GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

exclamation point

More than a month after its expiration, mayoral control is back

New York state senators resurrected mayoral control today, voting 47 against 8 to pass the legislation this afternoon.

According to the Daily News’ Liz Benjamin, debate over the bill lasted for two hours and turned personal when critics of mayoral control attacked the bill’s supporters, Sens. Daniel Squadron and Frank Padavan. The Senate also passed four amendments that will create a parent training center, an arts council, yearly school safety meetings, and expanded oversight of principals by superintendents.

Jimmy Vielkind at Politicker reports that the dissenting senators were Bill Perkins, Ruben Diaz Sr., Shirley Huntley, Kevin Parker, Velmanette Montgomery, Eric Adams, Carl Kruger, and Tom Duane. Perkins and Diaz also voted against all four amendments.

Standing on the Senate floor, Diaz forecast how tomorrow’s editorials would receive his vote. “You read it, tomorrow they’re going to call me a monkey, they’re going to call me a clown, they’re going to call me stupid. They’re going to call me all kinds of things,” he said.

The NY Post, which has been mayoral control’s biggest cheerleader, is reporting the news with an exclamation point in its lede.

“Mayor Bloomberg is still the undisputed educator-in-chief of New York City public schools!”

In a statement just sent out by Mayor Bloomberg’s office, the mayor thanked the two senators for sponsoring the bill. “With the governance question resolved, we can now move full steam ahead with efforts to ensure that this school year is marked by more great progress,” the statement said. Included in the list of people the mayor thanked is “Majority Leader Espada,” who is one half of the two-senator team that staged a Senate coup in early June and led to the mayoral control law’s sunset.

The state Senate also passed a resolution by a voice vote that will create a task force to oversee mayoral control. With a total of seven members — four Democratic senators and three Republicans — the subcomittee will have the power to hold hearings, issue subpoenas, and write reports.

  • Dissenter

    47-to-8 huh? I guess more than a month of delay got opponents 8 votes and some stupid amendments that the Assembly will ignore anyway. Sure, it was worth it.

  • Pogue

    Let’s just hope now we can vote Bloomberg’s (yes, it’s a curse word) out of office. End THIS mayor’s control.

  • Dissenter

    That’s correct Pogue, if people don’t like the Mayor, they can vote him out of office, but it has not happened so far. That’s what this all seems to be about. There are some who don’t like the Mayor. They are in the minority and they have decided to use other means to try to thwart him. It’s really quite simple. All that has to happen is to get a majority of voters in November to vote for former Board of Education (um, Titantic) President Bill Thompson, or perhaps come up with a better candidate than Thompson or Bloomberg.

  • Pogue

    I was hoping other candidates, Democratic or Republican, could have been discussed around this time of year, but NOOOO, New York City can’t survive or run without his holiness. No, let’s make payoffs and backdoor political contributions abound so we can change what the people wanted and already voted on twice. Save us Mayor Bloomberg, we can’t figure things out for ourselves. Nobody but you can rule NY. Politicians may bow to you, hopefully New York voters won’t. Send him packing.

  • Michael M.

    It’s ironic that Dissenter cites the Titanic, when one of the fundamental issues at hand is whether the Mayor and Chancellor are too focused on nominal lifeboats — aka charter schools — at the expense of the REST of the system.

    Of course, if my kid was already in a great high school, I too would be jumping up and down on one of the few lifeboat seats, incessantly asking why anyone in their right mind would want to rock the boat.

  • Michael M.

    I am hoping that today’s “victory” proves Pyrrhic, and that it either causes the citizenry to reconsider WHICH mayor they want in control, or causes this mayor to realize that it’s time for a new chancellor.

    With the recent Quinnipiac poll showing Bloomberg at under 50%, his lead over Thompson at only 10 points — down from 22 a month ago — and resentment of Bloomberg’s attempt to buy the office at (per memory) over 60%, I would suggest an office pool on Klein’s departure date might be a good investment.

    The “Education Mayor” can’t throw Klein overboard like Jonah to the public whale in advance of the election without undermining $36 million in marketing hype and the foundation of his campaign strategy.

    On the other hand, a well-timed noble resignation might not hurt, and might be amply rewarded someday.

    It would be ironic indeed if wining Mayoral Control cost Bloomberg the mayoralty.

    The emperor just got a new suit of clothes. It remains to be seen who will be wearing it come November.

  • Ellen McHugh

    They still have to get the Assembly to agree…..and then the Gov. needs to sign the bill. it ain’t over

  • canwetalk

    Is there another billionaire out there willing to be the mayor and will not use his/her money to buy the votes for mayoral control of schools?

  • Dissenter

    Michael M. you make me laugh–”only 10 points.” Obama won by 7 and that was a “landslide” over McCain. One thing’s for sure the only thing Mayor Bloomberg has to do from now on is let Thompson talk on the issues. Once that windbag opens his mouth it will be all downhill from there.

  • brookrunsover

    Mayoral Control in itself is not a bad thing, however, in the hands of men and women with a business mentality like Mayor Bloomberg and Klein, the schools will be streamlined like any business model and the losers will be immigrant kids, slow learners, indigents, etc.

    Quite frankly, this is not how a school system should be run. There’s a place for private (business) interests in the City, but education is not one of them, this must be left to the teachers, administrators, parents, and obviously the students. It takes a village not a mayor.

  • Pogue

    Hindsight is always 20/20. As a teacher I thought Mayoral Control, back in 2001, should be given a shot. Lord knows the system had its problems and maybe new ideas could help with the poor attendance and discipline issues. NOT! This guy turned into a budgetary dictator looking to bust a union, set up a segregationary system, and help his corporate and political friends. If only I knew then what’s been done to us now.

  • Michael M.

    1) There’s a difference between CENTRAL control, and MAYORAL control. Maybe we’ll get it right… in 2015. (Still too much muddling by commenters of the office powers and the officer as an individual.)

    2)
    Did Obama’s lead drop from 22% to 10% in a month, and before he finished at 7%?

    3) As I understand… it’s law as soon as Paterson signs. The hangnails are proposed amendments — not in the bill as voted by the Senate. They voted the Assy version! It was structured this way for just this reason. Bloomberg got a “Silver” spoon — to go with his platinum set.

    4) I’d say the one blowing $36M to toot his own horn is the windbag. That’s not just me, that’s a majority of New Yorkers per Quinnipiac.

  • Dissenter

    Michael if I recall correctly, Obama’s “lead” went from 13 points to 2 points, before the final tally of 7.

  • Michael M.

    D,

    Persistent?

    Obama’s popular lead ranged.

    But only McCain took a popular vote poll dive comparable to what Bloomberg experienced over the last month.

    http://www.pollster.com/polls/us/08-us-pres-ge-mvo.php

    If you want to press the analogy, McCain tanked during the debates, one after the other.

    So please join me in demanding that ALL candidates appear before the public for debates. Period.

    I’d love to hear Bloomberg promise that his next Chancellor will follow the law, especially given his team wrote the darn thing.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

Follow GothamSchools

RSS
Subscribe to the daily email digest:

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031