GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

school closing season

Jamaica and Columbus High School supporters pack hearings

Parents, teachers and alumni cheer on the testimony of a Jamaica High Schol supporter at a public hearing on the plan to close the school last night.

Parents, teachers and alumni cheer on the testimony of a Jamaica High School supporter at a public hearing on the plan to close the school last night.

From Queens to Brooklyn, hundreds of teachers, students, and alumni poured into auditoriums last night to defend their high schools from closure.

In Queens, supporters of Jamaica High School turned out in droves for the public hearing, a meeting also attended by Deputy Mayor Dennis Walcott and some of the Department of Education’s top brass.

The arguments against phasing out Jamaica and replacing it with several small schools in the same building were similar to those voiced at a question-and-answer session with DOE officials held at the school last month, which also drew an angry crowd.

When one speaker pointed out Walcott’s presence in the back of the auditorium, audience members rose from their seats, turned around to face him, and chanted, “Save Jamaica High School.”

The Queens representative on the Panel for Educational Policy, Dmytro Fedkowski, asked the DOE to postpone the board’s vote on the proposals until the department releases more information about how the closure decisions were made.

“These proposals seem to be moving forward at an alarming rate,” he said.

Fedkowski has one of 13 votes that will determine the fate of the 20 schools slated for closure. He said he is still unsure how he will vote at the panel meeting on January 26.

“We haven’t made a decision yet,” Fedkowski told me after testifying.

The lack of clear criteria for the phase-out decisions has been a common criticism of the plans, one that was also made last week by Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer.

DOE officials cite the school’s low enrollment and stagnant four-year graduation rates, and argue that smaller schools will better serve Queens students.

Critics of closing Jamaica say the school is educating a needier group of students, who frequently need longer than four years to graduate and who some observers argue are often excluded from the city’s small schools.

Robert Klugman, an alumnus of the school who has also taught there for 24 years, said that Jamaica graduates are prepared for the world, no matter how long it takes them to get their diploma. He quoted a remark from Chancellor Joel Klein, who asked what parent would send their student to a school with persistently low graduation rates like Jamaica.

“I’ll tell you who,” Klugman said. “The parent who knows that when their student walks out of this school, they are ready not only for life but also for college.”

In the Bronx, students, teachers, and alumni of Global Enterprise Academy and Christopher Columbus High School also came out to argue against plans to close them. Supporters of Columbus make the same case that Jamaica’s advocates do: in the last several years the school has been deluged with some of the highest-need students in the city and given almost no help in educating them.

“I don’t expect a student who comes to this country in their junior year of high school to graduate at the same time as someone who has been here for 18 years,” said one Columbus student. “If you came to Albania, to my country, I wouldn’t expect that of you either.”

Supporters of Global Enterprise, a small high school that opened in 2003 inside the Columbus building, said the school was too new and had not been given a chance to succeed. Others said it was nonsensical to close the school when the DOE has acknowledged that the school doesn’t meet their criteria for closing.

“What you’re asking is for a school to be phased out that was restructured in January of 2009,” said Global Enterprise principal Michelle Joseph, who has only worked at the school for a year and a half.

“This is an indictment of your procedure. It’s a political maneuver and you’re teaching these students that education and improvement actually do not work.”

  • Diego

    Close that school ASAP. It’s a longstanding horror story. People who didn’t show up to protest the closing were most assuredly afraid of being robbed.

