GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

Quietly, the $80 million data system launches — er, relaunches

A year after the program was launched to a widespread “meh,” the $80 million ARIS data system that is supposed to give educators and families detailed information about students’ performance in school is now online, all over again!

This week, principals are beginning half-day training sessions to learn how to access their students’ data, and soon they will sign up two members of their staff to become in-house experts on the system. Signing up staff members is listed as a “***REQUIRED/HIGH PRIORITY***” item in this week’s newsletter from Chancellor Joel Klein to principals.

This launch is going to get political fast, especially in this budget climate. Many groups, including the teachers union, principals union, and an immigrant families group, have singled out ARIS as a line item that should be first on the chopping block. In terms of slicing jobs, the accountability office, which has been ballooning in size, partly in order to manage ARIS, is an easy target. (Right now the Department of Education lists nine job openings in the accountability office.)

The administration will argue that without ARIS, the department could not execute its innovative initiatives. Many people, not just Klein disciples, believe that teachers can improve their craft and raise student performance by looking carefully at student scores on well-designed tests given periodically throughout a school year. I heard the president of decidedly old-guard Teachers College, Susan Fuhrman, endorse this “new way” of teaching just yesterday, at a presentation on entrepreneurship in education.

Plus, ARIS powers the progress reports that are the way the department decides whether schools are succeeding or not. Even department officials will admit the reports are a work in progress. But without them, they would argue, there is absolutely no way to decide whether schools are succeeding or not — no way short of No Child Left Behind, that is.

  • http://nycpublicschoolparents.blogspot.com Patrick J. Sullivan

    I asked Chief Accountability Officer Liebman at the last Panel for Educational Policy meeting how much the Progress Reports cost. He said $750K. So clearly he doesn’t need the $80 million ARIS system or the $80 million in interim assessment contracts to do them. Remember, the Progress Reports are based overwhelmingly on the State ELA and Math tests and not anything from ARIS.

  • http://www.classsizematters.org Leonie Haimson

    The progress reports are a joke and yield highly unreliable results; I am surprised to see that Gotham Schools is the last outpost in NYC outside of the Manhattan Institute and the Tweed building that would even bother to try to argue otherwise.

    We would be far better without these ridiculous reports, that only confuse parents with inacccurate information about the true state of their children’s schools, as well as the entire Accountability initiative, along with their data inquiry teams, the interim assessments, the School Achievement Facilitators, and the entire army of deluded bureaucrats that costs hundreds of millions of dollars and distracts teachers and principals from focusing on what should be their primary goal: teaching and learning.

  • Pogue

    ARIS = A Really Inept System – Computer-wise and DOE-wise.

  • Mr. Benjamin

    First, I agree with all that has been said about the sad state of the ARIS system. But eventually a school district of this magnitude will need a centralized database similar to this.

    And, as the New York Times so effectively illustrated, progress report grades can be manipulated in a number of variables to significantly alter a school’s grade. However, I do find that they contain a good deal of information about a school dependent on the data point used. As for the Quality Reports, I’m a bit more hesitant having seen the unusual procedures that accompany them.

    In no was do I find Ms. Green’s words to be advocating for or against the use of progress reports, as Ms. Haimson alleges. I’m at a loss regarding Ms. Haimson’s assertion.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

46 comments so far today

Events Calendar

Our Twitter Updates

Archives

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr  
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031