GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

bully pulpit

Mayoral control, Obama: unseen stars at Harlem Charter Night

The crowd at Harlem Charter Night.

The crowd at Harlem Charter Night.

Mayor Bloomberg and Lil Mama cheered charter schools, school choice, and mayoral control of the public schools before a crowd of thousands of parents and students last night.

The mayor and the rapper even shared some tactics. “Do we want more parent choice?” Mayor Bloomberg yelled. “I can’t hear you! Do we want more competition? Do we want better test scores and higher graduation rates?”

Lil Mama was more successful with the call-and-response style. She called “Parent” while the crowd screamed back, “Choice!” “You don’t have to send your child to a regular public school,” the Harlem native said before performing two of her hits, “G-Slide” and “Lip Gloss.” “You can send them to a public charter school.”

While many of the kids seemed most excited to watch Lil Mama perform, a team of volunteers and interns at the pro-mayoral control group Learn NY were on hand to encourage parents to sign a petition supporting mayoral control, and a parade of education officials used the unprecedented crowd size to push their causes. (The legislature will vote on whether to renew the mayor’s control of the public schools in June.)

The Harlem-born rapper Lil Mama performed on stage with charter school students.

The Harlem-born rapper Lil Mama performed on stage with charter school students.

Geoffrey Canada, founder of Harlem Children’s Zone and the chairman of Learn NY, spoke about how, just seven years ago, Harlem schools were the worst-performing in the state. “If people want to know why I support mayoral control, this never happens otherwise,” he told me after his speech, gesturing towards the enormous crowd of enthusiastic students and their parents. He said he’s a big fan of regular public schools as well, but “the issue is we want great education for our children, and if it’s parochial, if its public, if it’s charter—whatever it is, that’s what we’ve go to do for these kids.”

Because space is tight in lotteried charter schools, critics say the schools leave unlucky children in increasingly unsuccessful regular public schools. Bloomberg made one answer to the problem in his speech, saying that 30,000 kids are waiting to enter charter schools. The answer? Build more.

“We’ve got to make sure that the reforms that we made don’t all get rolled back by the politicians this June,” he said.

President Obama was the unseen star of the show. Organizers passed out buttons saying “Obama [heart] Charters,” and Canada played a video clip of the president’s recent education speech, where he declared that caps on charter schools are not ”good for our children our economy or our country.”

Chancellor Joel Klein declared that charter schools can deliver on the promise of Brown v. Board of Education. “Unless you are willing to stand up and fight and support public charter schools and parental choice so that every kid has an opportunity for the American dream, we will never, ever be the country we want to be,” he said.

The activist Howard Fuller, who chairs the pro-voucher and pro-charter Black Alliance for Educational Options, said that demanding school choice continues in the spirit of Rosa Parks, Malcolm X, and other black leaders. “Harriet Tubman’s mission was to rescue slaves. Our mission is to rescue children,” he said.

I also spoke to Paul Fucaloro, the director of literacy and math for Harlem Success Academy, who departed slightly from the cheerleading to say that not all charter schools are excellent. “Just because people open schools doesn’t mean they’re going to get the same care and attention to detail that we have,” he told me. “We put our money where our mouth is.”

We’ll post more on parents’ experience at charter night later today.

  • http://justicenotjustus Henry Funes riolove58@yahoo.com

    I understand the frustration of these parents as most of the public schools in Harlem are an abysmal failure and for decades. However, what happens when charter schools begin to fail? What happens when corporate money dries up and the teach for a while interlorpers leave?
    Bloomberg will not be mayor forever or will he?
    When the promise of Chater schools turns in a mixed bag of results those kids will be coming back to public schools. What then?
    All I have is questions.

    Wow I never figured a billionaire mayor to be the civil rights leader that he is. Truth is stranger than fiction sometimes!

  • Lindsay

    To answer some of your questions, not all charter schools receive corporate money. I work at a very successful Harlem charter school that only receives grant money from private foundations our after school enrichment and sports programs. The rest of our money comes from the city, state, and federal government and we get LESS than a regular public school. Yet we still acheive great test scores and are more successful than the public schools in the area. Why? We have a strong commitment to developing teachers, small class sizes, and a lot of support for at risk students. We also are held way more accountable by the city and state and we know our charter can be revoked at any time if we fail. We are not allowed to fail, which is the whole point. And if some charters do fail, great. That leaves room for a more successul one in its place. Hope that clears some things up!

  • Pogue

    Did you say small class sizes? And, you’re funded by the city? Wait a second, my school is funded by the city and our class sizes run 28 – 34. What the heck is going on here?