  • http://MLBKI.com Marilyn Kaye

    I attended Jamaica High School and graduated decades ago. At that time there were no Junior High Schools and the students came in well prepared in the basics. Perhaps one should look at the primary school first and get rid of the Junior High Schools before JHS..they are a disaster.You will pick up a building, a principals’s salary and protect pre-teens that are going further away from their homes for their education. Most NYC parents take their children out of grade school before junior high school because it is too dangerous. Jamaica High School is a landmark; it has sports: football, tennis, track, swiiming pool and a college type campus, just to name a few assets.The teachers and support system have always been caring and dedicated.JHS is large enough to prepare a student for college and sports give scholarships. Charter schools and smaller schools don’t have these assets and as per one studentat JHS, they don’t have students from Riker’s Island. There is no other school that has been named the best high school in Queens, NYC or NY State. JHS is the only one that I know of from all the boroughs. Perhaps one should examine the young student who said “are they closing our school because we are poor?” What a terrible example that is if that is true! Why did JHS not have the advantanges of the Collegiate School in the same building with more money, more computers more bathrooms… if you need to keep more schools at JHS,.perhaps add one but keep them equal..Take the lessons from a blended family,.treat us alike.. no favorites. but don’t close Jamaica High School. I went to a recent reunion. The successes of the former students were monumental. Schools in other states would love to have the history of the graduates of Jamaica High School. Success in the Arts, Music. Medicine, Business, & Political Giants are just a few assets. I myself sold real estate to many famous students from JHS. Having had multiple careers, traveling the world and working with the famous in Manhatan, many people came from Queens. You have a stately building on the hill that is a beacon: it is the Harvard of high schools, be careful when you forget your history… yes we must look forward but not at the expense of closing a jewel in NYC’s history. Treasure it, preserve it and let it live for it is our successful legacy and history; preserve it for others to be inspired. Isn’t that what the great schools in America do? Just look at the prep schools in the Northeast;.they don’t close, they build on their 100 year old history and restor to preserve their legacy. Let the flag on top of the hill at Jamaica High School continue to fly as a beacon to succeed in America for all..Our obligation is to preserve our history and particularly for Queens a borough in New York City. Let our jewel Jamaica High School live and become a great legacy for schools like the Statue of Liberty is for America.. Marilyn H Kaye. President. MLBKaye International Realty

  • Jason

    You apparently haven’t seen how frightful the school has become. I work there and always knew its inevitable fate. I can’t wait to be an ATR. If you’d like to vist, please contact me, and you’ll see hopelessness embodied in a historical landmark.

  • Alan Coles

    jason, it’s people like you who should never have become a teacher in the first place. The school would be better off without someone who belongs in a private school. Do the students, and staff a favor – RESIGN.

  • http://MLBKI.com Marilyn Kaye

    Jason: I read your comments about the school and I understand you teach there As a teacher and adult,you have an obligation to help restore order if students are disruptive.. There is nothing that can’t be fixed if one tries! Additionally, these students have a right to have positive feedback and if they are disruptive students in your class, use your power… send them to the principal or put them on probation. As a teacher, these tools should be available to you if you can’t teach a class. Positive feedback brings student success and your positive energy and teaching will make a difference to your students who want to learn..Scholarships come from grades and sports and Jamaica High School surely has the sports. I am sorry for you Jason that you see the glass half empty when it comes to JHS; it can be totally full again, it can be voted the best high school in America once again if everyone works together to make it happen..I sat on the Board of a school in a very rough neighborhood and one man with vision and the support of executives , teachers and staff sent over 50,000 students to college over decades.. He was a very positive person. I would like to see 100% of Jamaica High School students go to college if they want to and if that becomes your thought every day, the numbers will go up. All students should have an opportunity for a great education and teachers set the goal. Thank you for commenting, I appreciate your time. Go Jamaica High School students! Your teachers, parents and alumni want you to succeed, you are making an impact with the press and former students as they listen to you. You too can become a success as so many of the JHS alumni have thru the years. The school has all the assets; it is up to you, staff,parents,teachers, and former students to make it happen. Now students, you have the ear of New York City cheering you on for success, so just do it; work hard, there is nothing that can’t be changed if you keep.trying. Sincerely Marilyn R Kaye. Former JHS student

