent

    - They’re not even pretending to be objective. Litterally the only thing that would seem to sate the opponents of the school is to see the school closed. They don’t seem terribly interested in objectivity, even handedness, facts, or illuminating misconceptions. Nor do they want to entertain or tollerate other equally (if not more) valid opinions or points of view. According to them, anything that conflicts with their pre-determined narrative must be coming from someone who is naive, ignorant, stupid.

    I don’t have a stake in this one way or the other and what happens will not ultimately impact me. I do not live in East New York or Brownsville and I am not a parent. But as someone looking in from the outside, and also as a journalist, I am appalled and ashamed (and a little shocked) by the arrogant, paternalistic and condesending approach being utilized by those who are seem hell bent on seeing this school be closed down.

  • keep it real

    Lets keep it real just because you have a teaching degree don’t make you a gret teacher that’s why 19 schools are getting shut down for under performing…I don’t see any great difference from the teacher she had last year with the degree & the teacher she has this year with a college degree my child is still being taught well…I know many of you former teachers have issues with Sheila that I do not care to address because I didn’t walk in your shoes & I can’t tell you how to feel but I will say this I haven’t had a problem with her or the school so why is my child being punished? I feel sorry for those kids who were reading below grade level I hope you as the teacher with the teaching degree did your job and pulled up each & everyone of those kids reading levels with the help of the parents of coarse…And thats funny because @ the meeting I never once heard anyone say that their kids grades sufferd, all i heard was that they were doing great…..

  • http://gothamschool.org ENYP A Joke School

    Dear Parents Keep it Real and Concerned Parent,

    It is very sad, that you believe that children are doing well. My students did improve for the short time, I was there. Maybe the teacher, that your child has was not honest with your child’s progress. I only worked there for 3 months because the school was so terrible, and I could not waste my teaching passion in a school like ENYP. The children are amazing and so are the parents.

    If I were you, I would honestly open my eyes and truly see what type of education your child is receiving. Please, please for your child’s sake.

    Take care parents,

  • Keep it real

    Well we know it was not the 3rd because they did above & beyond on STATE test exams…I know It was not my childs 1st grade class because my kid was at or above grade level with test scores as proof and can read any book you hand her….So either your calling your fellow former co-workers with teaching degrees lazy dummies that did’nt care about the students or are saying that the kids are stupid ? I don’t know what type of b.s you’re trying to pull but any parent with eyes can see when their child(ren) is not getting what he/she needs in the class room

  • Keep it real

    And another thing when my child perfers do math in her head & not on paper and barely wants to count on her fingers in the second grade you or one else can’t tell me she’s not learning!!! Thank you for your 3mths at ENYP now be gone!!!!

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031