GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

the scoop

After criticism, Klein embarks on a sit-down spree with lawmakers

Chancellor Joel Klein conducted at least one of his meetings with lawmakers in his office at Tweed Courthouse.

Chancellor Joel Klein conducted at least one of his meetings with lawmakers in his office at Tweed Courthouse.

After suffering a beating from legislators who accused him of being rudely unresponsive to their concerns since taking office in 2003, Schools Chancellor Joel Klein is taking the hint and reaching out.

In the last few weeks, Klein has walked  Mark Weprin, a Queens lawmaker who is one of his sharpest critics on the Assembly’s education committee, through his Tweed Courthouse headquarters; sat down with a handful of other lawmakers; and made appointments with more, including the committee’s chairwoman, Catherine Nolan. He has also begun, through his staff, to send out prompt replies to lawmakers’ requests.

“We’re getting letters answered, we’re getting information that we’ve asked for,” a spokeswoman for Nolan, Kathleen Whynot, said. “We have a really good working relationship right now with some of the DOE staff, which has been a nice addition.”

Assembly members said the outreach began after they launched a series of five hearings on the subject of mayoral control — the governance structure that Klein strongly supports, but which several lawmakers have criticized as authoritarian. The state legislature handed the mayor control in 2002, but the law they wrote sunsets this year, and so many in Albany are rolling up their sleeves and hoping to revise it.

The hearings were a chance for citizens to give their thoughts on how they’d like the law changed (or not). They also became opportunities for the lawmakers to air their concerns. Several of the complaints had to do specifically with Klein and his staff, who lawmakers said frequently failed to respond even to basic questions and concerns. The complaints accelerated at a hearing held in Manhattan where Klein himself testified, sitting before a row of lawmakers who took turns rebuking him.

The chancellor began to get in touch with lawmakers just days after that Friday hearing. Daniel O’Donnell, an Assemblyman from Manhattan who deployed sarcasm and a few smirks during his interrogation, said his cell phone rang early into the very next week. The legislature was in session, so O’Donnell let the phone buzz. When he came out, he said, “There was a voicemail message from Joel Klein. I had to play it twice to make sure I was hearing that correctly.”

Weprin met with Klein at his office in Tweed Courthouse, just next door to City Hall. The men took a walking tour through Tweed, even stopping by a kindergarten class at the Ross Global Charter School, which is housed in Tweed’s bottom floor. They also sat down to talk about Weprin’s concerns with the mayoral control system. “He didn’t say great idea bad idea, but he was open to listening and said that we’ll talk about it and see if there are things we can agree on,” Weprin said. “So at least that’s different than saying, ‘We have a difference of opinion, we’re not budging.’”

Weprin said the extra attention from Klein is coming as a surprise to his colleagues — and he has a theory for Klein’s change in approach. “Micah Lasher’s fingerprints are all over this thing,” he said, referring to the school system’s newly hired lobbyist. “He seems like a young guy, but he’s pretty savvy on how to deal with human beings and legislators. I have a feeling he might have said, ‘Houston, there’s a problem here.’”

Lasher did not take credit for the meetings. “I think my sense of the chancellor is he’s a very accessible person, but he’s a busy guy,” he told me on the telephone this afternoon. “I have no idea what ships have passed in the night over years past. All I know is that in my brief time here, every time a legislator has reached out to him, he’s been very eager to hear their concerns.”

Amid mounting speculation that the mayor could sacrifice Klein for the sake of preserving mayoral control, the stakes for repairing his relationship with lawmakers could be high. Weprin named an even greater possible risk if Klein fails to work cooperatively: The law’s sunset could come and go without the main players reaching any consensus, and the school system could be sent back to a state almost no one seems to desire — the way it was before 2002, when a school board picked the chancellor and finger-pointing over responsibility was the main substance of education fights.

“I don’t want to make it look like we’re the gang that can’t shoot straight, but let’s face it. This requires an affirmative act by three groups: the Senate, the Assembly, and the governor,” he said. “If the’yre going to stick to their dotted I’s and their crossed T’s, we will defintely have a problem.”

  • Ellen McHugh

    I hope that the legislators know that, like any other fling, this could be a momentary love fest and only meant for a select few. Despite repeated requests, it took seven years for Mr. Klein to respond to the requests of elected officials.
    Today, not yesterday or last month or even last year, when a request for information was emailed from a CEC member to Mr. Klein, the member was referred to Martine, the chief mom, at OFEA. The request had nothing to do with Martine’s office. Deflecting people…or deflecting people who seem insignificant to him…. is an art the Chancellor has managed to perfect.

  • http://www.classsizematters.org Leonie Haimson

    He may be trying to stroke the legislators , but he is still treating parents like crap. Just in the past week, the DOE decided that : 1-SLT members cannot be eligible to serve on CECs; 2- Presidents council meeting to discuss CEC elections will be closed to all parents who aren’t members; 3- PTA meetings will be closed to all observers and even invited guests unless the PTA has by laws that state otherwise, and even then, the PTA must vote as a whole at a previous meeting to invite a particular person; 4-the DOE has unilaterally decided to close a zone school and open a charter school in its place, without the approval of the CEC, contrary to state law; and 5-they have blamed their egregious refusal to reduce class size — also in violation of state law –on parents!

    I don’t know what Klein is telling the legislators, but its up to us to let them know that the leopard hasn’t change his spots when it comes to his extreme contempt and disregard for parent input and parent rights.

  • Leonie haimson

    UPDATE: late last night, after much protest and complaint, Martine decided that SLT members could serve on CECs, and that it would be left up to President Councils as to whether they would allow other parents in. the rest of it still stands.

  • A. S. Evans

    It’s obvious that Chancellor Klein is “playing nice” which is something he can probably sustain for four months until the decision on mayoral control in June. What I hope lawmakers will remember is the disdain, contempt and arrogant disregard he treated them with for seven years. He’s like a used car salesman whose you’re best friend until he sells you the lemon and then reverts to his regular unpleasant self.

  • A. S. Evans

    It seems that the chancellors the independent school boards picked were distinguished professionals who cared about the NYC public school children and their education, so I don’t see why reverting to that option is so bad, considering the current sad state of affairs.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Word from Our Sponsor

From Our Jobs Board

Featured Employers
Recent Jobs

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

0 comments so far today

Archives

June 2013
M T W T F S S
« May  
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930