  • http://www.classsizematters.org leonie haimson

    by the way, charter schools not only get smaller classes but more per pupil funding than regular public schools. Sorry to rain on your parade. See

    the nyc public school parent blog; headline

    Charter School Funding Per Child Much Higher Than Public Schools

  • Lindsay

    A charter school IS a public school that provides a free education to neighborhood children. The only difference is we have more autonomy. Why shouldn’t we receive city and state aid? And I agree that class sizes are too large in traditional public schools, and you as a parent have a choice not to send your child there. Also, while per pupil spending may be slightly higher, charter schools most often have to pay for their facilities and DOE schools do not. The only time they do not have to pay for facilities is if they are conversion charters that have a deal with the DOE. Also, The funding formula only allows for charters to receive 80 percent of whatever the public schools get.

  • Pogue

    That’s right parents, because Bloomberg and Klein were failures, and, with Mayor Control, couldn’t figure out how to help ALL NYC school children in the six years time they were given, it is now up to you to get your kids away from the “regular” kids. Choice. Keep It Groaning, NYC.

  • Josephine Marino

    Since the mayor was handed control of the schools in 2002 I have seen vast improvements. PS53, where my grandson goes to school, is profoundly better. My grandson is able to get a great education due to smaller class rooms, computers in the class, a science room that they can do projects at. The school is always improving something for the students so they can excel.

    I know that with the mayor in control of the education of our city’s children, more attention is being paid to the kids, money is being distributed fairly and the paralysis of the old Board of Education is gone. In the end. I know that things are looking up for kids in Staten Island.

  • Michael M.

    Re “Chancellor Joel Klein declared that charter schools can deliver on the promise of Brown v. Board of Education. “Unless you are willing to stand up and fight and support public charter schools and parental choice so that every kid has an opportunity for the American dream, we will never, ever be the country we want to be,” he said.”

    Congratulations, New York City! The post of Chancellor of the Public Schools has been abdicated. (Though we apparently DO have a Chancellor of the Charter Schools.)

    As to Brown v. BoE, the issue from 1896 to 1954 was “de jure” segregation. As to NYC in 2009, the matter is STILL “de facto” segregation, and the achievement gap. I fail to see how Chancellor Klein’s gross favoritism toward charters addresses those problems in the rest of the system — for which he is STILL responsible.

    P.S. I am neutral on charters, save for when they take space away from existing public non-charter schools, and I support parent choice.

  • http://nyceducator.com NYC Educator

    I have to grant that this mayor has indeed delivered smaller classrooms, as the above poster pointed out. At my school. this is accomplished by erecting non-soundproofed sheetrock walls in the middle of existing classrooms.

    Unfortunately, the mayor has not delivered smaller class sizes, and I don’t believe even the DoE is pretending otherwise at this point. Still, it was certainly gracious of them to take hundreds of millions, at least, from the state for this purpose.

  • http://schools.nyc.gov/SchoolPortals/31/R053/AboutUs/Statistics/default.htm Michael M.

    Josephine:
    I am glad you are satisfied with your grandson’s education. I wish *ALL* 1,000,000 kids’ grandmothers felt the same.

    However… class sizes are going UP on average in the city in nearly every grade, the Capital Plan can’t keep up with existing overcrowding let alone accomodate growth in many parts of the city, and science (and other “cluster”) rooms such as your grandson enjoys are being eyeballed by Tweed at overcrowded schools for conversion to gen ed homerooms.

    Click link behind my name for PS53′s statistics. I note that PS53 improved from a “C” to a “B” in the last two School Progress Report Cards, and the Parent Surveys show it is well liked, most recently scoring in the 80th-95th percentile compared to the horizon. But this means some 80-95 percent of parents are NOT as satisfied.

    Best wishes.

  • Pingback: Fordham Fellows Blog

  • forge’t Hopkins

    i want to no if obama still have the school program that paies you to go to school

  • Pingback: DailyPolitical.com » Blog Archive » Odds And Ends

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Feb. 10: You’re invited!

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

46 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

  • Frank Thomas, DOE spokesman just told me no arrests have been made tonight at PEP despite confrontation between protesters & police earlier. 33 mins ago
  • RT @leoniehaimson: It's been shown repeatedly that as one schl closes another overwhelmed w/ high needs kids that small schls won't take 38 mins ago
  • Shael: the suggestion that kids are moved around (to large, struggling high schools) just isn't accurate. 41 mins ago
  • @SchoolBook: Manhattan rep @PSulliv and mayoral appointee Lisette Nieves get into an argument she tells him to get off his "soapbox” 43 mins ago
  • Mayoral appointee Lisette nieves chimes in on an increasingly irate @PSulliv she says he's being rude. 43 mins ago
  • More updates...

Archives

February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jan  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829  
?>