  • http://MKaye@mlbki.com Marilyn Kaye

    Hitler went thru Austria with fear and these tactics are not the American way, The parents have a right to choose the school they want for their children. The parents of Jamaica High School want this school to remain intact.and it is the only school voted the best in New York City in 1985 My company MLBKaye International Realty supports citizen’s choice. We keep the name America and the name United States of America.. As a former Board member of Boy’s Harbor and the YWCA, the parent’s were listened to If the financial constraints of the organization needed an additional building or if it needed girls added to the name but the original name was not killed. If Jamaica High School needs a charter school to survive financially then add it but don’t close Jamaica High School. Do not let Jamaica High School be like Austria under the third reich, under another banner and is no longer free.A public education is at Jamaica High School & it did not become.the best school in America as a charter school. Parents in some cases pay for their children to go to school at a charter school..We do not want free public schools to cease to exist in NYC. Pool the business sector for more funds and pool the alumni for more funds but don’t close the school, a free public high school, Jamaica High School… a landmarked building that should remain intact. Add a charter school if needed at JHS but do keep the public high school intact in Jamaica Hill, an area in New York City that is totally diverse.. My company MLBKaye International Realty and LBKaye International Realty helped Boy’s Harbor and the YWCA,.remain as landmarks with their name. They were not closed. PEN has helped the public schools with Principals for a Day raise money..Most of the business sector helped the conglomorate of public schools under PEN raise money for additional computers and school needs.I was a Principal of the Day and I am a product of Jamaica High School, a free public high school from decades ago and have learned valuable skills at Jamaica High School. It is landmarked, the charter schools are not! The name of our song in the United States is ” God Bless America” and most of the parents have come out and voted for Jamaica High School’s school name to remain as the beacon of freedom in the public school system in NYC. Let us not be as Austria.under the Third Reich going along but not free.. Let us not be as Austria in need of jobs and financial support come under a dictatorship. Add your charter school under Jamaica High School but do not destroy the school, the building and its name.The right for the parents to choose a public high school education is an American dream. Do not let fear change your name as Austria changed its allegiance and fell under Hitler. The song is “God Bless America” and the chant by the all the parents is “God Bless Jamaica High School” and like the landmark JHS is, do not change the name and the right to be free as a public high school in NYC…. the winner of the best high school in America. The citizens have spoken, their chant is “God bless Jamaica High School” the equivelant of.we do not want to be another Austria, we want to be free like you and me in the United States of America. As the unions say “Made in America,” the citizens of. Jamaica Hill want their public high school Jamaica High School to remain a free public school, made in the greatest city in the world, New York City in the U.S.. Our colors at Jamaica High School are red and blue, just like the flag of the United States of America flag is red and blue. A. Co-incidence… I don’t think so, as the spiratulists say, “there are no co-incidences” The truth has been spoken, just listen to the people that live there, the multi-national people living there, the Chinese, the Indians, the Bangledesh and the Muslims, just to name a few whose children go to the the great high school on the hill with the great American flag flying high. The residences living there have spoken… listen to them and as the unions say “Made in America,” Jamaica High School represents made in America too!. …. Marilyn Harra Kaye, a former JHS graduate President, MLBKaye International Realty MKaye@MLBKI.com

  • John Steven Alcantana

    Ironically enough, less than three years after former Evander Childs High School teacher Joe Bellacero’s comments in response to an earlier Gotham Gazzette post and a year and a half since Evander Childs’ closure the new Evander Campus finds itself in the same chaotic state as it did under the weaker administration before Ms. Monica Ortiz-Urena took over. Watch the Youtube video below:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6sjK_xl5bA

    which features a News 12 The Bronx story regarding a riot in Evander’s lunchroom on Wednesday, January 13, 2010, that left several school security agents injured, a number of them hospitalized and students terrified at what they’d witnessed.
    What’s even odder about this story is how it was not publicized in the Post, Daily News or Times. How’s that for a media blackout when it is convenient?

    Closing our large high schools is not the answer; helping them get it together and succeed is.

  • Selaine

    Jason, you are the reason why good teachers get blamed for poor performance. You give them reason to believe that teachers just don’t care. Students at least deserve good teachers, perhaps Jamaica’s problem is not being more careful about who they hire since they end up with people like you.

  • http://sites.google.com/site/goldstockstrading/profits-with-gold-stock-trading Jason Hargreaves

    I really can’t believe it. I hope Wayne Rooney is not injured for the cup!

  • Bibi Mckenzie

    Diego its people like you that should be kicked in a face with a giant boot;
    Jamaica is an outstanding school with amazing teachers

  • Ruby Celis

    I agree with Mr. Coles about Jason…if you dont like it, then get out. I bet the students you teach will be very happy to know you are not there anymore. I can also understand why you didn’t put your last name in your post. If you did, the principal would’ve fired you after reading the comment and he has all the right to fire someone who doesn’t like teaching students. It’s also obvious that you haven’t been working there long enough to see how great this school is. Ask anyone else who has been or used to worked in JHS and they will tell you how great this school is. I’m just very disappointed that I am not in NY to help support this school against the DOE, who has decided not to help us in any way possible, but if this fight keeps on going by the next school year, you can bet that I will be fighting side by side with my former teacher, friends, and family because this school deserves to stay open and help the next generation mature to help themselves in life and for the better.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

10 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031