GothamSchools — daily independent reporting on NYC public schools

What to watch for at tonight’s Teachers College debate

Our events section is causing some hard choices this week. Tonight there’s a reception for city charter school leaders (starting now!) and also a live debate at Teachers College between Obama and McCain education advisers. For the record, I’m going to hit the charter school happy hour and catch the debate on iTunes.

Here’s what I’ll be looking for at the debate: How will Linda Darling-Hammond, the Stanford professor who is advising Obama, represent his education position?

Darling-Hammond is at the center of disagreements over testing and No Child Left Behind in Obama’s inner circle. In the past, when representing Obama’s education positions, she has offered ideas friendly to the old Democratic guard, especially teachers unions. Guest-blogging at the United Federation of Teachers’ Edwize, on the subject of “Why Educators Should Support Barack Obama,” Darling-Hammond promoted Obama’s support for more resources to schools, his willingness to work with teachers unions rather than against them, and his support for a broader approach including health and welfare programs.

Meanwhile, guest-blogging at the new-guard, reform-minded Eduwonk blog, other Obama advisers Jon Schnur and Mike Johnston promoted a very different agenda, including charter schools, new performance pay systems to replace the old seniority-based career ladders, and parental responsibility.

Asked to explain the differences on the record, the advisers always say that there is not a war going on and that Obama’s decision to solicit a diversity of opinions is a good thing. But there is of course the question of what decisions he will make if elected president.

So what I will be looking for tonight is, how will Darling-Hammond communicate Obama’s agenda? In the final presidential debate, when John McCain pushed Obama on the charter school issue, suggesting that he is more serious about reforming America’s schools, Obama pushed back, declaring that he does not follow the teachers union on every matter and saying that he favors the explosive steps Michelle Rhee is taking in Washington D.C.

When McCain’s adviser, Lisa Graham Keegan, pushes Darling-Hammond, how will she respond?

  • http://www.classsizematters.org Leonie Haimson

    I object to the description “reform-minded Eduwonk blog” as though people with opposing points of view about the changes our schools need are not reform-minded. This is like Joel Klein, who tries to label anyone who disagrees with his approach to education as defenders of the status quo.

    Indeed, those who blog on Eduwonk as well as Klein are more in tune with the reigning ideology as expressed in NCLB and elsewhere that all that matters is more “accountability” (read test scores), more autonomy and authority to principals, and more “competition” (read charter schools). I would instead maintain that those of us who believe that we must change classroom conditions on the ground to allow more learning to take place are the real reformers.

Tips, questions, feedback?

Contact us at .

Follow GothamSchools

RSS

Feb. 10: You’re invited!

Chalk It Up

Recent Comments

44 comments so far today

Our Twitter Updates

  • She is now surrounded by community officers and security guards and she has calmed. 5 mins ago
  • Occupy protesters left long ago but one woman has managed to disrupt the panel discussion with her persistent yelling http://t.co/hNiSvXll 5 mins ago
  • Ghubemi okotieuro, BK rep, looks exasperated by a woman in the second row as he questions Marc sternberg. 9 mins ago
  • a lengthy conversation on CTE schools. DOE is closing 3; they will open 12 new in next 2 years. Shael shows rare emotion in his defense. 17 mins ago
  • Public comment period ends. Moving much faster than what was expected. Most protesters didn't speak and UFT got here too late to sign up. 54 mins ago
  • More updates...

Archives

February 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jan  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829  
?>