GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

purchasing power

DOE contracting practices on the City Council hot seat right now

Last week, the City Council’s education committee examined next year’s Department of Education budget, and next week it is scheduled to look into the explosive issue of charter school expansion. For today, however, the committee is turning its attention to the technical but no less important issue of how the DOE enters into business contracts.

The DOE hires external vendors to perform a variety of services, from managing admissions processes to constructing data systems. Some of the department’s contracts, such as one with the consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal to redo the system’s bus lines two years ago, have been criticized for being expensive and being entered into without a competitive bidding process. In January 2008, the state comptroller, Thomas DiNapoli, announced he would open an audit of the department’s no-bid contracts, which at that point totaled more than $300 million. The results of that audit have not been released.

Tired of waiting for DiNapoli, a handful of enterprising Columbia University journalism students launched NYCPublicEyes.org, a Web site that they’re calling “an experiment in open-source investigative journalism” to get more details about the DOE’s contracting practices. So far they’ve posted a list of no-bid contracts the DOE has entered into, which they obtained by filing a Freedom of Information Law request. They’re also updating their blog as they learn more: The most recent post is about how two offices that technically are supposed to monitor DOE spending, the Public Advocate’s Office and the Comptroller’s Office, gave the students two different lists of no-bid DOE contracts. My guess is that NYCPublicEyes, like GothamSchools, will be reporting about today’s hearing.

3 Comments

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack

  1. Michael M.

    “$300 million” — $300,000,000.00 — in NO-BID CONTRACTS.

    Let’s have some fun with math: Say it costs roughly $15k per year to educate a student. That’s 20,000 students’ worth, very roughly the number of students in a typical CEC’s purview (one fiftieth of one million kids). Can you imagine the hue and cry if any local school board — pre-mayoral control — had forked out that much under similar circumstances? People would be screaming for… mayoral control. Ain’t irony grand?

    Surely the Office of “Accountability”, with its own $31M budget, might have something to say about that current $300M. (Not holding my breath.)

  2. [...] on how the department’s contracting procedures allegedly hurt small local businesses and an account of the range of issues in question.) Questions of financial rectitude aside, council members blame A&M for suggesting [...]

  3. [...] while disputing a city audit that found its contracting process “out of control” by allowing one in five contracts to [...]

Leave a Reply

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Mapping the Budget Cuts

Post a comment about the budget cuts at your school on our interactive comment map. more »

Chalk It Up

Our Twitter Updates

  • Kanye West on education (no really) RT @kanyewest cool ain't cool no more, it's a new day education is the new motivation 1 day ago
  • "Lady Gaga is doing just fine with just a year of college" says NYC Mayor Bloomberg. 2 days ago
  • Pass rates on state tests fell sharply this year, after the state raised the scores needed to be deemed proficient. http://bit.ly/b5PK3I 2 days ago
  • Duncan on Michelle Rhee's firings: "It’s a race to the top. I don’t think anyone’s going to fire their way to the top." 3 days ago
  • What should $4b for bottom 5% schools go toward? Duncan: "Whatever it takes, we want folks to do." 3 days ago

Events Calendar

  • No events.

Archives

July 2010
M T W T F S S
« Jun  
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

GothamSchools by Email

Technology in Education

The blogroll is a work-in-progress; to be added or if you've been miscategorized, send us an email at .